A LIGHT-hearted TV advert for Hampshire based Twinings tea in which three white women flirt with a young black American was today cleared of playing on negative racial stereotypes.
The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) said it had decided not to uphold a lone complaint from a viewer who believed the ad suggested black men were sexually promiscuous and existed to provide sexual services for white women.
The complainant, a woman who was not identified by the ASA, alleged that an ad for Lady Grey tea and another for Earl Grey, which also featured the black character, were both offensive and harmful.
In the plug for Earl Grey, Stephen Fry, pictured, is seen behind the counter of a tea shop as the black male, named Tyrone, writes a message on a blackboard informing customers that the drink "puts the zing in your ding-a-ling".
Dismissing the claims of racial bias, an ASA panel described the innuendo used to promote the aromatic beverages as unlikely to cause widespread offence.
The panel observed: "Although we acknowledged the innuendo was mildly sexual, we did not consider that it was reliant on the young man's ethnic origins or a racial stereotype.
advertisement
"We noted the character of Tyrone was shown as an attractive, confident young man... clearly enjoying the attentions of the women.
Confidence-boosting'
"We did not consider that his or the women's enjoyment of the situation implied that his character was there simply to provide sexual services for white women, but rather that he was a young man enjoying the confidence-boosting attentions of a group of women.
"We considered that Tyrone was shown as a positive character and, because neither ad was reliant on race for its humour, viewers generally were unlikely to believe the ads implied that black men were promiscuous or there to provide sexual services for white women."
Andover-based Twinings, which traces its history back to 1706, defended the ads, which first aired in October 2006, against the claim of racism.
The firm's advertising agency, Lowe, informed the ASA that the black character had been chosen as the "perfect foil" for Fry.
"We did not consider that his or the women's enjoyment of the situation implied that his character was there simply to provide sexual services for white women, but rather that he was a young man enjoying the confidence-boosting attentions of a group of WHITE women."
There, fixed it.
"We did not consider that his or the women's enjoyment of the situation implied that his character was there simply to provide sexual services for white women, but rather that he was a young man enjoying the confidence-boosting attentions of a group of WHITE women."
Posted by: Miss Grey, Hampton Court on 2:40pm Thu 27 Mar 08
For pity sake, I assumed this was an 'advert' for TEA, lasting all of 1 minute...... surely it's nothing to do with the colour of anyones skin !!!! .... I'm surprised this 'complainant' didn't maybe mention that due to Mr Frys accent, that this is 'obviously' a brand of tea aimed at the 'upper' class...... IT'S ONLY AN ADVERT, NOT REAL LIFE.
For pity sake, I assumed this was an 'advert' for TEA, lasting all of 1 minute...... surely it's nothing to do with the colour of anyones skin !!!! .... I'm surprised this 'complainant' didn't maybe mention that due to Mr Frys accent, that this is 'obviously' a brand of tea aimed at the 'upper' class...... IT'S ONLY AN ADVERT, NOT REAL LIFE.
Posted by: John, Southampton on 11:02pm Thu 27 Mar 08
Some people really do need to wind their necks in, this advert may have a slight sexual twist to it, but is it in any way racist? No. I can imagine someone short of a few quid and decided to get on their high-horse and draw attention to themselves....pathet
ic.
Some people really do need to wind their necks in, this advert may have a slight sexual twist to it, but is it in any way racist? No. I can imagine someone short of a few quid and decided to get on their high-horse and draw attention to themselves....pathet
ic.
Posted by: Earl Grey, Mrs Miggins Tea Shoppe on 7:02pm Sat 29 Mar 08
Maybe it's the same person who wrote in and complained to Twinings when they started using Stephen Fry in their Tv adverts a few years back. The person was complaining about Twinings choice of celebrity and thought was inappropriate because Stephen Fry is a "well known homosexual". True story.
Maybe it's the same person who wrote in and complained to Twinings when they started using Stephen Fry in their Tv adverts a few years back. The person was complaining about Twinings choice of celebrity and thought was inappropriate because Stephen Fry is a "well known homosexual". True story.
If you liked this article and would like to share it with others on the web who might be searching for good content we've made it easy for you to do it.
At the bottom of all articles, you'll see links to six sites. These sites - commonly called 'social bookmark' or 'social news' sites - have large communities of web users who share and rate interesting, useful and fun things on the web.
Clicking the links will automatically add the address of the story you are reading to one of these sites, letting you share it with others. Each site will ask you to register to share stories. Registration is free and once a member, you can store, recommend and search for stories that interest you.
Print
Email this
Comment
