News RSS Feed


Fluoride debate Tweet with the Daily Echo Financial Crisis Ford's Future in Southampton


Crisis at animal shelter

9:11am Monday 28th April 2008

comment Comments (21)   Have your say »

Photograph of the Author By Jon Reeve »

PADLOCKED gates keeping the public out, security staff guarding the site around the clock and staff fearful for their futures after colleagues were suspended without warning.

It is all a far cry from the happy image of a small charity that for 55 years has been dedicated to caring for and re-homing unwanted and abandoned animals.

Crisis-hit Hampshire charity St Francis Animal Welfare has suddenly closed after dramatic developments in the internal dispute threatening to tear it apart.

Fears have now been raised about the long-term future of the Fair Oak shelter, with some fundraisers telling the Daily Echo they will not be collecting money or food donations for the shelter anymore.

Some St Francis charity boxes have even been removed from display around the county.

However bosses say it is business as usual and there is no doubt over the sanctuary continuing.

A month after the Charity Commission revealed it was investigating complaints about the way the charity was being run, the ruling committee has suspended two of the shelter's four full-time staff.

One of them is the shelter's live-in manager of nearly 30 years, Ann Hillman.

The other suspended worker was escorted from the premises amid an internal investigation into comments posted on the social networking website Facebook.

The committee that runs St Francis was controversially re-elected at an AGM in March, where around 50 apparently paid-up members were barred from entering and having their say.

Police were called to keep the peace at the stormy meeting, with the committee saying it feared it would be hijacked by a rival group trying to gain control of the charity.

Animal welfare In the aftermath of the meeting at Fair Oak Village Hall arguments continued, but the main focus of all concerned was the care of the hundreds of animals at the Mortimers Lane sanctuary.

With the gates suddenly closing on Friday afternoon, the ability to do that - and particularly to re-home pets - has now been called into question.

Only members of the public with pre-arranged appointments are being allowed on to the site.

A source close to the shelter, who has asked not to be named, said staff and supporters of the charity were in shock at the dramatic developments.

"Every single lock has been changed and there are security staff on site 24 hours a day," they said.

"The shelter has been closed for a week at least, but no one is quite sure what else is going to happen. It's disgusting.

"It's going to hit the shelter hard. Obviously it's going to cause money problems.

"There are animals in desperate need of new homes, but that can't happen while the gates are locked."

The charity's constitutional affairs officer, Matthew Myatt said opening has only been temporarily restricted, and the shelter would be back to normal on Friday.

He confirmed investigations are being carried out into "an internal staffing matter", but said it would be unfair on the individuals concerned to discuss details.

"It's business as usual," said Mr Myatt. "The shelter is open to the public by appointment only because we feel we need the staff to be concerned with the animals' welfare without distraction.

"If people want to come, by all means phone and make an appointment, but we've got to put the welfare of the animals first."

Mr Myatt said the future of the shelter, which costs more than £125,000 a year to run, is not in any doubt.

"If there is a small number of people who now feel that because of the action we've taken they don't want to collect for St Francis that is their decision," he said.

"We can't force people to support us, but at the moment we are very solvent. There are absolutely no worries about the future whatsoever."


Your Say YourEcho

St Francis, of Assisi says...
10:22am Mon 28 Apr 08

Get things sorted out ASAP!

Who did the 'escorting off the premises', sounds very dodgy to me.

The committee obviously do not care about animals or they would keep the rehoming programme running, after the psuedo-riot that was reported at the St Francis AGM via the Echo recently, it makes you wonder what motives and direction the committee has, sounds like Captain Mainwaring from Dads Army is running things!

Robert, says...
10:44am Mon 28 Apr 08

This place follows the Robert Mugabe School of Business Organisation. Nuff said on that.

You read of outrageous things happening in the affairs of capitalist organisations. But animal charities can be ten times worse.

Robert, says...
10:48am Mon 28 Apr 08

Put the management of this place into the hands of Robert Mugabe. It will be a big improvement.

robert, says...
10:53am Mon 28 Apr 08

Put Robert Mugabe in charge here. It will be a big improvement.

Robert Mugabe, On a farm says...
11:12am Mon 28 Apr 08

Hey?

James, Hampshire says...
11:19am Mon 28 Apr 08

As a source close to, yet still impartial, I am sure that there are a number of employment rights issues that have been broken here. The actions taken by the committee seem to point to serious mismanagement or disrepute by the workers; yet until this committee was appointed, there have been absolutely no event ever to question the integrity of this charity.

I can fully understand the public perception of the shelter changing for the worse and subsequent funding reducing, but I would urge people to make rational opinions based on their experiences of the shelter, not on that of hearsay.

The animals remain unaffected by these petty, internal squabbles and it is a shame that these grievances are being aired in public; it surely will do absolutely no good for the shelter at all.

NB. I have no doubt that this forum will turn into a shouting match with two very distinct sides…the ‘animal rights protestors’ and those who will be looking to berate the shelter; I wonder if these groups can remain rational in their arguments?

Cat Owner, says...
12:12pm Mon 28 Apr 08

I have had many a cat from St Francis, always been polite and well manered.

(the cats that is)

Animal lover, southampton says...
12:17pm Mon 28 Apr 08

I help out at the shelter at weekends, I have been away for a couple of weeks, I only found out yesterday that there has been problems, it is a shame, I just feel sorry for the animals if anything happens. I am still going to go a visit as its not the animals fault. Reason that some of the animals are there is because there are some stupid people out there who don't know how to care and look after the animals.
I hope that things get sorted out soon.

angry local, says...
12:50pm Mon 28 Apr 08

I have heard that they will be selling the land for housing

James, Hampshire says...
1:02pm Mon 28 Apr 08

angry local wrote:
I have heard that they will be selling the land for housing
Interesting...I could well believe this. Without spreading rumor, it would certainly fit with a newly appointed commitee who appear to have very little emotional commitment to the shelter.

Curiously, where did you hear this?

Mrs. De Pointe, says...
2:16pm Mon 28 Apr 08

Sounds like they need Robert Mugabe to sort them out.

Lisa, Hythe says...
4:07pm Mon 28 Apr 08

is the summer fayre still on?
copied from the website:

Sunday 1st June 2008 - 2pm to 5pm - Summer Open Day - at our shelter in Mortimer's Lane. A great day out for all the family. Many amusements, games and stalls, a bouncy castle for the kids as well as live music in our BBQ and refreshments area! You will get the chance to see the many animals needing new homes, as well as our permanent residents

Angry Local, says...
4:35pm Mon 28 Apr 08

James wrote:
angry local wrote: I have heard that they will be selling the land for housing
Interesting...I could well believe this. Without spreading rumor, it would certainly fit with a newly appointed commitee who appear to have very little emotional commitment to the shelter. Curiously, where did you hear this?
A pixie told me on the way to Eragons house for dinner with a Elk.

paul, soton says...
5:58pm Mon 28 Apr 08

I hope that the summer fayre is on because promised the grandchildren a trip down there to see the animals

Animal Lover2, Southampton says...
7:54pm Mon 28 Apr 08

James wrote:
angry local wrote: I have heard that they will be selling the land for housing
Interesting...I could well believe this. Without spreading rumor, it would certainly fit with a newly appointed commitee who appear to have very little emotional commitment to the shelter. Curiously, where did you hear this?
I think this could just be a case of chinese whispers as my understanding is that the charitys commissions bought the land and it is only them who have the authority to sell the land if the shelter was ever to go under.

I could be wrong, but that is how I understood it.

auntie_ethel, southampton says...
8:29am Tue 29 Apr 08

As an impartial observer to all this, it would seem those who are currently in charge are quite happy to see it 'go to the wall'. If that were to happen, which person(s) would stand to gain from its demise ?.

me, southampton says...
9:19am Tue 29 Apr 08

why oh why is it there is so many cats to be re homed yet when i try to get one i get told no way... all because i live in a ground floor flat

Sue Robson, Woolston says...
12:43pm Tue 29 Apr 08

First: To answer the previous post, I got one of my cats from St Francis and I lived in a ground floor flat at the time. They took all circumstances into account.
Second: I too am a volunteer helper at St Francis, going there once a week to keep the elderly cats company. I didn't know anything about this trouble either. The centre is wonderful, everyone I've had contact with is dedicated, and we must continue to support it. We don't know the full story yet, obviously. We should still donate and bring food and supplies to help, for the sake of the animals, and wait and see what happens and if later we find that any of the stories are true that may cause the place to close we must then fight to keep it open and running as it has for 50 years .

resident, says...
5:57pm Tue 29 Apr 08

Bit concerning, if they are having these problems. Matthew Myatt is a Candidate in the elections in Eastleigh. Not a trust worthy candidate if you ask me.

SURPORTER, EASTLEIGH says...
1:25pm Thu 1 May 08

I am deeply concerned by the comments made by MR MYATT and find his statement about not being concerned that businesses are removing the charity collecting box,s from their counters and removing the gift collection points incredibly naive.Less than 2 years ago ST Francis made an URGENT appeal for funding to enable the charity to continue with the excellent work Ann Hillman her staff and team of voluntary workers do.If this is MR MYATTS thinking, when every penny is vitally important to maintaining the running of ANY charity, I question should he be the charitys constitutional affairs officer ???

Fred Bassett, Bishopstoke says...
10:23am Wed 28 May 08

I can honestly say that I know nothing of the politics of the charity.
What I do know is that Ann, her staff and volunteers at the centre have always put animals first. I have not just received a loving pet from St. Francis but also ongoing help and support with caring for a rescue dog.
I can only thank Ann and her team for their vast knowledge of how to help and put the welfare of animals first. I hope the charity can get over these difficulties and the people involved, can be allowed to carry on with what they do best - Caring for Animals!

Your sayYourEcho

comment Add your comment

Register for a FREE Daily Echo account and you can have your say on today's news and sport by adding comments on articles we publish. The best comments may even get published in the paper.

Please register now or sign in below to continue.




Forgotten your password?
Video News Food & Restaurant Reviews

Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »