Send us your pictures and video by text, email or by uploading. Click here to find out how. »
8:48am Monday 25th August 2008
Comments (124) Have your say »
ICE campaigners have been told they need to show operators a city rink could be a commercial success on its own because the council will not subsidise one.
The council's finance boss said the council was doing all it can to facilitate the return of a permanent rink to the city after 20 years.
But Councillor Jeremy Moulton said it would be up to developers to make the dream come true.
"If the market is willing to build and run an ice rink all it has to do if find a site and get planning permission," he said.
He was speaking after scores of campaigners marched through Southampton calling on the city council to finally replace the Top Rank ice rink which closed in the city 20 years ago.
They also presented a Daily Echo-backed petition signed by more than 5,000 campaigners also showing their support for a rink.
Cllr Moulton said the Tories had done more than any previous administration to help bring it about, including putting money aside for feasibility work and talks with operators and developers.
But he said council estimates suggested a city centre rink would require a council subsidy of at least £1m which was "unaffordable".
He ruled out selling land cheaply for schemes that offered no guarantees such as a proposed £60m ice rink complex for St Mary's Road.
Cllr Moulton said if the cash-strapped council was to spend money or subsidise a rink frontline line services, such as road repairs, bin collections and social services, would face cuts.
"If we offer subsidises, something else has to give. It's not a top priority when it comes to spending.
"If we get into the habit of underwriting facilities like this, what's next?"
Cllr Moulton said talks with operators and developers suggested a viable commercial rink would have to be part of a larger leisure or retail complex.
He added: "The more that local people can express desire for an ice rink to leisure operators the more chance there is.
"We will continue our dialogues and are doing all everything we can to facilitate a deal."
live local, southampton says...
10:00am Mon 25 Aug 08
Sunny Saint, says...
10:29am Mon 25 Aug 08
southy, redbridge says...
11:21am Mon 25 Aug 08
George, says...
12:04pm Mon 25 Aug 08
southy wrote:No, Southy, it isn't 5000-0. As I said on another story, there wasn't any petition for people against the idea. Stop making up statistics for this proven dead duck
live local, southampton there is land that could be used, test playing fields on the west side of the M271 next to the echo office
Sunny Saint they was there in name 5000 to 0,tower park ice rink at poole makes a very large profit there is no lost
southy, redbridge says...
12:21pm Mon 25 Aug 08
southy, redbridge says...
1:41pm Mon 25 Aug 08
southy, redbridge says...
2:07pm Mon 25 Aug 08
listen, southampton says...
2:42pm Mon 25 Aug 08
southy, redbridge says...
2:51pm Mon 25 Aug 08
George, says...
3:08pm Mon 25 Aug 08
southy wrote:Utter nonsense
George on it is 0 till the no vote can get of there butt and start a no petition it is simple really 5000 to 0
THE BRICK, @THE ICE RINK says...
3:08pm Mon 25 Aug 08
THE BRICK, @THE ICE RINK says...
3:10pm Mon 25 Aug 08
George wrote:Go on George, take up the challenge and lets see what support you get.
southy wrote:Utter nonsense
George on it is 0 till the no vote can get of there butt and start a no petition it is simple really 5000 to 0
George, says...
3:11pm Mon 25 Aug 08
THE BRICK wrote:Read it and weep? Read what and weep? If you seriously think that the result of some game is more meaningful to your campaign than the actual facts of the matter, you're utterly blind. Your demands were not met. Read THAT and weep
I see the neggies are back with their sniping remarks because they know jack.
British Army Blades 3
Southampton Vikings 7
Read it and weep guys, we never give up.
Good on you southy, let em' have it.
THE BRICK, @THE ICE RINK says...
3:14pm Mon 25 Aug 08
George wrote:Georges duck has been killed, plucked, cooked and eaten.
southy wrote:No, Southy, it isn't 5000-0. As I said on another story, there wasn't any petition for people against the idea. Stop making up statistics for this proven dead duck
live local, southampton there is land that could be used, test playing fields on the west side of the M271 next to the echo office
Sunny Saint they was there in name 5000 to 0,tower park ice rink at poole makes a very large profit there is no lost
southy, redbridge says...
3:15pm Mon 25 Aug 08
listen wrote:this is true its called short term thinking and the quick buck.
Why don\'t these people use some common sense. Its simple, not gunna be built as there is not enough money to be be made out of it. Bet even the campaigners would only use it once a month tops. All our land is gunna be used for flats and hotels as thats what developers make money from. Its up to the council to stop this but ofcourse our council have extremely low asperations. Unfortunate but true.
THE BRICK, @THE ICE RINK says...
3:18pm Mon 25 Aug 08
George wrote:You know nothing about the campaign except what you read in the media, little do you really know what is happenning.
THE BRICK wrote:Read it and weep? Read what and weep? If you seriously think that the result of some game is more meaningful to your campaign than the actual facts of the matter, you're utterly blind. Your demands were not met. Read THAT and weep
I see the neggies are back with their sniping remarks because they know jack.
British Army Blades 3
Southampton Vikings 7
Read it and weep guys, we never give up.
Good on you southy, let em' have it.
George, says...
3:18pm Mon 25 Aug 08
THE BRICK wrote:Then why has your idea been turned down by the council? Sorry, you're making yourself out to be an utter buffoon now. Claiming some victory when your campaign has quite clearly failed just proves that you had no idea what you were talking about in the first place. How is it 5000-0? That would suggest that there are only 5000 people in the city.
George wrote:Georges duck has been killed, plucked, cooked and eaten.
southy wrote:No, Southy, it isn't 5000-0. As I said on another story, there wasn't any petition for people against the idea. Stop making up statistics for this proven dead duck
live local, southampton there is land that could be used, test playing fields on the west side of the M271 next to the echo office
Sunny Saint they was there in name 5000 to 0,tower park ice rink at poole makes a very large profit there is no lost
Still a big fat zero whatever way you want to see it.
5000+ to USS
George, says...
3:19pm Mon 25 Aug 08
THE BRICK wrote:Oh, so one of Southampton's other city councils is going ahead with the idea, are they? You've failed with this stage, you might be able to find a private developer interested, but there's little point coming on here rubbishing everybody for saying this hasn't worked, when they're clearly right
George wrote:You know nothing about the campaign except what you read in the media, little do you really know what is happenning.
THE BRICK wrote:Read it and weep? Read what and weep? If you seriously think that the result of some game is more meaningful to your campaign than the actual facts of the matter, you're utterly blind. Your demands were not met. Read THAT and weep
I see the neggies are back with their sniping remarks because they know jack.
British Army Blades 3
Southampton Vikings 7
Read it and weep guys, we never give up.
Good on you southy, let em' have it.
Hahaha, keep taking the pills George.
George, says...
3:21pm Mon 25 Aug 08
southy wrote:No, it isn't up to the "no" voters to start their own petition. They've already got their way, the council will not be building an ice rink. I don't know how to simplify it any further. If the "no" voters have "lost", where is the ice rink they failed to prevent?
listen wrote:this is true its called short term thinking and the quick buck.
Why don\'t these people use some common sense. Its simple, not gunna be built as there is not enough money to be be made out of it. Bet even the campaigners would only use it once a month tops. All our land is gunna be used for flats and hotels as thats what developers make money from. Its up to the council to stop this but ofcourse our council have extremely low asperations. Unfortunate but true.
we got to many hotels now and i not heard of one yet that has been filled up even for 1 day.there houses flats and apartments in southampton that can not be sold some places have been empty for 6 plus more years.
and george its up to the no voters to start there own petition,not the yes voters to do it for them 5000 to 0
southy, redbridge says...
3:22pm Mon 25 Aug 08
George, says...
3:23pm Mon 25 Aug 08
THE BRICK wrote:What's the point in me actively campaigning for something that
George wrote:Go on George, take up the challenge and lets see what support you get.
southy wrote:Utter nonsense
George on it is 0 till the no vote can get of there butt and start a no petition it is simple really 5000 to 0
George 0
USS 5000
George, says...
3:25pm Mon 25 Aug 08
southy wrote:Question: is the council going to build you an ice rink? Answer yes or no, don't bleat on about what you think should happen, or present false evidence to prove that the actual outcome is a figment of our imaginations. Is the council building you an ice rink or not?
george the council has not turn it down at all its just that the developers who want to build an ice rink are beening out bid at the auction for land,
5000-0
THE BRICK, @THE ICE RINK says...
3:25pm Mon 25 Aug 08
George wrote:Yeah, thanks for the insult. The 'morons' got over 5000 supporters and a great hockey game which they won against the Army,
southy wrote:No, it isn't up to the "no" voters to start their own petition. They've already got their way, the council will not be building an ice rink. I don't know how to simplify it any further. If the "no" voters have "lost", where is the ice rink they failed to prevent?
listen wrote:this is true its called short term thinking and the quick buck.
Why don\'t these people use some common sense. Its simple, not gunna be built as there is not enough money to be be made out of it. Bet even the campaigners would only use it once a month tops. All our land is gunna be used for flats and hotels as thats what developers make money from. Its up to the council to stop this but ofcourse our council have extremely low asperations. Unfortunate but true.
we got to many hotels now and i not heard of one yet that has been filled up even for 1 day.there houses flats and apartments in southampton that can not be sold some places have been empty for 6 plus more years.
and george its up to the no voters to start there own petition,not the yes voters to do it for them 5000 to 0
Jesus, these people are behaving like utter morons. Claiming victory in the face of a total defeat
George, says...
3:29pm Mon 25 Aug 08
THE BRICK wrote:This just proves how utterly and hopelessly confused you are on this issue. That your team won a game is good - well done, sincerely - but it has absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with your campaign. What are you missing? If I said I scored over 50,000,000 on Donkey Kong last night (I didn't) would that have any bearing?
George wrote:Yeah, thanks for the insult. The 'morons' got over 5000 supporters and a great hockey game which they won against the Army,
southy wrote:No, it isn't up to the "no" voters to start their own petition. They've already got their way, the council will not be building an ice rink. I don't know how to simplify it any further. If the "no" voters have "lost", where is the ice rink they failed to prevent?
listen wrote:this is true its called short term thinking and the quick buck.
Why don\'t these people use some common sense. Its simple, not gunna be built as there is not enough money to be be made out of it. Bet even the campaigners would only use it once a month tops. All our land is gunna be used for flats and hotels as thats what developers make money from. Its up to the council to stop this but ofcourse our council have extremely low asperations. Unfortunate but true.
we got to many hotels now and i not heard of one yet that has been filled up even for 1 day.there houses flats and apartments in southampton that can not be sold some places have been empty for 6 plus more years.
and george its up to the no voters to start there own petition,not the yes voters to do it for them 5000 to 0
Jesus, these people are behaving like utter morons. Claiming victory in the face of a total defeat
George still has a big fat has zero
southy, redbridge says...
3:30pm Mon 25 Aug 08
George wrote:george the council dont build them they just give planing permission.and they have giving an out line permission a few times to developers if they can aquire the land
southy wrote:Question: is the council going to build you an ice rink? Answer yes or no, don't bleat on about what you think should happen, or present false evidence to prove that the actual outcome is a figment of our imaginations. Is the council building you an ice rink or not?
george the council has not turn it down at all its just that the developers who want to build an ice rink are beening out bid at the auction for land,
5000-0
George, says...
3:33pm Mon 25 Aug 08
southy wrote:So not only do you make up statistics, you are also unable to answer a simple yes/no question. Are you an MP?
George wrote:george the council dont build them they just give planing permission.and they have giving an out line permission a few times to developers if they can aquire the land
southy wrote:Question: is the council going to build you an ice rink? Answer yes or no, don't bleat on about what you think should happen, or present false evidence to prove that the actual outcome is a figment of our imaginations. Is the council building you an ice rink or not?
george the council has not turn it down at all its just that the developers who want to build an ice rink are beening out bid at the auction for land,
5000-0
THE BRICK, @THE ICE RINK says...
3:33pm Mon 25 Aug 08
George wrote:Another insult, and the 'majority' is your invention, your perception.
THE BRICK wrote:What's the point in me actively campaigning for something that
George wrote:Go on George, take up the challenge and lets see what support you get.
southy wrote:Utter nonsense
George on it is 0 till the no vote can get of there butt and start a no petition it is simple really 5000 to 0
George 0
USS 5000
a) I don't want to happen
b) Has already happened
?
You fail to remember that I actually would like an ice rink, I just don't think it's going to happen. Plus, this story clearly states the council have said no. Me campaigning after the fact would be even more pointless than you ranting repeatedly that 5000 people out of 200,000 is a "majority"
Fool
George, says...
3:35pm Mon 25 Aug 08
THE BRICK wrote:Idiotic beyond belief, to be honest. Give up, you clealy live in cloud cuckoo land. The result of your game is 100% irrelevant.
George wrote:Another insult, and the 'majority' is your invention, your perception.
THE BRICK wrote:What's the point in me actively campaigning for something that
George wrote:Go on George, take up the challenge and lets see what support you get.
southy wrote:Utter nonsense
George on it is 0 till the no vote can get of there butt and start a no petition it is simple really 5000 to 0
George 0
USS 5000
a) I don't want to happen
b) Has already happened
?
You fail to remember that I actually would like an ice rink, I just don't think it's going to happen. Plus, this story clearly states the council have said no. Me campaigning after the fact would be even more pointless than you ranting repeatedly that 5000 people out of 200,000 is a "majority"
Fool
Still a zero compared to our 5000+ oh and our 7 goals that was hard fought for by the Mighty Southampton Vikings.
southy, redbridge says...
3:37pm Mon 25 Aug 08
THE BRICK, @THE ICE RINK says...
3:40pm Mon 25 Aug 08
George wrote:Gerogie, we have NEVER asked the council to build us an ice rink. Your perception that only you believe. The petition said QUOTE call upon the Southampton City Council to actively seek and assist interested parties in developing a new ice rink without any further delay
southy wrote:So not only do you make up statistics, you are also unable to answer a simple yes/no question. Are you an MP?
George wrote:george the council dont build them they just give planing permission.and they have giving an out line permission a few times to developers if they can aquire the land
southy wrote:Question: is the council going to build you an ice rink? Answer yes or no, don't bleat on about what you think should happen, or present false evidence to prove that the actual outcome is a figment of our imaginations. Is the council building you an ice rink or not?
george the council has not turn it down at all its just that the developers who want to build an ice rink are beening out bid at the auction for land,
5000-0
southy, redbridge says...
3:50pm Mon 25 Aug 08
southy, redbridge says...
3:55pm Mon 25 Aug 08
THE BRICK, @THE ICE RINK says...
3:57pm Mon 25 Aug 08
southy wrote:Dead right southy, Colin Warburg was the developer and that just goes to show that the council are the ones opposing development not the developers.
goerge look in the echo item dated 9:37am Wednesday 20th August 2008 head line;Council resolute over East Park
there a little bit
from this item
Despite initial estimates that the deal would be wrapped up in a couple of months, the council is still negotiatingwith a housebuilder, understood to be Lovell, more than a year after it won an auction for the site - beating a bid from local developers to build an £80m ice rink complex there.
southy, redbridge says...
4:00pm Mon 25 Aug 08
THE BRICK, @THE ICE RINK says...
4:11pm Mon 25 Aug 08
southy wrote:The petition is still on the website if you are interested and they are still being sent to the council.
and he not the only one that been getting out bid at the auction by house builders
Common Sense, A local Ice Rink says...
4:33pm Mon 25 Aug 08
southy wrote:The ice rink at Tower Park closed years ago and was replaced by the Bingo!!! You should pay more attention when you are there "every month!" see :http://www.towerpar
the ice rink at poole is in the same complex tower park,i know i take people there once a 1 mth, the ice rink in bornmouth was closed down when tower park ice rink open up there was agreement between the 2 councils to have the one to service both areas because the one in bornmouth a developer wanted the land for building homes.the site do not list all that is there like it only say about the 1 swimming pool but there is 2 swimming pools there
southy, redbridge says...
4:53pm Mon 25 Aug 08
Contributor, says...
8:28pm Mon 25 Aug 08
George wrote:Nice humour!
THE BRICK wrote:Idiotic beyond belief, to be honest. Give up, you clealy live in cloud cuckoo land. The result of your game is 100% irrelevant.
George wrote:Another insult, and the \'majority\' is your invention, your perception.
THE BRICK wrote:What\'s the point in me actively campaigning for something that
George wrote:Go on George, take up the challenge and lets see what support you get.
southy wrote:Utter nonsense
George on it is 0 till the no vote can get of there butt and start a no petition it is simple really 5000 to 0
George 0
USS 5000
a) I don\'t want to happen
b) Has already happened
?
You fail to remember that I actually would like an ice rink, I just don\'t think it\'s going to happen. Plus, this story clearly states the council have said no. Me campaigning after the fact would be even more pointless than you ranting repeatedly that 5000 people out of 200,000 is a \"majority\"
Fool
Still a zero compared to our 5000+ oh and our 7 goals that was hard fought for by the Mighty Southampton Vikings.
*shakes head in disbelief that this person can even do their own shoelaces up*
southy, redbridge says...
8:39pm Mon 25 Aug 08
THE BRICK, @THE ICE RINK says...
8:55pm Mon 25 Aug 08
Contributor wrote:
"The Lost Cause Brigade, of wishful thinkers, consistently try to blind with warm fuzzy anecdotal stuff or cite 100% incorrect facts. Totally ignoring reality they bounce back from whatever rational, intelligent, irrefutable, indisputable observations you put in front of them. Heavily into denial and deaf to reason, they will sorely try your patience! I'm not sure they are worth the effort, as they appear to cast themselves as die-hard lemmings. "
live local, southampton says...
3:29am Tue 26 Aug 08
Mental Mickey, Tatchbury says...
9:35am Mon 25 Aug 08