County council rules out badger cull on land owned by Hampshire

Daily Echo: Badgers are safe from culling on land owned by Hampshire County Council. Badgers are safe from culling on land owned by Hampshire County Council.

LEAVE our badgers alone.

That was the message from Hampshire councillors who overwhelmingly backed a motion to ban badger culling on county-owned land.

It comes after pilot culls have been launched to destroy 5,000 badgers in Somerset and Gloucestershire to curb the spread of Bovine TB in cattle.

Lib Dem councillor Rupert Kyrle put forward the motion at a full council meeting in Winchester.

His motion argued that culling was not a proven solution to the TB problem and that more research was needed for vaccinations.

After the vote, Cllr Kyrle, who represents Botley and Hedge End, said: “This is a great day for badgers in Hampshire. We all want to see a real solution to prevent the spread of bovine TB across our countryside, but it is not right that badgers should be singled out in this way.

“We must protect our countryside, and that includes the species that make it their home.”

The number of recorded cases of TB in cows is steadily increasing, with seven cases in 2009, 12 in 2010, 19 in 2011, 21 in 2012 and 33 as of June 2013. No trace has been found in Hampshire badgers.

The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) does not know how many badgers there are in Hampshire, but it is thought there are 250,000 nationwide.

Related links

But Sandra Nichols, county adviser for the National Farmers’ Union (NFU), said the problem was not serious enough yet to warrant a cull.

She said: “It’s highly unlikely we will see badger culling in Hampshire, because the numbers are not high enough and herd restriction controls will help to keep incidents low.

“If the worst comes to the worst we would support a cull, because we have to get a handle on this disease.”

Susannah Mannerings, who runs Attwoods Drove dairy farm in Compton, near Winchester, slammed the council’s decision.

She said: “It’s a cowardly way out and a waste of time, because no one is even thinking of a cull in this area yet.

If badgers did have TB they have to be culled.”

Meanwhile, Hampshire & Isle of Wight Wildlife Trust is trying to raise £45,000 for badger vaccinations on 40 setts across 16 nature reserves by 2014.

Hampshire wildlife expert Chris Packham has also criticised culling as “shameful”.

Comments (4)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

11:12am Wed 25 Sep 13

StevenAus says...

Good. This is a knee jerk solution and so sad to see these beautiful creatures destroyed int his callous way. A solution to Tb is needed but this is not the answer.
Good. This is a knee jerk solution and so sad to see these beautiful creatures destroyed int his callous way. A solution to Tb is needed but this is not the answer. StevenAus
  • Score: 21

11:43am Wed 25 Sep 13

Harrisgo says...

The cull is a disgusting political stunt to appease a small but powerful lobby, it needs to be ended and the so-called "environment secretary" who seems intent only on slaughtering badgers, concreting over the countryside and cutting down forests needs replacing with someone who isn't so corrupt.
The cull is a disgusting political stunt to appease a small but powerful lobby, it needs to be ended and the so-called "environment secretary" who seems intent only on slaughtering badgers, concreting over the countryside and cutting down forests needs replacing with someone who isn't so corrupt. Harrisgo
  • Score: 17

1:03pm Wed 25 Sep 13

housewife says...

Vaccination will mean that farmers can no longer blame badgers for their own poor husbandry practices.
..
They get recompensed for destroyed cattle so have no financial incentive to behave properly.
Vaccination will mean that farmers can no longer blame badgers for their own poor husbandry practices. .. They get recompensed for destroyed cattle so have no financial incentive to behave properly. housewife
  • Score: 13

5:43pm Wed 25 Sep 13

Dresnez says...

Delighted that Hampshire County Council have made this decision. Farmers in a 'clean' area test for TB every four years. This could be done annually, catching it earlier would stop the spread. Farmers who sell unpasteurized milk have to test annually.

They say that badgers are responsible for bovine TB, but only 1.7% of badgers carry the disease. They also say that bovine TB decimating our herds. To decimate would suggest that 10% of cattle are culled, but only 0.5% of the National herd are slaughtered annually.

Compensation is paid to the farmer and the animal still goes into the food chain, demonstrating the hypocrisy in the claim that bovine TB is a significant risk to human health. Also there are bovine TB outbreaks in areas where there are no badgers. More research is needed into farming methods.
Delighted that Hampshire County Council have made this decision. Farmers in a 'clean' area test for TB every four years. This could be done annually, catching it earlier would stop the spread. Farmers who sell unpasteurized milk have to test annually. They say that badgers are responsible for bovine TB, but only 1.7% of badgers carry the disease. They also say that bovine TB decimating our herds. To decimate would suggest that 10% of cattle are culled, but only 0.5% of the National herd are slaughtered annually. Compensation is paid to the farmer and the animal still goes into the food chain, demonstrating the hypocrisy in the claim that bovine TB is a significant risk to human health. Also there are bovine TB outbreaks in areas where there are no badgers. More research is needed into farming methods. Dresnez
  • Score: 9

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree