Send us your pictures and video by text, email or by uploading. Click here to find out how. »
9:27am Saturday 24th May 2008
TWO bus companies could face fines totalling hundreds of thousands of pounds after almost one in seven of their services in Hampshire were late or unreliable.
A survey found 11.3 per cent of Solent Blue Line buses, 18.3 per cent of its rebranded Marchwood Motorways buses and 13.4 per cent of First buses turned up early, arrived too late or failed to show up.
The companies were hauled before a public inquiry and could face respective fines of up to £90,000 and £229,000.
Managers blamed high volumes of traffic, roadworks, illegally parked cars, sick drivers, and even slow passengers as "reasonable excuses" for some of the punctuality problems.
Checks carried out by the Vehicle and Operator Services Agency between July and November last year found 100 out of 713 Solent Blue Line journeys failed to meet required targets, while 121 of First's 903 journeys were below standard.
Solent Blue Line bosses said council roadworks along Millbrook Road and around Redbridge, and heavy freight lorries, had caused unforeseen "critical delays".
Poorly parked cars, pedestrians "unpredictably" using a crossing at Portswood Road and St Deny's Road, were said to be responsible for further delays.
Solent Blue Line operations director Andrew Wickham explained that the £3million acquisition in October 2006 of debt-laden Marchwood Motorways by Solent Blue Line's parent company Go Ahead had led to problems.
Outgoing owner and boss Peter Osborne retired leaving a management team that "wasn't up to the task", Mr Wickham said, and it took time for replacements to turn things around.
Managing director of First, Richard Soper, said: "South-ampton's roads are running at near-full capacity. It only takes the smallest thing to go wrong and the whole system breaks down."
Solent Blue Line runs 71 buses while its Marchwood operation runs 17 buses alongside 26 coaches, while First Bus has 373 buses, 127 of which operate in Southampton.
The inquiry was welcomed by Southampton Pensioners' Forum, which represents the majority of the services' users.
Spokesman John Nixon said: "There have been problems with buses in Southampton for some time now so I welcome this inquiry.
"Pensioners rely on buses to get around and something has to be done to make sure services are up to scratch."
gorf, soton says...
10:01am Sat 24 May 08
George, says...
10:29am Sat 24 May 08
mike, southampton says...
11:00am Sat 24 May 08
nuthead, southampton says...
11:08am Sat 24 May 08
Grumpy, Southampton says...
11:10am Sat 24 May 08
Grumpy, Southampton says...
11:28am Sat 24 May 08
John, soton says...
11:51am Sat 24 May 08
hulla, baloo says...
12:09pm Sat 24 May 08
DSM, Winchester says...
12:17pm Sat 24 May 08
Don, s'oton says...
1:05pm Sat 24 May 08
Blue Star Driver, Eastleigh says...
1:12pm Sat 24 May 08
BS1 user, 715-280 says...
1:51pm Sat 24 May 08
DSM wrote:You are talking rubbish DSM.. If this happened the driver would be caught and sacked. Now run along and get a life instead of trying to create some sort of online complaint forum.
So what is the excuse for leaving early, then? Many times I have arrived at the bus stop to catch the Bluestar 1 in the evening only to find it has already gone, five or six minutes early.
brigsy, C/Ford says...
2:41pm Sat 24 May 08
DSM wrote:Thro experience it's not leaving 3 to 8 mins early, it's leaving 15 mins late. The bus you think you have have just missed is The bus prior tou yours!!!
So what is the excuse for leaving early, then? Many times I have arrived at the bus stop to catch the Bluestar 1 in the evening only to find it has already gone, five or six minutes early.
beryl, southampton says...
4:05pm Sat 24 May 08
George wrote:perhaps they should use realistic timetables
Reminds me of the incident years ago, somewhere else, where a bus actually went through its entire route without actually stopping to pick up passengers. The driver went on to make transport history by remarking that this was the only way he could stick to the timetable I wish I was a corporation. Then I, too, could simply refuse to accept any responsibility for anything whatsoever, and blame the customer
sotonian, southampton says...
4:07pm Sat 24 May 08
Grumpy wrote:and they wonder why people want to use their cars and not public transport
Outgoing owner and boss Peter Osborne retired leaving a management team that "wasn't up to the task", Mr Wickham said, and it took time for replacements to turn things around. That is a total lie about the former management of Marchwood Motorways. The company worked very well until Blue Line removed the Marchwood management and put in their own incompetent managers who were simply not capable of running a bus service. The first thing they did was to remove the 19 service to Thornhill which is/was needed by the older people to get to the octors at Thornhill Park road. If Blueline had left the Marchwood management in place instead of putting in management who spends more time in the pub than managaging then it would have been ok. Mr Wickham from Blue Line I think you can probably expect a solicitors letter very shortly.
John Martin, says...
4:21pm Sat 24 May 08
Disillusioned, says...
4:23pm Sat 24 May 08
Dave, in a jam says...
4:29pm Sat 24 May 08
mike wrote:If bus lanes were abolished there would'nt be half the problems with conjestion. Buses have too much priority on southamptons roads with often empty bus lanes on most major routes. Take bursledon road before 9am - there is always half a mile of traffic waiting to get into town. I say they should fine the bus companys by opening all bus lanes.
I think most of the problem is with the city traffic planners messing about with traffic lights and making junctions into one lane when there was two
Bollenater, Fareham says...
4:57pm Sat 24 May 08
J Harrison, Thornhill says...
5:32pm Sat 24 May 08
David, says...
5:45pm Sat 24 May 08
Colin Hawken, Southampton says...
6:20pm Sat 24 May 08
Dave, in a jam says...
6:34pm Sat 24 May 08
Bollenater wrote:Bollicknator, I have not missed the point. Public transport is an alternative means of transport. It is choice whether you travel by car, bus, or tractor even. It is a fact that bus lanes cause conjestion and some roads are even giving priority to buses at peak times which adds to this conjestion. Southampton is nowhere near as conjested as say, London where buses (as well as cabs) are the preferred method of transport, therefore bus lanes would be justified.
Dave, you miss the point. Bus lanes serve to allow passengers a quicker journey into town, whilst car users are penalised for adding to the conjestion. What IS needed is a decent park and ride system. Oxford and Bristol can do it.... why can't Southampton? There have been many other posts in this discussion which have been spot-on, though....
Bus driver, Eastleigh says...
6:40pm Sat 24 May 08
Colin Hawken wrote:Well said Colin, 37 years myself :-)
Having read all these comments,I have just one Question. How many of you are ex busdrivers?
I don't mean did you do the job for a fewv weeks while you were waiting for a better paid job to conme along.How many of you,like me and a lot of others,did it for about 30 years or more? Judging by your comments,not many of you. Most of you don't have a clue what you are talking about.
Dave, in a jam says...
7:02pm Sat 24 May 08
Colin Hawken, Southampton says...
7:24pm Sat 24 May 08
mr x, says...
7:54pm Sat 24 May 08
ex so'ton, Abingdon says...
7:57pm Sat 24 May 08
Bob444, 391-905 says...
8:07pm Sat 24 May 08
Colin Hawken wrote:Radio communication?
The one thing I\'ve never understood is when people get on a bus and ask the Driver,\"What happened to the bus in front of you?\" How on earth do they expect the Driver to know about any bus except the one he is driving?
Think about it,it\'s hardly Rocket Science.
Another Bus Driver, Southampton says...
8:13pm Sat 24 May 08
Bus Driver, Shirley says...
8:14pm Sat 24 May 08
Bob444 wrote:The drivers would be on their radios all day then - and they shouldn't really use them in motion anyway!!! Its impossible to track every bus all day, until they get some sort of sat nav and location system into every bus!!
Colin Hawken wrote: The one thing I\'ve never understood is when people get on a bus and ask the Driver,\"What happened to the bus in front of you?\" How on earth do they expect the Driver to know about any bus except the one he is driving? Think about it,it\'s hardly Rocket Science.Radio communication?
Bob, here says...
9:13pm Sat 24 May 08
Bob444 wrote:Idiot
Colin Hawken wrote:Radio communication?
The one thing I\'ve never understood is when people get on a bus and ask the Driver,\"What happened to the bus in front of you?\" How on earth do they expect the Driver to know about any bus except the one he is driving?
Think about it,it\'s hardly Rocket Science.
Ihatebuses, Cloud 9. says...
9:15pm Sat 24 May 08
Dave, Dibden says...
9:53pm Sat 24 May 08
markus, southampton says...
9:53pm Sat 24 May 08
bollenater, says...
10:20pm Sat 24 May 08
Colin Hawken wrote:Didn't say you did... and I'm not hiding behind anyone elses ID either. HTH. HAND.
Whoever is using my name,if you haven\'t got the courage to identify yourself,shut up. I didn\'t send to you either bollenater.
Talya, Soton says...
11:24pm Sat 24 May 08
bollenater, 894-235 says...
11:34pm Sat 24 May 08
Talya wrote:A bus ca be late at the beginning of its route for several reasons.... late arrival from its previous route is one of them.
Unilink aren\'t reliable!! Their buses are ALREADY 5-10 mins late even leaving the National Oceanography centre (beginning of route) and sometimes don\'t even bother going down to the station (U1C on weekends). I waited at the station for what i THOUGHT was the last bus into town, never turned up, I phoned unilink and they said \'oh we cancelled that one\' well why does it say it\'s coming on the board?! We had to escort an older lady on the CityLink because she was worried she\'d get lost changing buses. Not on really. How can the buses already be late at the very beginning of the route? No hope there really.
George B., Soton says...
11:50pm Sat 24 May 08
Bollenater, Fareham says...
7:41am Sun 25 May 08
paul wrote:I bloody hate french polishers, i had to have a table restored about 2 years ago when some benefit claimer burgled my house and stood on it. I say replace them with spanish polishers.
I bloody hate bus drivers, i had to go on public transport about 2 years ago when some benefit claimer stole my car. I say replace them with Polish drivers.
a bus driver, some were in pompey says...
8:34am Sun 25 May 08
Dave wrote:i think that we should have more bus lanes to increase the level of buses that is needed to run a very standred of bus levels with in the city,and more low floor buses
mike wrote: I think most of the problem is with the city traffic planners messing about with traffic lights and making junctions into one lane when there was twoIf bus lanes were abolished there would'nt be half the problems with conjestion. Buses have too much priority on southamptons roads with often empty bus lanes on most major routes. Take bursledon road before 9am - there is always half a mile of traffic waiting to get into town. I say they should fine the bus companys by opening all bus lanes.
kelly, southampton says...
9:24am Sun 25 May 08
troy colmer, southampton says...
9:29am Sun 25 May 08
anon, shirley says...
10:02am Sun 25 May 08
Bambi, says...
10:22am Sun 25 May 08
anon wrote:Utopia? Are you sure that's what you meant? Are you sure you didn't mean dystopia?
I can agree with alot of the comments about the state of the roads in southampton, and the fact that the council have not put money into repairing them. I raised this question with Cllr Gavin Dick through my own ward councilor who had the cabinet post at the time, he was more worried about getting Millbrook road resurfaced, because of the money that the boat show brought into the city then looking at the other roads in the city.
As for park and ride, yes I agree that there should be some form of that, but the surrounding councills use to not be willing to give up some of their land to allow a park and ride scheme to be brought in, for the city. They are anti such things, even though Southampton is the main point of focus for the area, it is the place where a large percentage of people are employed, etc. Perhaps the council needs to take the bull by the horns and impose a congestion charge, just like Ken Livingstone did in London, that has certainly enabled people to move round the capital easier, plus he did not increase the prices on public transport he cut them, and the numbers using it went up, not down as predicted.
Something has to be done to get people out of their cars and on to public transport, perhaps the answer may be to take the buses that run in the city back into council control, and do what they did in Sheffield a few years ago that is have a maximum charge for what ever distance you travel. The problem of transport has to be solved soon, oil is running out, so eventually the petrol car will be no more, and then people will not have a god to bow down to their own little space to go to where they want to go will be gone.
For goods movement we need to be looking to try and move more freight by train, and where possible even waterways, to distribution centres closer to the final destinations, that way we will not need so many large heavy lorries on the roads.
If all public transport, buses, trains, ferries were cheaper to use, and there was a coordinated approach, ie a bus arrives a few minutes before the train to london left, and the same the other way, a few minutes before the ferry left then people would use. And even better if there was some way in which you could have through ticketing so you did not have to stop to purchase another ticket. That is the only way in which we will solve the transport propblems.
I know I am looking at utopia but uptopia is going to have to come soon, and what will the oil gods do then when there is no more oil!!!!!!!!!!!!
satisfied Blue Line user, southampton says...
1:21pm Sun 25 May 08
Ihatebuses wrote:I hate buses is obviously living in cloud cuckoo land not on cloud 9. Blue line charge £12 and First £14 for a weeks travel. So obviously does not park in the city as if he did he would know that for a 9-5 office worker it can cost £8.00+ per day. This means they will be paying £45.00+ per week £180.00 a month just in parking add on petrol and you would be paying at least 3-4 times more than a bus passenger. I hope this makes sense.Ggggrrrr.
Whats the point of fining the bus co\'s? The services will NEVER improve. They don\'t give a flying fc.uk about their passengers, they only care about profits. Check them out on line and see how much profit they make, I did and it will amaze you! It\'s cheaper (still) to take your car to towns and park for a couple of hours than get a bus. It\'s even cheaper with a few people to get a taxi for c.hrists sake, make sense? NO! Gggggrrrr
Bowmore, Southampton says...
1:28pm Sun 25 May 08
left standing, Southampton says...
3:29pm Sun 25 May 08
Ihatebuses, Cloud 9. says...
3:52pm Sun 25 May 08
satisfied Blue Line user wrote:I didn't say I was going to town for the whole week. Read my comment and you might see where you slipped up with you comment. Read and digest!
Ihatebuses wrote: Whats the point of fining the bus co\\\'s? The services will NEVER improve. They don\\\'t give a flying fc.uk about their passengers, they only care about profits. Check them out on line and see how much profit they make, I did and it will amaze you! It\\\'s cheaper (still) to take your car to towns and park for a couple of hours than get a bus. It\\\'s even cheaper with a few people to get a taxi for c.hrists sake, make sense? NO! GggggrrrrI hate buses is obviously living in cloud cuckoo land not on cloud 9. Blue line charge £12 and First £14 for a weeks travel. So obviously does not park in the city as if he did he would know that for a 9-5 office worker it can cost £8.00+ per day. This means they will be paying £45.00+ per week £180.00 a month just in parking add on petrol and you would be paying at least 3-4 times more than a bus passenger. I hope this makes sense.Ggggrrrr.
satisfied Blue line Passenger, Southampton says...
5:45pm Sun 25 May 08
Ihatebuses wrote:I never said you go to town for the week either. What I said was you OBVIOUSLY don't park in town because IF you did you would know the cost of parking and how much petrol you buy each week. Also the cost of car parking costs a minimum of £1.20 per hour and not many people can do all they need to do in that hour,as by the time a parking space has been found and you have got out of car park to start what you need to do you have probably wasted 5-10 mins. I catch the bus about 8am and it is full of city workers be it officer workers or retail staff and I am sure at least one of those would have a car, so they obviously know that it costs less to catch the bus than to park. Car parks are often unmanned and as car crime is quite high now I would not want to leave a car of mine in the city.
satisfied Blue Line user wrote:I didn\'t say I was going to town for the whole week. Read my comment and you might see where you slipped up with you comment. Read and digest!Ihatebuses wrote: Whats the point of fining the bus co\\\\\\\'s? The services will NEVER improve. They don\\\\\\\'t give a flying fc.uk about their passengers, they only care about profits. Check them out on line and see how much profit they make, I did and it will amaze you! It\\\\\\\'s cheaper (still) to take your car to towns and park for a couple of hours than get a bus. It\\\\\\\'s even cheaper with a few people to get a taxi for c.hrists sake, make sense? NO! GggggrrrrI hate buses is obviously living in cloud cuckoo land not on cloud 9. Blue line charge £12 and First £14 for a weeks travel. So obviously does not park in the city as if he did he would know that for a 9-5 office worker it can cost £8.00+ per day. This means they will be paying £45.00+ per week £180.00 a month just in parking add on petrol and you would be paying at least 3-4 times more than a bus passenger. I hope this makes sense.Ggggrrrr.
Bus driver, Southampton says...
5:52pm Sun 25 May 08
Bowmore wrote:Timetables are worked out today how they have always been. 12mph without stopping around the route.
I think part of the problem is when they are creating the timetables. When they time how long it takes for the bus to get from A to B they must do it on a Sunday morning when there is very little traffic and few passengers, Then seem supprised that a 25 min journey actually takes 35min and one bus can't do the round trip once an hour.
They need more realistic timetables and more buses to provide a reliable service.
Sue, Southampton says...
7:13am Mon 26 May 08
gonzo, Soton says...
6:05pm Tue 27 May 08
Bus driver wrote:What a load of rubbish, not sure if this is supposed to be a joke or not. As someone who has worked in Public Transport for a decade or so I certainly didn't go riding a "stagecoach from the victorian period" when I last timetabled a route! I did it by travelling the route lots of times and all times of the day and working out the average times by time band (that includes stop/starting at bus stops).
Bowmore wrote: I think part of the problem is when they are creating the timetables. When they time how long it takes for the bus to get from A to B they must do it on a Sunday morning when there is very little traffic and few passengers, Then seem supprised that a 25 min journey actually takes 35min and one bus can't do the round trip once an hour. They need more realistic timetables and more buses to provide a reliable service.Timetables are worked out today how they have always been. 12mph without stopping around the route. The 12mph comes from the average speed of a stagecoach from the victorian period. This system has been in use since then and still is today with none of todays traffic being taken into account
sid, Southampton says...
7:58pm Mon 2 Jun 08
Enter your postcode, town or place name
Search for jobs with the Daily Echo
Search Now »
Find the right person for you with the Daily Echo
Search Now »
Search for homes with the Daily Echo
Search Now »
Search for cars with the Daily Echo
Search Now »
Wewullywinky, says...
9:59am Sat 24 May 08