- Mobile site
- E-Newsletters
-
- News feed
- Find us on Twitter
@dailyecho
Daily Echo on Twitter
@the_saints
Saints News on Twitter
SceneSouth
Leisure news on Twitter
- Find us on Facebook
Facebook
Daily Echo on Facebook
Opposition plan to derail NHS reforms (From Daily Echo)
When news happens, text SDE and your photos or videos to 80360. Or contact us by email and phone.
MP John Denham aiming to bring down Health and Social Care Bill
11:00am Tuesday 21st February 2012 in News
By Melanie Adams, Health Reporter
Southampton Itchen MP John Denham.
PRESSURE is mounting on the Government as Hampshire politicians prepare to take action to bring down its controversial shake-up of the NHS.
As David Cameron chaired a summit at Downing Street and Health Minister Andrew Lansley faced a barrage of heckling from protestors, Southampton Itchen MP John Denham revealed his plans to derail the Health and Social Care Bill, which is reaching a critical stage in its passage through Parliament.
He will lead an army of health professionals and residents to voice their opposition to the plans at a rally on March 1 at the Sir James Matthews Building at Southampton Solent University.
It will be open for everyone who opposes the bill.
Mr Denham said: “No one voted for this Health Bill and it looks to me like no one wants this bill at all.
The list of healthcare organisations against the bill is growing every week.
“I’m holding this event to allow Southampton residents to send a loud message to David Cameron and Andrew Lansley – drop this damaging, unwanted and unnecessary bill.”
Grass roots Liberal Democrats are also plotting to help derail the bill with activists planning to pile the pressure on Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg at the party’s spring conference next month.
Heading the charge is Martin Tod, who is vice-chairman of Winchester Lib Dems. He has set up a petition calling for the debate at the spring conference.
Mr Tod, who compared the bill to a “dead man walking”, said: “We remain very concerned that the bill is incredibly complicated and disruptive at a time when the NHS needs to be saving large amounts of money.
“It has little or no confidence from the people who will be asked to implement it.”
Yesterday’s summit at Downing Street became a focus of anger after it emerged that critics of the bill, including the British Medical Association, had not been invited.
Mr Lansley was met with fierce hostility from protestors waiting outside, with one, June Hautot, 75, telling him: “I’ve had enough of you and Cameron.”
Comments(15)
Shoong
says...
11:46am Tue 21 Feb 12
St Retford wrote:Absolutely, because the previous lot did such a great job didn't they? 'Course they did.
Good luck, John. This bill could well be the undoing of this government, and lord knows it needs undoing sooner rather than later.
Sometimes I think certain peoples memories started on 11 May...
George4th
says...
11:56am Tue 21 Feb 12
"It will be open for everyone who opposes the bill"
A balanced debate then?!
Lone Ranger.
says...
12:39pm Tue 21 Feb 12
.
If he does succeed then its RIP NHS but best of all RIP Conservatives.
.
This could be the final nail
Shoong
says...
1:14pm Tue 21 Feb 12
Lone Ranger. wrote:With the quality of alternatives on offer, I wouldn't fire up the hearse just yet.
With so many Tories, Lib Dems, Labour and the majority of Health Professionals against this NHS Bill still the arrogance of Cameron continues to take it forward.
.
If he does succeed then its RIP NHS but best of all RIP Conservatives.
.
This could be the final nail
dave1958
says...
1:16pm Tue 21 Feb 12
How many people remember the Tory slogan the NHS is safe in our hands, that was a joke.
The NHS is one subject that no one trusts Tories with, purely because they are only interested in one thing making money, and the resturation of the have's and have nots, the Tories being the have's and everyone else the have nots.
When it comes to health care, they do not want to see it free at the point of delivery. They would rather everyone had private medical care and they could then be making big bucks out of it. We do not want American health care system over hear, the quicker the bill is dropped the better. The NHS belongs to everyone not just the select few, and I want a doctor who will treat me, and not be spending his time, worrying about the totals not adding up on the spreadsheet, or sitting in a disciplinary hearing, over something that has happened. I want the doctor I see to have his full concentration on what ever medical issue I am consulting him about.
I totally agree with the final words of Lone Ranger, if it succeed, then Dave C, Andrew Lansley, Nick Clegg will all be RIP. I for one will not be attending the funeral.
freemantlegirl2
says...
1:53pm Tue 21 Feb 12
dave1958 wrote:Well put and when your own party and coalitiion partners aren't in favour, and there has been no chance for open debate (no opposers were invited to DC's meeting yesterday) then it will fail.
What people should remember is the words of Dave C whilst out on the campaign trail, "There will be no top down reorganisation of the NHS". He said that whilst knowing full well that Lansley with the help of £8.3m in the form of 333 donations from private health companies to the Tory party was doing the exact opposite.
How many people remember the Tory slogan the NHS is safe in our hands, that was a joke.
The NHS is one subject that no one trusts Tories with, purely because they are only interested in one thing making money, and the resturation of the have's and have nots, the Tories being the have's and everyone else the have nots.
When it comes to health care, they do not want to see it free at the point of delivery. They would rather everyone had private medical care and they could then be making big bucks out of it. We do not want American health care system over hear, the quicker the bill is dropped the better. The NHS belongs to everyone not just the select few, and I want a doctor who will treat me, and not be spending his time, worrying about the totals not adding up on the spreadsheet, or sitting in a disciplinary hearing, over something that has happened. I want the doctor I see to have his full concentration on what ever medical issue I am consulting him about.
I totally agree with the final words of Lone Ranger, if it succeed, then Dave C, Andrew Lansley, Nick Clegg will all be RIP. I for one will not be attending the funeral.
I think this is the one thing that has made me most angry about this government, that and the disablist bashing (which Cameron also said he would never do either having had a disabled son). This is is COALITION but no-one would ever think it would they! Even Nick Clegg was struggling on TV this morning and has been sent to some youth project today to keep him out of the way.
I will be protesting at this rally and more if they continue to ignore a large majority of professionals, staff, fellow polititians and patients who have clear issues with it.
George4th
says...
2:27pm Tue 21 Feb 12
Look anywhere else in the world and see what sort of medical care you get! And at what cost!
If the NHS is made an efficient and cost effective organisation, it will be sustainable for decades to come - if not, it will all collapse and everyone will end up having to pay for medical care out of their own pocket.
You choose...........
Lone Ranger.
says...
2:49pm Tue 21 Feb 12
Shoong wrote:The alternatives may not be great ... But they cannot be any worse than a Tory led coalition that is so out of touch with the electorate.
Lone Ranger. wrote:With the quality of alternatives on offer, I wouldn't fire up the hearse just yet.
With so many Tories, Lib Dems, Labour and the majority of Health Professionals against this NHS Bill still the arrogance of Cameron continues to take it forward.
.
If he does succeed then its RIP NHS but best of all RIP Conservatives.
.
This could be the final nail
.
Fortunately Cameron is so arrogant that he cant see the dangers that lay ahead.
.
Even the opinion polls show that his lead has been completely eroded due to this Bill.
.
This is great news ..... let him carry on and dig his own grave.
.
So it may not be fired up but the ignition is on
Shoong
says...
2:54pm Tue 21 Feb 12
Lone Ranger. wrote:Sorry, I disagree. It's easy to confuse 'arrogant' with 'determined' whatever your goals maybe.
Shoong wrote:The alternatives may not be great ... But they cannot be any worse than a Tory led coalition that is so out of touch with the electorate.
Lone Ranger. wrote:With the quality of alternatives on offer, I wouldn't fire up the hearse just yet.
With so many Tories, Lib Dems, Labour and the majority of Health Professionals against this NHS Bill still the arrogance of Cameron continues to take it forward.
.
If he does succeed then its RIP NHS but best of all RIP Conservatives.
.
This could be the final nail
.
Fortunately Cameron is so arrogant that he cant see the dangers that lay ahead.
.
Even the opinion polls show that his lead has been completely eroded due to this Bill.
.
This is great news ..... let him carry on and dig his own grave.
.
So it may not be fired up but the ignition is on
13 years of utter incompetency have to be rectified.
They are not popular choices, never will be.
Lone Ranger.
says...
3:23pm Tue 21 Feb 12
Shoong wrote:13 years without any opposition is because the Tories etc had nothing to offer.
Lone Ranger. wrote:Sorry, I disagree. It's easy to confuse 'arrogant' with 'determined' whatever your goals maybe.
Shoong wrote:The alternatives may not be great ... But they cannot be any worse than a Tory led coalition that is so out of touch with the electorate.
Lone Ranger. wrote:With the quality of alternatives on offer, I wouldn't fire up the hearse just yet.
With so many Tories, Lib Dems, Labour and the majority of Health Professionals against this NHS Bill still the arrogance of Cameron continues to take it forward.
.
If he does succeed then its RIP NHS but best of all RIP Conservatives.
.
This could be the final nail
.
Fortunately Cameron is so arrogant that he cant see the dangers that lay ahead.
.
Even the opinion polls show that his lead has been completely eroded due to this Bill.
.
This is great news ..... let him carry on and dig his own grave.
.
So it may not be fired up but the ignition is on
13 years of utter incompetency have to be rectified.
They are not popular choices, never will be.
.
13 years and "the people" voted Labour back in on three occasions.
.
After 13 of incompetency (your word) why did the Tories STILL NOT win an overall majority.
.
and after not even two years if the Country went to the polls tomorrow Labour would win again.
.
And i do know the difference between aroganct and determined ... do you.
.
Cameron is "arogant" in pushing forward with this Bill.
Shoong
says...
3:27pm Tue 21 Feb 12
Lone Ranger. wrote:You didn't accuse him of being 'arogant' ;)
Shoong wrote:13 years without any opposition is because the Tories etc had nothing to offer.
Lone Ranger. wrote:Sorry, I disagree. It's easy to confuse 'arrogant' with 'determined' whatever your goals maybe.
Shoong wrote:The alternatives may not be great ... But they cannot be any worse than a Tory led coalition that is so out of touch with the electorate.
Lone Ranger. wrote:With the quality of alternatives on offer, I wouldn't fire up the hearse just yet.
With so many Tories, Lib Dems, Labour and the majority of Health Professionals against this NHS Bill still the arrogance of Cameron continues to take it forward.
.
If he does succeed then its RIP NHS but best of all RIP Conservatives.
.
This could be the final nail
.
Fortunately Cameron is so arrogant that he cant see the dangers that lay ahead.
.
Even the opinion polls show that his lead has been completely eroded due to this Bill.
.
This is great news ..... let him carry on and dig his own grave.
.
So it may not be fired up but the ignition is on
13 years of utter incompetency have to be rectified.
They are not popular choices, never will be.
.
13 years and "the people" voted Labour back in on three occasions.
.
After 13 of incompetency (your word) why did the Tories STILL NOT win an overall majority.
.
and after not even two years if the Country went to the polls tomorrow Labour would win again.
.
And i do know the difference between aroganct and determined ... do you.
.
Cameron is "arogant" in pushing forward with this Bill.
I guess it's all down to perception, I'm sure he will tell you he's determined.
While I think these reforms could do with a little polish, I believe that they safeguard the future of the NHS in the long term.
I could be wrong, time will tell.
Lone Ranger.
says...
3:27pm Tue 21 Feb 12
George4th wrote:As regards a balanced debate .... some call it a "summit" IF you read the papers you would have noticed Camerons total farce in his NHS Summit yesterday.
"He will lead an army of health professionals and residents to voice their opposition to the plans"
"It will be open for everyone who opposes the bill"
A balanced debate then?!
.
Of course only invited were the the ones in favour of the Bill.
.
Yes excluded organisations such as the BMA, RCN, RCM and of course no Lib Dems.
.
How pathetic is that then ....???
.
In your words ... "A balanced debate then"
Linesman
says...
4:39pm Tue 21 Feb 12
George4th wrote:Like Cameron, who only invited those in favour of the bill, to join talks with him at No 10. So much for a government that listens!
"He will lead an army of health professionals and residents to voice their opposition to the plans"
"It will be open for everyone who opposes the bill"
A balanced debate then?!
Linesman
says...
4:41pm Tue 21 Feb 12
dave1958 wrote:Well said Dave.
What people should remember is the words of Dave C whilst out on the campaign trail, "There will be no top down reorganisation of the NHS". He said that whilst knowing full well that Lansley with the help of £8.3m in the form of 333 donations from private health companies to the Tory party was doing the exact opposite.
How many people remember the Tory slogan the NHS is safe in our hands, that was a joke.
The NHS is one subject that no one trusts Tories with, purely because they are only interested in one thing making money, and the resturation of the have's and have nots, the Tories being the have's and everyone else the have nots.
When it comes to health care, they do not want to see it free at the point of delivery. They would rather everyone had private medical care and they could then be making big bucks out of it. We do not want American health care system over hear, the quicker the bill is dropped the better. The NHS belongs to everyone not just the select few, and I want a doctor who will treat me, and not be spending his time, worrying about the totals not adding up on the spreadsheet, or sitting in a disciplinary hearing, over something that has happened. I want the doctor I see to have his full concentration on what ever medical issue I am consulting him about.
I totally agree with the final words of Lone Ranger, if it succeed, then Dave C, Andrew Lansley, Nick Clegg will all be RIP. I for one will not be attending the funeral.
St Retford says...
11:35am Tue 21 Feb 12