Report this comment
  • "
    ben-evans wrote:
    Graeme Harrison wrote:
    Brock_and_Roll wrote:
    Re-trial - seriously?

    Whatever lawyer said a re-trail is possible is either incomeptant or on a nice juicy fee....

    What exactly are the grounds for appeal?

    The fact that Evans refused to show the warden the ticket is proof that even in the highly unlikely event that "Mr Bailey" exisited, Evans would have known the ticket was false and hence was a party to the fraud.

    Clearly with £1,000 of parking fines to his name (which surely takes some doing outside of London) and previous for "making off" leaves any reasonable person in no doubt about Mr Evans intentions with regards to parking charges.

    I hope I am not contributing towards this chaps legal fees!

    If you dont like the park charges, dont park there. And if you are really bothered, vote for a party that will reduce them and raise the money elsewhere - its called democracy.
    Everyone convicted by a magistrates' court has an automatic right of appeal to the Crown Court. No grounds of appeal are necessary.
    I honestly didn't produce nor did i put ANY tickets that were fraudulent in my car. It's now just to convince people that I wasn't aware. If someone got you a parking ticket would you think twice about it being fake? Of course not. The arrangement was I drive he pays for parking therefore what motive did I have for doing it? none. But for him saving £8. He paid my fine and yes he called up and paid on his card, does that not show guilt????? I'd appreciate some advice. Being accused of something that you haven't done and no one believing you is so wrong. They may aswell say I raped him too. Can I add how many people are wrongfully accused then found not guilty. And I didn't respond to there letters because I had £1000 fines to which not all were justified. Paying fines for tickets blowing off my dash and parking just outside the bay wasnt fair. Advice would be welcomed
    My advice would be to take the fine and not risk it being increased.
    You say you didn't know the ticket was faked and yet you refused to show it to the warden - seems you can't help but lie mate - a known skill in the estate agency business so no surprises there.
    The only real surprise is that you are stupid enough to try and defend yourself on here when a blind man can see you have a meritless case.
    My advice is give up, and go get a proper job."
  • This field is mandatory
  • This field is mandatory
  • Please note we will not accept reports with HTML tags or URLs in them.

  • Enter the above word in the box below

Dozy parker Benjamin Evans gets £530 bill for trying to avoid £8 ticket

First published in News Daily Echo: Photograph of the Author by , Deputy News Editor

HE thought it was a clever ploy to save himself just £8.

Benjamin Evans believed he had got round the daily fee in the car park near his work – by planting a fake ticket on his dashboard instead.

But the serial cheat didn’t count on the eagle-eyed city centre ticket inspector who spotted the replica and got photographic evidence – landing the 27-year-old in court charged with offences under the Fraud Act.

Yet in a final bid to avoid taking the blame, Evans even stood up in court and claimed to know nothing about the spoof ticket – instead trying to incriminate a former work colleague and friend.

Southampton Magistrates’ Court heard how, in August last year, civil enforcement officer Christopher Meadows was on his daily patrol of car parks in Southampton when he approached Evans’ grey BMW in Lime Street car park and became suspicious.

The ticket, which claimed that a fee of £8 had been paid for ten hours’ parking, had part of its serial number covered by a 10p coin.

He told how the shading on the city council logo was slightly different to genuine tickets, the number ‘3’ was printed more curved than usual and the edges to the counterfeit ticket were rough, prompting him to slap a fixed penalty notice on the windscreen.

Evans, who was working for estate agents Your Move at the time, saw the warden from his office block and went to confront him, the court was told.

But he refused to open the car to show Mr Meadows the ticket, and walked away telling him to “go and get a proper job”.

The court was told how investigations were carried out which confirmed no ticket had been bought from any of the machines servicing that car park at the price of £8 that day.

Parking enforcement officers repeatedly contacted Evans – who the court heard has received more than £1,000 in separate parking fines in recent years – asking him to provide the ticket, but he failed to respond.

Instead, weeks after the incident on August 29, he emailed them – to complain about his treatment by Mr Meadows.

Giving evidence in his trial, Evans named a former colleague, Jonathan Bailey, as the man who must have got the fake ticket. He said the pair shared the journey to work, with Evans driving every day and Mr Bailey paying for parking.

However, the court heard how nobody had been able to trace Mr Bailey – and Evans was accused by Southampton City Council lawyer, Francisca Da Costa, of “inventing a fictional character” to take the blame when he was caught trying to get “a freebie”.

Evans, from Crampmoor Lane, Romsey, admitted one count of failing to give information which would identify the owner of the car, and was found guilty of a second charge of displaying a false parking ticket.

The court was told how he had three previous convictions for making off without paying, for which he had received 80 hours community service.

Sentencing him, chairman of the bench Susan Williams told Evans she did not believe his evidence and gave him a further 130 hours of community work and ordered him to pay £530 costs.

Comments (126)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree