- Mobile site
- E-Newsletters
-
- News feed
- Find us on Twitter
@dailyecho
Daily Echo on Twitter
@the_saints
Saints News on Twitter
SceneSouth
Leisure news on Twitter
- Find us on Facebook
Facebook
Daily Echo on Facebook
Church bans yoga for 'not being Christian' (From Daily Echo)
When news happens, text SDE and your photos or videos to 80360. Or contact us by email and phone.
St. Edmund's Church in Southampton bans yoga class for not being Christian
9:40am Wednesday 26th September 2012 in News
Exclusive By Tara Russell, Feature Writer
IT is meant to be relaxing and work miracles for people’s peace of mind.
But the ancient discipline of yoga is at the centre of a rowafter it was banned from a Hampshire church hall.
A Roman Catholic priest has refused to allow yoga instructor Cori Withell to use his church’s hall for her weekly classes.
Father John Chandler, of St Edmund’s Church in Southampton , ruled out hosting the exercise class saying it was un-Christian.
Cori, who runs her own business CW Fitness, said she paid a £180 deposit and started signing up people for her classes back in August.
The 36-year-old was due to teach a Pilates class as well as a Unite class – a mixture of Pilates and yoga.
But after the church found out the exercises would include yoga she got a call from the church off The Avenue, in Southampton, saying the class was “against the church’s religion”.
Cori, who lives in Allbrook, Eastleigh , described the church’s position as “ridiculous”.
She said: “I was both flabbergasted and infuriated when I got the call. I tried to explain to the church that my yoga classes were not religious at all and I even offered to come and demonstrate the class.
“Yoga is not about religion at all. It is about calmness and relaxation. When you think of the issues we have with heart disease, obesity and stress we have in this country and you would think people should be promoting exercise – not preventing it taking place. The church has completely misunderstood this.”
Last night Father Chandler defended his decision, saying: “Because yoga is a Hindu spiritual discipline it is not compatible with Catholicism. The two just don’t mix.
“There are documents written by the church on yoga and it is not compatible with our faith, so no, Catholics should not be doing it, no more than Hindus should be doing something which is against their religion. If people are using the hall for keep fit that isn’t a problem but if you are putting a spiritual dimension with it, which yoga does do, you can’t have it in the church.”
A spokesman for the Diocese of Portsmouth said in 17 years it was the first time he was asked to comment on a yoga ban but it was up to individual priests.
He said: “What we don’t allow is anything that can be construed as non Christian worship and there is a dilemma with yoga, which could be seen as a form of relaxation – or a non-Christian possible Hindu meditation.
“On the other hand from the calls I have made there are some Catholic retreats which offer yoga.
“It may be this particular priest is erring on the side of caution, I don’t know. There isn’t a diocese or a national line but it would be inappropriate for non Christian religious activities to be taking place in the church halls.”
Yoga enthusiasts condemned the move as “ignorant” and even urged the priest to try a session.
Pierre Bibby, chief executive of the charity British Wheel of Yoga, said: “Yoga has got nothing to do with religion. This just shows the complete lack of understanding.
“There is research that demonstrates that yoga improves people’s health and wellbeing physically and mentally. Who could object to that?
“I am appalled by this knee-jerk reaction.”
What other churches say
THE decision to ban the yoga classes divided opinion among religious communities in Southampton.
Father David Sillince, of St Boniface Catholic Church in Freemantle and Shirley, said: “In my opinion yoga is no more religious than line dancing frankly. It is not as if people are coming to
spread an alternative gospel. The yoga I have encountered is about unwinding and destressing
and I don’t believe there are any particular religious overtones.
“Most Catholic churches would regard it as a simple form of exercise but there are one or two who take it in its strictest sense.”
A Church of England spokesman said while there are some “cases of particular sensitivities to the background of yoga with its routes in the Hindu faith”, the general feeling is that yoga is
today used as a way to keep fit.
He said: “You can look at most church halls and there will be yoga classes held there because today it is seen as a way to keep fit and agile, not for its spiritual background.”
Meanwhile the city’s Hindu community said yoga resulted in better health.
A spokesman from the Vedic Temple in Southampton said: “In today’s hectic materialistic world doesn’t attending a yoga class fall in the same category as attending a gym? If one attains peace just by meditating will it be counted as a Hindu peace?
“Our temple proudly displays photographs of other religions, including Christianity. All I can request is a greater understanding of yoga, which will resolve this issue.”
- Use the links below to share this story with your friends and followers.
Comments(183)
Ginger_cyclist
says...
9:54am Wed 26 Sep 12
Scott_OOOSH
says...
10:01am Wed 26 Sep 12
The Wickham Man
says...
10:07am Wed 26 Sep 12
Ginger_cyclist
says...
10:08am Wed 26 Sep 12
Scott_OOOSH wrote:To be honest I think the best religions people could go for are Buddhism and Hinduism because as far as I can tell, they're the only ones that haven't resorted to violence to get their points across.
Ha, religion is funny!
Ginger_cyclist
says...
10:09am Wed 26 Sep 12
The Wickham Man wrote:That's a good way to put it.
On the surface it's no more that one lot of silly rituals criticising another set of silly rituals, but it is rank hypocrisy to see christian ministers and priests regularly attending the religious festivals of moslems and hindus in some kind of pointless show of joint faith and unity and then denigrating and denounce the old religions such as paganism and new age spritualism with some ferocity. You either support "faith" or you don't. Trying to select other faiths you "like" from those you "don't like" defeats the whole "faith" purpose and turns christians into narrow minded intolerant hypocrites. (then again those of us above all that primitive superstitious nonsense know that anyway).
Vix1
says...
10:10am Wed 26 Sep 12
SaintAsh1964
says...
10:11am Wed 26 Sep 12
Ginger_cyclist wrote:Your comment is as stupid as the attitude of this Priest, other religious hate Christian's and Catholics because they wont allow Yoga in a Church?
And that is why other religious groups hate Christians and Catholics.
The Crusades I can understand caused some friction, but not banning Yoga.
George4th
says...
10:13am Wed 26 Sep 12
mooky9
says...
10:14am Wed 26 Sep 12
The Wickham Man wrote:Steady you may need to put an oxygen mask on from sitting way up there on your high horse...
On the surface it's no more that one lot of silly rituals criticising another set of silly rituals, but it is rank hypocrisy to see christian ministers and priests regularly attending the religious festivals of moslems and hindus in some kind of pointless show of joint faith and unity and then denigrating and denounce the old religions such as paganism and new age spritualism with some ferocity. You either support "faith" or you don't. Trying to select other faiths you "like" from those you "don't like" defeats the whole "faith" purpose and turns christians into narrow minded intolerant hypocrites. (then again those of us above all that primitive superstitious nonsense know that anyway).
And before you start, no I am not a Christian, however if someone else has a belief or point of view I let them go with what they want to do.
Higginz
says...
10:14am Wed 26 Sep 12
By the way, BIG fan of Pilates.
nedscrumpo
says...
10:15am Wed 26 Sep 12
eurogordi
says...
10:18am Wed 26 Sep 12
None of us are perfect, whatever religion, meditation or relaxation we choose to follow, but the fundamentals of yoga do conflict with the teachings of Christianity.
Well done, Father Chandler, and I very much hope and pray that other Christian leaders and churches will follow your example.
As another contributor has already written "It's about time that Christians were allowed to have a voice again!! Good on them for standing up for what the Bible teaches!"
Incidentally, if this story was about a mosque refusing a church choir to to hire a room for rehearsals,, I am sure that no one would be criticising the decision of Islamic leaders for upholding their belief structure!
elvisimo
says...
10:25am Wed 26 Sep 12
Shoong
says...
10:25am Wed 26 Sep 12
cliffwalker
says...
10:54am Wed 26 Sep 12
Ginger_cyclist wrote:Just to keep the record straight:
Scott_OOOSH wrote:To be honest I think the best religions people could go for are Buddhism and Hinduism because as far as I can tell, they're the only ones that haven't resorted to violence to get their points across.
Ha, religion is funny!
There was widespread conflict between Hindu and Muslim during the partition of India including massacres carried out by Hindus (and Muslims). Further ther was internecine violence involving "warrior monks" in Japan during the feudal period.
I'm not aware of any strongly held faith that has not or would not lead to violence of one kind or another.
As for the church hall story; does anyone expect logical behaviour to flow from an irrational belief?
Scrutinizer
says...
10:54am Wed 26 Sep 12
Evidentally, this is yet another example of the increasing paranoia on the part of the christian church's powers-that-be. They are obviously panicking on account of gradually losing their dominance in Western society. However, to be fair, and has been mentioned in the article, not all christians are the same in their attitude to this.
Georgem
says...
11:08am Wed 26 Sep 12
Ginger_cyclist wrote:Church of Satan. Seriously. Forget "ritual sacrifice", that's a media invention.
Scott_OOOSH wrote:To be honest I think the best religions people could go for are Buddhism and Hinduism because as far as I can tell, they're the only ones that haven't resorted to violence to get their points across.
Ha, religion is funny!
Huey
says...
11:09am Wed 26 Sep 12
"Oh we'll hide Nazis and cover up child abuse, but don't try to do yoga in our church!"
Well if there is a God they will all be damned.
Georgem
says...
11:10am Wed 26 Sep 12
Shoong wrote:Any excuse to bash religion.
It's the property of the church I assume so it's up to them. Can't see what the fuss is about.
Georgem
says...
11:12am Wed 26 Sep 12
Vix1 wrote:Wait, what? The Church has banned yoga? Where?
It's because yoga focuses on self! As a Christian you consider yourself last and others first. I know people who have done yoga and they tell you it's all about finding your inner self and communicating with your "core". Now question why the church has banned it!!! It's about time that Christians were allowed to have a voice again!! Good on them for standing up for what the Bible teaches!
Linesman
says...
11:16am Wed 26 Sep 12
Linesman
says...
11:17am Wed 26 Sep 12
Georgem wrote:I had never considered Yoga to be a religion. If it is, who is their religious leader?
Shoong wrote:Any excuse to bash religion.
It's the property of the church I assume so it's up to them. Can't see what the fuss is about.
Huey
says...
11:19am Wed 26 Sep 12
No place for them in the modern world.
Pathetic really.
Georgem
says...
11:19am Wed 26 Sep 12
Ginger_cyclist wrote:Bear in mind that people use that same exact reasoning when telling you why they think ALL cyclists are scumbags. Remember that you are quick to point out that such behaviour is not necessarily representative of ALL cyclists.
And that is why other religious groups hate Christians and Catholics.
Shoong
says...
11:19am Wed 26 Sep 12
Linesman wrote:Attempt at being clever = Fail.
Georgem wrote:I had never considered Yoga to be a religion. If it is, who is their religious leader?
Shoong wrote:Any excuse to bash religion.
It's the property of the church I assume so it's up to them. Can't see what the fuss is about.
Inform Al
says...
11:19am Wed 26 Sep 12
Georgem
says...
11:21am Wed 26 Sep 12
Linesman wrote:I'm referring to the people kicking up a fuss.
Georgem wrote:I had never considered Yoga to be a religion. If it is, who is their religious leader?
Shoong wrote:Any excuse to bash religion.
It's the property of the church I assume so it's up to them. Can't see what the fuss is about.
Georgem
says...
11:29am Wed 26 Sep 12
BenjiWinsor
says...
11:35am Wed 26 Sep 12
eurogordi wrote:hear hear!
I fully support the decision taken by this priest and have personal concerns about those churches that do allow practices which started in other religions.
None of us are perfect, whatever religion, meditation or relaxation we choose to follow, but the fundamentals of yoga do conflict with the teachings of Christianity.
Well done, Father Chandler, and I very much hope and pray that other Christian leaders and churches will follow your example.
As another contributor has already written "It's about time that Christians were allowed to have a voice again!! Good on them for standing up for what the Bible teaches!"
Incidentally, if this story was about a mosque refusing a church choir to to hire a room for rehearsals,, I am sure that no one would be criticising the decision of Islamic leaders for upholding their belief structure!
freefinker
says...
11:40am Wed 26 Sep 12
Georgem wrote:.. lol.
I wonder what Rahit Maryada would say about all this.
Cue southy, but it will take him a while as he needs to translate the wise man’s words from Sikh to English.
BenjiWinsor
says...
11:46am Wed 26 Sep 12
ersforthenewage.org/
Articles_ChristianYo
ga.html
freefinker
says...
11:52am Wed 26 Sep 12
The Wickham Man wrote:.. couldn't have put it better myself.
On the surface it's no more that one lot of silly rituals criticising another set of silly rituals, but it is rank hypocrisy to see christian ministers and priests regularly attending the religious festivals of moslems and hindus in some kind of pointless show of joint faith and unity and then denigrating and denounce the old religions such as paganism and new age spritualism with some ferocity. You either support "faith" or you don't. Trying to select other faiths you "like" from those you "don't like" defeats the whole "faith" purpose and turns christians into narrow minded intolerant hypocrites. (then again those of us above all that primitive superstitious nonsense know that anyway).
However, although yoga originates in Hinduism, in the west, at least, it is just a secular exercise and meditation regime.
I have 3 yoga instructors as friends. They are all 100% confirmed atheists.
Huey
says...
11:57am Wed 26 Sep 12
Laughable really.
Georgem
says...
12:00pm Wed 26 Sep 12
http://www.youtube.c
om/watch?feature=pla
yer_detailpage&v=mSp
o3rLMvKg#t=50s
Stephen J
says...
12:08pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Georgem
says...
12:10pm Wed 26 Sep 12
sotonwinch09
says...
12:10pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Georgem
says...
12:15pm Wed 26 Sep 12
sotonwinch09 wrote:Exactly. People are being manipulated by a mildly sensationalist headline, but apparently it's the Christians who are unthinking, brain-washed sheep. Go figure.
The church own the building so they can decide what events go ahead. Don't see why this is a story. Just book another hall.
BerryMan
says...
12:19pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Religion will ruin this world.
Goldenwight
says...
12:20pm Wed 26 Sep 12
I wonder if Father Chandler has ever read 'The Life of Pi' by Yann Martel? Probably not, because he certainly doesn't seem to be that clued up on the Bible. If this were an episode of 'Father Ted' I imagine he would be playing Father Jack.
StMarysSaint
says...
12:31pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Stephen J
says...
12:34pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Georgem wrote:Which is why I deliberately used a small "c". From what we have read of The Church's position, it is clear that The Church regards this as a local decision for which Father Chandler alone is answerable. Of course The Church doesn't have a strict view on whether Yoga should be banned from its premises. Enforcing such a ban might create a risk of The Church looking ridiculous to a degree that is out of all proportion to the issue. Such a view does not seem to be shared by the church in the Avenue.
It's worth pointing out that The Church hasn't banned anything. This specific church, is not allowing it's own premises to be used by a particular yoga class. Nothing more.
Stillness
says...
12:45pm Wed 26 Sep 12
To those who have read the bible but failed to understand it and it's principles saying that focusing on your own well being is not Christian I would point out that without the well people there would not be any people to help the unwell ones. I wonder how many of these people start their prayers with something along the lines of "help me"?
Any organization, religion or otherwise will fail if they base their actions on what was (possibly) said or written thousands of years ago.
Perhaps all religions should think about Rumi's statement "The lamps are different but the light is the same"?
If anyone is wondering he was a 13th century Sufi poet but of course the church will have a fit if they find out that that makes him a Muslim lol.
Chas O'Bursledon
says...
12:45pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Art_Vandelay
says...
12:47pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Georgem
says...
12:53pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Chas O'Bursledon wrote:You're condemning Father John Chandler for his beliefs.
Another stupid example of how hate and bigotry never solved a problem. I am proud of my atheism. My moral compass does not allow me to hate or condemn a person I do not know for their beliefs. I do not judge them unless they impose or try to impose their belief system on me. Yoga does no harm. It is not a religion or a martial art. I do not condemn Catholicism but a very stupid man who is coincidentally a priest. I would worry about the example he is setting his congregation.
Walter K
says...
12:59pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Stillness
says...
1:01pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Georgem wrote:Not his beliefs, his actions.
Chas O'Bursledon wrote:You're condemning Father John Chandler for his beliefs.
Another stupid example of how hate and bigotry never solved a problem. I am proud of my atheism. My moral compass does not allow me to hate or condemn a person I do not know for their beliefs. I do not judge them unless they impose or try to impose their belief system on me. Yoga does no harm. It is not a religion or a martial art. I do not condemn Catholicism but a very stupid man who is coincidentally a priest. I would worry about the example he is setting his congregation.
MGRA
says...
1:03pm Wed 26 Sep 12
MGRA
says...
1:08pm Wed 26 Sep 12
eurogordi wrote:"Father" chandler is a simple bigot who is ignorant and un-informed..... surprise surprise..... move on nothing to see hear except religious zealots making people miserable like they enjoy.... What is better for stress ? yoga or going to "confession" and being told you are a sinner for doing something a bigotted guy in a frock says you should not ???
I fully support the decision taken by this priest and have personal concerns about those churches that do allow practices which started in other religions.
None of us are perfect, whatever religion, meditation or relaxation we choose to follow, but the fundamentals of yoga do conflict with the teachings of Christianity.
Well done, Father Chandler, and I very much hope and pray that other Christian leaders and churches will follow your example.
As another contributor has already written "It's about time that Christians were allowed to have a voice again!! Good on them for standing up for what the Bible teaches!"
Incidentally, if this story was about a mosque refusing a church choir to to hire a room for rehearsals,, I am sure that no one would be criticising the decision of Islamic leaders for upholding their belief structure!
StMarysSaint
says...
1:11pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Georgem wrote:Religion gives Spirituality a bad name.
Chas O'Bursledon wrote:You're condemning Father John Chandler for his beliefs.
Another stupid example of how hate and bigotry never solved a problem. I am proud of my atheism. My moral compass does not allow me to hate or condemn a person I do not know for their beliefs. I do not judge them unless they impose or try to impose their belief system on me. Yoga does no harm. It is not a religion or a martial art. I do not condemn Catholicism but a very stupid man who is coincidentally a priest. I would worry about the example he is setting his congregation.
Stillness
says...
1:16pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Besides the priest is probably worried that if he upsets the all loving, all forgiving, all caring beardy shinny man who lives above the clouds and who he calls father he will be sent him to hell by him to be tortured for eternity.
confused of kingsland
says...
1:22pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Chas O'Bursledon wrote:Hear hear! So pleased I'm a Humanist.
Another stupid example of how hate and bigotry never solved a problem. I am proud of my atheism. My moral compass does not allow me to hate or condemn a person I do not know for their beliefs. I do not judge them unless they impose or try to impose their belief system on me. Yoga does no harm. It is not a religion or a martial art. I do not condemn Catholicism but a very stupid man who is coincidentally a priest. I would worry about the example he is setting his congregation.
snapperdownunder
says...
1:23pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Stillness
says...
1:43pm Wed 26 Sep 12
snapperdownunder wrote:Not at all. It's those that like to use it to help define and divide people that are a curse. Personally I prefer to listen to:
Who needs religion? The curse of mankind.
"The heart of every religion is the religion of the heart." (Br. David Steindl-Rast)
"I am a Hindu, I am a Christian, I am a Muslim, I am a Jew." (Gandhi)
"Ekam sat vipra bahundha vedantihi." Truth is One but the wise have called it by many names. (Rig Veda)
"Do not be confused because you hear many voices. Know that I am One and the same." (Talmud)
"The lamps are different but the light is the same: it comes from beyond." (Rumi)
"There is only one religion, the religion of love. There is only one God, the light that shines in your heart." (Satya Sai Baba)
"Imagine there's no countries
It isn't hard to do
Nothing to kill or die for
And no religion too" (John Lennon)
MisterGrimsdale
says...
1:51pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Linesman wrote:I am. Now keep bending like I told you and await further instructions.
Georgem wrote:I had never considered Yoga to be a religion. If it is, who is their religious leader?
Shoong wrote:Any excuse to bash religion.
It's the property of the church I assume so it's up to them. Can't see what the fuss is about.
Paramjit Bahia
says...
2:12pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Georgem wrote:Yes that could be interesting.
I wonder what Rahit Maryada would say about all this.
lowe esteem
says...
2:25pm Wed 26 Sep 12
For just 45p (that's 9/-!) this and more exciting stories-in your super soaraway...
Stillness
says...
2:27pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Paramjit Bahia wrote:Well I would guess that you could meditate on Nam whist doing your Yoga. What would YOU say?
Georgem wrote:Yes that could be interesting.
I wonder what Rahit Maryada would say about all this.
charlotte7933
says...
2:29pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Dazman67
says...
2:42pm Wed 26 Sep 12
bluetouchpaper
MGRA
says...
2:55pm Wed 26 Sep 12
charlotte7933 wrote:so how come 100s of child molestors were allowed to abuse children on catholic church premises then and then protected from prosecution ?? what does "your god" say about that ?? regards Yoga,,,, you say its unsafe ! I would rather send my children to a Yoga class than allow them to be in the sole care of a catholic priest !! Thats how "safe" yoga is, you are far less likely to get sexually abused.
No one is saying yoga is religous. Yoga is spiritural. Which is why the catholic church can't allow it on church premises. I totally agree with the priest. when doing yoga you are entering into meditation. As father said St Edmunds is a catholic church. Yoga's origon is from the hindu faith. Our God says in scripture that alternative therapies should be avoided theres NO alternative to god. seek god for peace and relaxation. meditate on god. The results are very rewarding. I have had teaching on this and have heard that rather than being a positive excercise it can have very negative affects. There are lots of other forms of exercise that is far safer than yoga. this would be why the priest said no when you said abiut the yoga. pilate is just as good if not better than yoga.
Georgem
says...
2:57pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Shoong
says...
3:04pm Wed 26 Sep 12
First in the world for Life Expectancy, Literacy, Education & Standards of Living.
2nd Highest Capita per GDP.
But they are all very, very boring.
Paramjit Bahia
says...
3:05pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Ginger_cyclist wrote:Best thing for people could be to stay away from religions.
Scott_OOOSH wrote:To be honest I think the best religions people could go for are Buddhism and Hinduism because as far as I can tell, they're the only ones that haven't resorted to violence to get their points across.
Ha, religion is funny!
But as there are some who remain addicted to unscientific dangerous drug, religion, society should be compassionate towards them and let them exercise their perversion within the confine of their own places of worship, so that toxins could be contained.
In theory most religions may appear attractive propositions but become problems when manipulated by vested interests, your recommendations Hinduism and Budhism included.
Buddhist attacking Haringa (My spelling may be incorrect) in Burma has been in the news recently.
Hinduism?
Hindu fanatics killed even Mahatama Gandhi... If they did not even spare him do you need to look any further.
Conflicts between Hinduism and Islam was the cause of one of the biggest slaughter of humans when they caused division of India.
Successors of Mahatama Gandhi's killers are now fascist political party in India ( BJP) . Fanatics demolished ancient Muslim Mosque (Babri Masjid) causing disturbances all over the globe.
Riots in BJP ruled Gujrat when many non Hindus were burnt alive and only recently their two most prominent members (including one cabinet minister) have been found guilty of mass murders.
For your info BJP and other Hindu fascist organisations have branches even in UK and followers even in Southampton.
Sticking to church in this item, is it not strange that christian church while preaching love thy neighbour won't allow people to exercise Yoga because some idiot thinks to keep fit may be against his religion, BUT keeping in line of tolerance and forgiveness churches have allowed pedophile priests to screw small kids?
It is not just ordinary hypocrisy but the almighty's hypocrisy
southy
says...
3:09pm Wed 26 Sep 12
freefinker wrote:Ask Rahit what he thinks, but if your on about Sikh Reht Maryada then go to there web site.
Georgem wrote:.. lol.
I wonder what Rahit Maryada would say about all this.
Cue southy, but it will take him a while as he needs to translate the wise man’s words from Sikh to English.
http://www.sgpc.net/
sikhism/sikh-dharma-
manual.html
I see the Greens in Brighton have done it again with there none Green Policy, not just cuts now, they want to build on heath land.
As for this matter of Yoga, what real hurm is it doing None at all.
Maybe this girl needs to find a place right next door and have big signs up saying Yoga classes, would this victor complain still i wonder.
Ginger_cyclist
says...
3:12pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Georgem wrote:Your'e right, I should have worded it better though I would have thought most people would realize I meant a minority of them but obviously not and some have taken offense.
Ginger_cyclist wrote:Bear in mind that people use that same exact reasoning when telling you why they think ALL cyclists are scumbags. Remember that you are quick to point out that such behaviour is not necessarily representative of ALL cyclists.
And that is why other religious groups hate Christians and Catholics.
Paramjit Bahia
says...
3:14pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Stillness wrote:Sorry for my ignorance, what is Nam?
Paramjit Bahia wrote:Well I would guess that you could meditate on Nam whist doing your Yoga. What would YOU say?
Georgem wrote:Yes that could be interesting.
I wonder what Rahit Maryada would say about all this.
Surely you could not be referring to Non Alligned Movement started by Nehru Tito and Nassar, which has now been hijacked by nations like Iran
kingnotail
says...
3:19pm Wed 26 Sep 12
southy
says...
3:32pm Wed 26 Sep 12
George4th wrote:Look what kind of people control Religions, Religions are Business
A good example of why religions continually cause conflict! The hypocrisy of all religions knows no bounds!
thesaint
says...
3:45pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Stillness
says...
4:03pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Paramjit Bahia wrote:Nam: Divine Substance, also translated as "God's attributed self".
Stillness wrote:Sorry for my ignorance, what is Nam?
Paramjit Bahia wrote:Well I would guess that you could meditate on Nam whist doing your Yoga. What would YOU say?
Georgem wrote:Yes that could be interesting.
I wonder what Rahit Maryada would say about all this.
Surely you could not be referring to Non Alligned Movement started by Nehru Tito and Nassar, which has now been hijacked by nations like Iran
Well, at least according to The Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee anyway.
bobbyboy
says...
4:08pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Georgem
says...
4:19pm Wed 26 Sep 12
southy wrote:I can't ask Rahit what he thinks, as he is not a person. We all know this! But let's not dwell on that.
freefinker wrote:Ask Rahit what he thinks, but if your on about Sikh Reht Maryada then go to there web site.
Georgem wrote:.. lol.
I wonder what Rahit Maryada would say about all this.
Cue southy, but it will take him a while as he needs to translate the wise man’s words from Sikh to English.
http://www.sgpc.net/
sikhism/sikh-dharma-
manual.html
I see the Greens in Brighton have done it again with there none Green Policy, not just cuts now, they want to build on heath land.
As for this matter of Yoga, what real hurm is it doing None at all.
Maybe this girl needs to find a place right next door and have big signs up saying Yoga classes, would this victor complain still i wonder.
Or your bizarre insertion of something about the Green Party for no reason whatsoever.
Yoga is indeed doing no harm, but if some stupid priest doesn't want it in his church hall, that's up to him I guess.
southy
says...
4:28pm Wed 26 Sep 12
bobbyboy wrote:If only all religions who learn to mingle and cross marriage across all faiths.
yawn are we in the 21st century yet or did i miss it i'm sure when i sat at Christs right hand he said to me embrace all my son regardless of origins they are all my children we are mere leaders and preachers not owners of human faiths.
sotonboy84
says...
4:28pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Georgem wrote:I agree.
sotonwinch09 wrote: The church own the building so they can decide what events go ahead. Don't see why this is a story. Just book another hall.Exactly. People are being manipulated by a mildly sensationalist headline, but apparently it's the Christians who are unthinking, brain-washed sheep. Go figure.
It's nice to see somebody stand strong next to their beliefs and not back down.
Whatever people's different views are, it's Father Chandler who has the final say.
southy
says...
4:33pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Georgem wrote:No Rahit is a people first name, Reht is not look at the spelling even go up on there web site to check the spelling.
southy wrote:I can't ask Rahit what he thinks, as he is not a person. We all know this! But let's not dwell on that.
freefinker wrote:Ask Rahit what he thinks, but if your on about Sikh Reht Maryada then go to there web site.
Georgem wrote:.. lol.
I wonder what Rahit Maryada would say about all this.
Cue southy, but it will take him a while as he needs to translate the wise man’s words from Sikh to English.
http://www.sgpc.net/
sikhism/sikh-dharma-
manual.html
I see the Greens in Brighton have done it again with there none Green Policy, not just cuts now, they want to build on heath land.
As for this matter of Yoga, what real hurm is it doing None at all.
Maybe this girl needs to find a place right next door and have big signs up saying Yoga classes, would this victor complain still i wonder.
Or your bizarre insertion of something about the Green Party for no reason whatsoever.
Yoga is indeed doing no harm, but if some stupid priest doesn't want it in his church hall, that's up to him I guess.
The Green thing was for Free to check up on.
Is it up to the Priest you should be asking, I would of though it was up to the church Committee/council to decide or is this priest riding shot gun over all others
Paramjit Bahia
says...
4:43pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Stillness wrote:Thanks for info. I dare not go to Gurdwara in case God really exists, because for all my sins he/she may drop the celing upon me...
Paramjit Bahia wrote:Nam: Divine Substance, also translated as "God's attributed self".
Stillness wrote:Sorry for my ignorance, what is Nam?
Paramjit Bahia wrote:Well I would guess that you could meditate on Nam whist doing your Yoga. What would YOU say?
Georgem wrote:Yes that could be interesting.
I wonder what Rahit Maryada would say about all this.
Surely you could not be referring to Non Alligned Movement started by Nehru Tito and Nassar, which has now been hijacked by nations like Iran
Well, at least according to The Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee anyway.
In all fairness SGPC is good source of information if anybody is looking into that kind of stuff. At least they helped me in correcting the pure fiction on certain parts of Sikhism that Southy was posting on this site.
sarfhamton
says...
4:52pm Wed 26 Sep 12
cantthinkofone
says...
5:00pm Wed 26 Sep 12
wilson castaway
says...
5:00pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Paramjit Bahia
says...
5:06pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Stillness wrote:What a pity not many people know about Sufi version of Islam. Because Woohabi version suited the big powers even intelligence agencies have been promoting its followers, which has led to many of today's major problem.
"Religion". From the Latin "to rejoin". You have to laugh don't you?
To those who have read the bible but failed to understand it and it's principles saying that focusing on your own well being is not Christian I would point out that without the well people there would not be any people to help the unwell ones. I wonder how many of these people start their prayers with something along the lines of "help me"?
Any organization, religion or otherwise will fail if they base their actions on what was (possibly) said or written thousands of years ago.
Perhaps all religions should think about Rumi's statement "The lamps are different but the light is the same"?
If anyone is wondering he was a 13th century Sufi poet but of course the church will have a fit if they find out that that makes him a Muslim lol.
Some of the Sufi Saints/scholars are also recognised and respected in Sikhism.
Best quote of one often recited in Sikh Gurdwaras basically means 'Let the world go by and mind ones own business'.
Something neither many so called Sikhs practise nor anyone of us is likely to on this site!!!
Georgem
says...
5:09pm Wed 26 Sep 12
southy wrote:Lol you don't learn, do you?
Georgem wrote:No Rahit is a people first name, Reht is not look at the spelling even go up on there web site to check the spelling.
southy wrote:I can't ask Rahit what he thinks, as he is not a person. We all know this! But let's not dwell on that.
freefinker wrote:Ask Rahit what he thinks, but if your on about Sikh Reht Maryada then go to there web site.
Georgem wrote:.. lol.
I wonder what Rahit Maryada would say about all this.
Cue southy, but it will take him a while as he needs to translate the wise man’s words from Sikh to English.
http://www.sgpc.net/
sikhism/sikh-dharma-
manual.html
I see the Greens in Brighton have done it again with there none Green Policy, not just cuts now, they want to build on heath land.
As for this matter of Yoga, what real hurm is it doing None at all.
Maybe this girl needs to find a place right next door and have big signs up saying Yoga classes, would this victor complain still i wonder.
Or your bizarre insertion of something about the Green Party for no reason whatsoever.
Yoga is indeed doing no harm, but if some stupid priest doesn't want it in his church hall, that's up to him I guess.
The Green thing was for Free to check up on.
Is it up to the Priest you should be asking, I would of though it was up to the church Committee/council to decide or is this priest riding shot gun over all others
charlotte7933
says...
5:17pm Wed 26 Sep 12
MGRA wrote:firstly you can not blame every priest for abuse, and if you had your facts right then you would know that it was also c of e vicars to. your reply is all to common of the ignorance in society regarding these terrible crimes. Oh and god is appalled at it which why he exposed the abusers. Not that the yoga subject has anything to do with abuse! and yes you probably would take your child to yoga ignoranse must be bliss eh. yoga is channelling into the dark side. fact!
charlotte7933 wrote:so how come 100s of child molestors were allowed to abuse children on catholic church premises then and then protected from prosecution ?? what does "your god" say about that ?? regards Yoga,,,, you say its unsafe ! I would rather send my children to a Yoga class than allow them to be in the sole care of a catholic priest !! Thats how "safe" yoga is, you are far less likely to get sexually abused.
No one is saying yoga is religous. Yoga is spiritural. Which is why the catholic church can't allow it on church premises. I totally agree with the priest. when doing yoga you are entering into meditation. As father said St Edmunds is a catholic church. Yoga's origon is from the hindu faith. Our God says in scripture that alternative therapies should be avoided theres NO alternative to god. seek god for peace and relaxation. meditate on god. The results are very rewarding. I have had teaching on this and have heard that rather than being a positive excercise it can have very negative affects. There are lots of other forms of exercise that is far safer than yoga. this would be why the priest said no when you said abiut the yoga. pilate is just as good if not better than yoga.
housewife
says...
5:19pm Wed 26 Sep 12
.
If their booking form and system had worked properly THEN it would be a non story.
.
As it is we have bigotry and incompetence working together. Excellent.
charlotte7933
says...
5:22pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Vix1 wrote:at last some one talking sense. blessings vix1
It's because yoga focuses on self! As a Christian you consider yourself last and others first. I know people who have done yoga and they tell you it's all about finding your inner self and communicating with your "core". Now question why the church has banned it!!! It's about time that Christians were allowed to have a voice again!! Good on them for standing up for what the Bible teaches!
Georgem
says...
5:25pm Wed 26 Sep 12
charlotte7933 wrote:Not to throw oil on the fire, but if God was so appalled by the abuse, why did he take so long to expose it?
MGRA wrote:firstly you can not blame every priest for abuse, and if you had your facts right then you would know that it was also c of e vicars to. your reply is all to common of the ignorance in society regarding these terrible crimes. Oh and god is appalled at it which why he exposed the abusers. Not that the yoga subject has anything to do with abuse! and yes you probably would take your child to yoga ignoranse must be bliss eh. yoga is channelling into the dark side. fact!
charlotte7933 wrote:so how come 100s of child molestors were allowed to abuse children on catholic church premises then and then protected from prosecution ?? what does "your god" say about that ?? regards Yoga,,,, you say its unsafe ! I would rather send my children to a Yoga class than allow them to be in the sole care of a catholic priest !! Thats how "safe" yoga is, you are far less likely to get sexually abused.
No one is saying yoga is religous. Yoga is spiritural. Which is why the catholic church can't allow it on church premises. I totally agree with the priest. when doing yoga you are entering into meditation. As father said St Edmunds is a catholic church. Yoga's origon is from the hindu faith. Our God says in scripture that alternative therapies should be avoided theres NO alternative to god. seek god for peace and relaxation. meditate on god. The results are very rewarding. I have had teaching on this and have heard that rather than being a positive excercise it can have very negative affects. There are lots of other forms of exercise that is far safer than yoga. this would be why the priest said no when you said abiut the yoga. pilate is just as good if not better than yoga.
Stillness
says...
5:25pm Wed 26 Sep 12
charlotte7933 wrote:Why bring Star Wars in to it? Did Darth do Yoga?
MGRA wrote:firstly you can not blame every priest for abuse, and if you had your facts right then you would know that it was also c of e vicars to. your reply is all to common of the ignorance in society regarding these terrible crimes. Oh and god is appalled at it which why he exposed the abusers. Not that the yoga subject has anything to do with abuse! and yes you probably would take your child to yoga ignoranse must be bliss eh. yoga is channelling into the dark side. fact!
charlotte7933 wrote:so how come 100s of child molestors were allowed to abuse children on catholic church premises then and then protected from prosecution ?? what does "your god" say about that ?? regards Yoga,,,, you say its unsafe ! I would rather send my children to a Yoga class than allow them to be in the sole care of a catholic priest !! Thats how "safe" yoga is, you are far less likely to get sexually abused.
No one is saying yoga is religous. Yoga is spiritural. Which is why the catholic church can't allow it on church premises. I totally agree with the priest. when doing yoga you are entering into meditation. As father said St Edmunds is a catholic church. Yoga's origon is from the hindu faith. Our God says in scripture that alternative therapies should be avoided theres NO alternative to god. seek god for peace and relaxation. meditate on god. The results are very rewarding. I have had teaching on this and have heard that rather than being a positive excercise it can have very negative affects. There are lots of other forms of exercise that is far safer than yoga. this would be why the priest said no when you said abiut the yoga. pilate is just as good if not better than yoga.
God did not expose the abusers, a priest did. Maybe exposure is another think that should be investigated along with any other dirty habits.
Stillness
says...
5:27pm Wed 26 Sep 12
MisterGrimsdale
says...
5:29pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Stillness wrote:Darth Vader did Yoda? Disgraceful.
charlotte7933 wrote:Why bring Star Wars in to it? Did Darth do Yoga?
MGRA wrote:firstly you can not blame every priest for abuse, and if you had your facts right then you would know that it was also c of e vicars to. your reply is all to common of the ignorance in society regarding these terrible crimes. Oh and god is appalled at it which why he exposed the abusers. Not that the yoga subject has anything to do with abuse! and yes you probably would take your child to yoga ignoranse must be bliss eh. yoga is channelling into the dark side. fact!
charlotte7933 wrote:so how come 100s of child molestors were allowed to abuse children on catholic church premises then and then protected from prosecution ?? what does "your god" say about that ?? regards Yoga,,,, you say its unsafe ! I would rather send my children to a Yoga class than allow them to be in the sole care of a catholic priest !! Thats how "safe" yoga is, you are far less likely to get sexually abused.
No one is saying yoga is religous. Yoga is spiritural. Which is why the catholic church can't allow it on church premises. I totally agree with the priest. when doing yoga you are entering into meditation. As father said St Edmunds is a catholic church. Yoga's origon is from the hindu faith. Our God says in scripture that alternative therapies should be avoided theres NO alternative to god. seek god for peace and relaxation. meditate on god. The results are very rewarding. I have had teaching on this and have heard that rather than being a positive excercise it can have very negative affects. There are lots of other forms of exercise that is far safer than yoga. this would be why the priest said no when you said abiut the yoga. pilate is just as good if not better than yoga.
God did not expose the abusers, a priest did. Maybe exposure is another think that should be investigated along with any other dirty habits.
southy
says...
5:29pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Georgem wrote:Your the one not learning, Go to there personal web site I give you the link again, and take note how they spell it and there is no other way in spelling it.
southy wrote:Lol you don't learn, do you?
Georgem wrote:No Rahit is a people first name, Reht is not look at the spelling even go up on there web site to check the spelling.
southy wrote:I can't ask Rahit what he thinks, as he is not a person. We all know this! But let's not dwell on that.
freefinker wrote:Ask Rahit what he thinks, but if your on about Sikh Reht Maryada then go to there web site.
Georgem wrote:.. lol.
I wonder what Rahit Maryada would say about all this.
Cue southy, but it will take him a while as he needs to translate the wise man’s words from Sikh to English.
http://www.sgpc.net/
sikhism/sikh-dharma-
manual.html
I see the Greens in Brighton have done it again with there none Green Policy, not just cuts now, they want to build on heath land.
As for this matter of Yoga, what real hurm is it doing None at all.
Maybe this girl needs to find a place right next door and have big signs up saying Yoga classes, would this victor complain still i wonder.
Or your bizarre insertion of something about the Green Party for no reason whatsoever.
Yoga is indeed doing no harm, but if some stupid priest doesn't want it in his church hall, that's up to him I guess.
The Green thing was for Free to check up on.
Is it up to the Priest you should be asking, I would of though it was up to the church Committee/council to decide or is this priest riding shot gun over all others
vvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv
http://www.sgpc.net/
sikhism/sikh-dharma-
manual.html
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
^
If you can not take it from me then take it from the people who heads that type of religion.
Then do some research your self and you will find that Rahit is an Arabic name that pre-dates that Religion by 100's of years and older, where as Reht is an Hindu word.
ac1211
says...
5:29pm Wed 26 Sep 12
It is a church after all and to me it wouldn't seem right as yoga uses meditation as well as exercises and where it may not be a religion it is still in a different mindset to the christian belief and lets face it that's why they were built in the first place for people to come together and worship.
i personally would be against everyday keep fit classes taking place in a church because it starts to undermine its importance.and by the way i have not been to church since i was a kid so im not coming from a religious standpoint.
Georgem
says...
5:31pm Wed 26 Sep 12
MisterGrimsdale wrote:Rule 34 never fails, so this must exist somewhere.
Stillness wrote:Darth Vader did Yoda? Disgraceful.
charlotte7933 wrote:Why bring Star Wars in to it? Did Darth do Yoga?
MGRA wrote:firstly you can not blame every priest for abuse, and if you had your facts right then you would know that it was also c of e vicars to. your reply is all to common of the ignorance in society regarding these terrible crimes. Oh and god is appalled at it which why he exposed the abusers. Not that the yoga subject has anything to do with abuse! and yes you probably would take your child to yoga ignoranse must be bliss eh. yoga is channelling into the dark side. fact!
charlotte7933 wrote:so how come 100s of child molestors were allowed to abuse children on catholic church premises then and then protected from prosecution ?? what does "your god" say about that ?? regards Yoga,,,, you say its unsafe ! I would rather send my children to a Yoga class than allow them to be in the sole care of a catholic priest !! Thats how "safe" yoga is, you are far less likely to get sexually abused.
No one is saying yoga is religous. Yoga is spiritural. Which is why the catholic church can't allow it on church premises. I totally agree with the priest. when doing yoga you are entering into meditation. As father said St Edmunds is a catholic church. Yoga's origon is from the hindu faith. Our God says in scripture that alternative therapies should be avoided theres NO alternative to god. seek god for peace and relaxation. meditate on god. The results are very rewarding. I have had teaching on this and have heard that rather than being a positive excercise it can have very negative affects. There are lots of other forms of exercise that is far safer than yoga. this would be why the priest said no when you said abiut the yoga. pilate is just as good if not better than yoga.
God did not expose the abusers, a priest did. Maybe exposure is another think that should be investigated along with any other dirty habits.
freefinker
says...
5:33pm Wed 26 Sep 12
southy wrote:.. as I keep telling you southy, over and over again, I have NO CONNECTION with the Green Party.
Georgem wrote:No Rahit is a people first name, Reht is not look at the spelling even go up on there web site to check the spelling.
southy wrote:I can't ask Rahit what he thinks, as he is not a person. We all know this! But let's not dwell on that.
freefinker wrote:Ask Rahit what he thinks, but if your on about Sikh Reht Maryada then go to there web site.
Georgem wrote:.. lol.
I wonder what Rahit Maryada would say about all this.
Cue southy, but it will take him a while as he needs to translate the wise man’s words from Sikh to English.
http://www.sgpc.net/
sikhism/sikh-dharma-
manual.html
I see the Greens in Brighton have done it again with there none Green Policy, not just cuts now, they want to build on heath land.
As for this matter of Yoga, what real hurm is it doing None at all.
Maybe this girl needs to find a place right next door and have big signs up saying Yoga classes, would this victor complain still i wonder.
Or your bizarre insertion of something about the Green Party for no reason whatsoever.
Yoga is indeed doing no harm, but if some stupid priest doesn't want it in his church hall, that's up to him I guess.
The Green thing was for Free to check up on.
Is it up to the Priest you should be asking, I would of though it was up to the church Committee/council to decide or is this priest riding shot gun over all others
Seems to be a deluded obsession on your part.
Georgem
says...
5:34pm Wed 26 Sep 12
southy wrote:ZZZZZZZZZZ
Georgem wrote:Your the one not learning, Go to there personal web site I give you the link again, and take note how they spell it and there is no other way in spelling it.
southy wrote:Lol you don't learn, do you?
Georgem wrote:No Rahit is a people first name, Reht is not look at the spelling even go up on there web site to check the spelling.
southy wrote:I can't ask Rahit what he thinks, as he is not a person. We all know this! But let's not dwell on that.
freefinker wrote:Ask Rahit what he thinks, but if your on about Sikh Reht Maryada then go to there web site.
Georgem wrote:.. lol.
I wonder what Rahit Maryada would say about all this.
Cue southy, but it will take him a while as he needs to translate the wise man’s words from Sikh to English.
http://www.sgpc.net/
sikhism/sikh-dharma-
manual.html
I see the Greens in Brighton have done it again with there none Green Policy, not just cuts now, they want to build on heath land.
As for this matter of Yoga, what real hurm is it doing None at all.
Maybe this girl needs to find a place right next door and have big signs up saying Yoga classes, would this victor complain still i wonder.
Or your bizarre insertion of something about the Green Party for no reason whatsoever.
Yoga is indeed doing no harm, but if some stupid priest doesn't want it in his church hall, that's up to him I guess.
The Green thing was for Free to check up on.
Is it up to the Priest you should be asking, I would of though it was up to the church Committee/council to decide or is this priest riding shot gun over all others
vvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv
http://www.sgpc.net/
sikhism/sikh-dharma-
manual.html
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
^
If you can not take it from me then take it from the people who heads that type of religion.
Then do some research your self and you will find that Rahit is an Arabic name that pre-dates that Religion by 100's of years and older, where as Reht is an Hindu word.
Give up. You lost that one several months ago. Quite why you want to go through that all over again is beyond me.
freefinker
says...
5:39pm Wed 26 Sep 12
ac1211 wrote:.. no, it's not a church; it's a church hall.
Call me old fashioned but to me a church is a sacred place where people can go to seek comfort and refuge from lifes troubles whether they believe in god or not,however i can understand exactly where the church is coming from on this and i think the decision not to allow yoga classes to take place there is the right one.
It is a church after all and to me it wouldn't seem right as yoga uses meditation as well as exercises and where it may not be a religion it is still in a different mindset to the christian belief and lets face it that's why they were built in the first place for people to come together and worship.
i personally would be against everyday keep fit classes taking place in a church because it starts to undermine its importance.and by the way i have not been to church since i was a kid so im not coming from a religious standpoint.
Do you not know the difference?
freefinker
says...
5:47pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Georgem wrote:.. agreed.
southy wrote:ZZZZZZZZZZ
Georgem wrote:Your the one not learning, Go to there personal web site I give you the link again, and take note how they spell it and there is no other way in spelling it.
southy wrote:Lol you don't learn, do you?
Georgem wrote:No Rahit is a people first name, Reht is not look at the spelling even go up on there web site to check the spelling.
southy wrote:I can't ask Rahit what he thinks, as he is not a person. We all know this! But let's not dwell on that.
freefinker wrote:Ask Rahit what he thinks, but if your on about Sikh Reht Maryada then go to there web site.
Georgem wrote:.. lol.
I wonder what Rahit Maryada would say about all this.
Cue southy, but it will take him a while as he needs to translate the wise man’s words from Sikh to English.
http://www.sgpc.net/
sikhism/sikh-dharma-
manual.html
I see the Greens in Brighton have done it again with there none Green Policy, not just cuts now, they want to build on heath land.
As for this matter of Yoga, what real hurm is it doing None at all.
Maybe this girl needs to find a place right next door and have big signs up saying Yoga classes, would this victor complain still i wonder.
Or your bizarre insertion of something about the Green Party for no reason whatsoever.
Yoga is indeed doing no harm, but if some stupid priest doesn't want it in his church hall, that's up to him I guess.
The Green thing was for Free to check up on.
Is it up to the Priest you should be asking, I would of though it was up to the church Committee/council to decide or is this priest riding shot gun over all others
vvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv
http://www.sgpc.net/
sikhism/sikh-dharma-
manual.html
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
^
If you can not take it from me then take it from the people who heads that type of religion.
Then do some research your self and you will find that Rahit is an Arabic name that pre-dates that Religion by 100's of years and older, where as Reht is an Hindu word.
Give up. You lost that one several months ago. Quite why you want to go through that all over again is beyond me.
southy, you need to look at what Paramjit Bahia says; 4:43pm Wed 26 Sep 12, above.
You see, even he knows you are again talking total nonsense.
Paramjit Bahia
says...
5:56pm Wed 26 Sep 12
I don’t know if Southy ever learns or not, he most certainly does not give up and definitely does not ever admit that he could be wrong.
Southy, I have even spoken to you in person, and most humbly requested you to stop trying to appear ‘know it all Charlie’.
None of us is perfect, we all make mistakes. But if and when corrected most of us tend to own it. I believe your approach is undermining lots of your hard work and could even be damaging your Socialist Party, for which you in fact work very hard.
I am once again posting copy of e-mail from SGPC on the subject of pure fiction you had posted, but sadly you are still trying to hide behind this or that name and how these could be spelt, thus trying to cover up the original whopper of your own imagination.
So as a fellow socialist I am once again requesting you to stop treating all of us on this site as brain dead people. Even many of your so called capitalists do not try to treat people in this manner.
For the sake of record I have once again posted copy of e-mail from SGPC office, proving you to be wrong. (Only top part of e-mail is missing because it basically is in Punjabi as form of polite address:
Apropos your email dated Aug, 6, 2012, Please be informed that 'Sikh
Rehat Maryada' is not at all named after any person whatsoever. You
please send your complete mailing address enabling us to have a copy
of the same in English dispatched to you, wherein you would find how it
came into being.
(Note: You can also read/download it from our website www.sgpc.net)
Thanking you..
Yours Sincerely,
(Joginder Singh)
OSD to President, SGPC.
ac1211
says...
6:01pm Wed 26 Sep 12
freefinker wrote:To be honest i don't see what difference it makes,its the same organisation and its their right to say what goes on there,they own the property and they say what goes.
ac1211 wrote:.. no, it's not a church; it's a church hall.
Call me old fashioned but to me a church is a sacred place where people can go to seek comfort and refuge from lifes troubles whether they believe in god or not,however i can understand exactly where the church is coming from on this and i think the decision not to allow yoga classes to take place there is the right one.
It is a church after all and to me it wouldn't seem right as yoga uses meditation as well as exercises and where it may not be a religion it is still in a different mindset to the christian belief and lets face it that's why they were built in the first place for people to come together and worship.
i personally would be against everyday keep fit classes taking place in a church because it starts to undermine its importance.and by the way i have not been to church since i was a kid so im not coming from a religious standpoint.
Do you not know the difference?
Stillness
says...
6:01pm Wed 26 Sep 12
ac1211 wrote:Dear Mr Oldfashioned.
Call me old fashioned but to me a church is a sacred place where people can go to seek comfort and refuge from lifes troubles whether they believe in god or not,however i can understand exactly where the church is coming from on this and i think the decision not to allow yoga classes to take place there is the right one.
It is a church after all and to me it wouldn't seem right as yoga uses meditation as well as exercises and where it may not be a religion it is still in a different mindset to the christian belief and lets face it that's why they were built in the first place for people to come together and worship.
i personally would be against everyday keep fit classes taking place in a church because it starts to undermine its importance.and by the way i have not been to church since i was a kid so im not coming from a religious standpoint.
The word church originally meant belong to the lord as in the lord of the land and not a sacred place. Also as people are keen on saying, one can be a member of a church. Now you must admit that it would be very hard to be a member of a building. What they are referring to is the organization. They are a member of an organization a bit like a supporters club. If you want to find somewhere sacred just look under you feet. It's called planet Earth, we all live on it and if we all remember that it is as sacred as any place you will ever find and act accordingly we would not have a need for the supporters clubs and the bloody committees that go with them.
freefinker
says...
6:15pm Wed 26 Sep 12
ac1211 wrote:.. yes, it's within their rights to refuse to allow yoga in the church hall - agreed.
freefinker wrote:To be honest i don't see what difference it makes,its the same organisation and its their right to say what goes on there,they own the property and they say what goes.
ac1211 wrote:.. no, it's not a church; it's a church hall.
Call me old fashioned but to me a church is a sacred place where people can go to seek comfort and refuge from lifes troubles whether they believe in god or not,however i can understand exactly where the church is coming from on this and i think the decision not to allow yoga classes to take place there is the right one.
It is a church after all and to me it wouldn't seem right as yoga uses meditation as well as exercises and where it may not be a religion it is still in a different mindset to the christian belief and lets face it that's why they were built in the first place for people to come together and worship.
i personally would be against everyday keep fit classes taking place in a church because it starts to undermine its importance.and by the way i have not been to church since i was a kid so im not coming from a religious standpoint.
Do you not know the difference?
However your original post clearly and on several occasions mentions a 'church' - not a church hall.
If you can't see the difference between the two, and the activities they respectively entertain, then you don't have much of a clue on the subject under discussion.
charlotte7933
says...
6:26pm Wed 26 Sep 12
BenjiWinsor wrote:we said
eurogordi wrote:hear hear!
I fully support the decision taken by this priest and have personal concerns about those churches that do allow practices which started in other religions.
None of us are perfect, whatever religion, meditation or relaxation we choose to follow, but the fundamentals of yoga do conflict with the teachings of Christianity.
Well done, Father Chandler, and I very much hope and pray that other Christian leaders and churches will follow your example.
As another contributor has already written "It's about time that Christians were allowed to have a voice again!! Good on them for standing up for what the Bible teaches!"
Incidentally, if this story was about a mosque refusing a church choir to to hire a room for rehearsals,, I am sure that no one would be criticising the decision of Islamic leaders for upholding their belief structure!
charlotte7933
says...
6:26pm Wed 26 Sep 12
BenjiWinsor wrote:we said
eurogordi wrote:hear hear!
I fully support the decision taken by this priest and have personal concerns about those churches that do allow practices which started in other religions.
None of us are perfect, whatever religion, meditation or relaxation we choose to follow, but the fundamentals of yoga do conflict with the teachings of Christianity.
Well done, Father Chandler, and I very much hope and pray that other Christian leaders and churches will follow your example.
As another contributor has already written "It's about time that Christians were allowed to have a voice again!! Good on them for standing up for what the Bible teaches!"
Incidentally, if this story was about a mosque refusing a church choir to to hire a room for rehearsals,, I am sure that no one would be criticising the decision of Islamic leaders for upholding their belief structure!
Stillness
says...
6:32pm Wed 26 Sep 12
eurogordi
says...
6:55pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Did Cori already know that the church would refuse her teaching yoga which is why she failed to disclose her true intentions when the booking was made? Could this be a very clever publicity trick on her part, especially as the classes have now been moved to a local Hindu temple?
At least Father Chandler has been honest in stating the church's opposition to yoga, whereas Ms. Withell now appears to have been less than honest by failing to reveal her true intentions!
S Pance
says...
7:22pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Whilst true Yoga originated as a form of transcendental meditation and is thus Hindu in origin, most modern day "yoga" is purely a relaxation class which bares no relation to the Hindu ritual.
Besides, the Roman Catholic Church has adopted many rituals from other religions and called them their own so in my opinion this is a little two faced.
In any event, the RC church should be tolerant of the beliefs of others, rather than confrontational as they appear to be in this case.
Stillness
says...
7:27pm Wed 26 Sep 12
eurogordi wrote:WOW! The distance you can jump you should try out for the Olympics.
This story has just been featured on BBC South Today and it appears that the instructor, Cori Withell, booked the hall for pilates and it was only later that the church discovered the classes would combine pilates AND yoga.
Did Cori already know that the church would refuse her teaching yoga which is why she failed to disclose her true intentions when the booking was made? Could this be a very clever publicity trick on her part, especially as the classes have now been moved to a local Hindu temple?
At least Father Chandler has been honest in stating the church's opposition to yoga, whereas Ms. Withell now appears to have been less than honest by failing to reveal her true intentions!
One thing is for sure, if i ever want a publicity stunt organized I go to Cori rather than Father Chandler. His response to this is going to alienate the catholic church even further and with it's recent "troubles" it could well do without any more.
bazzeroz
says...
7:31pm Wed 26 Sep 12
GrahamTheRetired
says...
7:56pm Wed 26 Sep 12
The hypocritical Catholic Church is trying to raise its ugly head again. In view of all the current bad press with its covering up of child rape by its priests (a very high proportion of supposedly celibate incumbants). They would do well to keep a low profile. This doesn't even begin to raise the questions of the 'Dark Ages' when the Church ruled and tortured and murdered anyone who disagreed with their view of (an unproveable) 'Truth'.
The inquisition, the Holy Wars (like Muslim Jihad), the witch burning, the terrible treatment of women etc. all add up to something to be avoided rather than be proud and pompous about your religion. Christianity has thousand of denominations, who all interpret scripture and dogma differently. So who are this Church and minister to criticize other religions?
The sooner all religions dissappear, the better, as they can't keep their bronze-age opinions to themselves.
Scrutinizer
says...
8:05pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Sir Ad E Noid
says...
8:06pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Stillness
says...
8:18pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Sir Ad E Noid wrote:Oh, the congregation took a vote. I must have missed that bit.
It's their Church Hall and they can say and do what they want. You have had more than your fifteen mins of mock indignation. Please, now, shut up and no more stupid bits on South Today. Hilarious.
charlotte7933
says...
8:37pm Wed 26 Sep 12
charlotte7933 wrote:well said
BenjiWinsor wrote:we said
eurogordi wrote:hear hear!
I fully support the decision taken by this priest and have personal concerns about those churches that do allow practices which started in other religions.
None of us are perfect, whatever religion, meditation or relaxation we choose to follow, but the fundamentals of yoga do conflict with the teachings of Christianity.
Well done, Father Chandler, and I very much hope and pray that other Christian leaders and churches will follow your example.
As another contributor has already written "It's about time that Christians were allowed to have a voice again!! Good on them for standing up for what the Bible teaches!"
Incidentally, if this story was about a mosque refusing a church choir to to hire a room for rehearsals,, I am sure that no one would be criticising the decision of Islamic leaders for upholding their belief structure!
arthur boutfaith
says...
8:56pm Wed 26 Sep 12
MGRA
says...
9:16pm Wed 26 Sep 12
charlotte7933 wrote:you are living in a fantasy land... get real... No CofE officers protected and harboured child rapists.... The catholic church is a dangerous place for children, anyone who says otherwise is an idiot.
MGRA wrote:firstly you can not blame every priest for abuse, and if you had your facts right then you would know that it was also c of e vicars to. your reply is all to common of the ignorance in society regarding these terrible crimes. Oh and god is appalled at it which why he exposed the abusers. Not that the yoga subject has anything to do with abuse! and yes you probably would take your child to yoga ignoranse must be bliss eh. yoga is channelling into the dark side. fact!
charlotte7933 wrote:so how come 100s of child molestors were allowed to abuse children on catholic church premises then and then protected from prosecution ?? what does "your god" say about that ?? regards Yoga,,,, you say its unsafe ! I would rather send my children to a Yoga class than allow them to be in the sole care of a catholic priest !! Thats how "safe" yoga is, you are far less likely to get sexually abused.
No one is saying yoga is religous. Yoga is spiritural. Which is why the catholic church can't allow it on church premises. I totally agree with the priest. when doing yoga you are entering into meditation. As father said St Edmunds is a catholic church. Yoga's origon is from the hindu faith. Our God says in scripture that alternative therapies should be avoided theres NO alternative to god. seek god for peace and relaxation. meditate on god. The results are very rewarding. I have had teaching on this and have heard that rather than being a positive excercise it can have very negative affects. There are lots of other forms of exercise that is far safer than yoga. this would be why the priest said no when you said abiut the yoga. pilate is just as good if not better than yoga.
G0Rf
says...
9:18pm Wed 26 Sep 12
NOT a church of england christian church???
G0Rf
says...
9:18pm Wed 26 Sep 12
NOT a church of england christian church???
G0Rf
says...
9:18pm Wed 26 Sep 12
NOT a church of england christian church???
G0Rf
says...
9:18pm Wed 26 Sep 12
NOT a church of england christian church???
G0Rf
says...
9:18pm Wed 26 Sep 12
NOT a church of england christian church???
G0Rf
says...
9:18pm Wed 26 Sep 12
NOT a church of england christian church???
MGRA
says...
9:19pm Wed 26 Sep 12
ac1211 wrote:call me old fashioned but to me a church is not a place where children should be raped by priests.
Call me old fashioned but to me a church is a sacred place where people can go to seek comfort and refuge from lifes troubles whether they believe in god or not,however i can understand exactly where the church is coming from on this and i think the decision not to allow yoga classes to take place there is the right one.
It is a church after all and to me it wouldn't seem right as yoga uses meditation as well as exercises and where it may not be a religion it is still in a different mindset to the christian belief and lets face it that's why they were built in the first place for people to come together and worship.
i personally would be against everyday keep fit classes taking place in a church because it starts to undermine its importance.and by the way i have not been to church since i was a kid so im not coming from a religious standpoint.
G0Rf
says...
9:31pm Wed 26 Sep 12
S Pance
says...
9:31pm Wed 26 Sep 12
However, the yoga being practiced here is the westernised version, essentially a glorified excercise/relaxation class with no connection to the Hindu religion, save for the name.
Georgem
says...
9:32pm Wed 26 Sep 12
MGRA wrote:We get it. You once read a story about child abuse within the church. Well done.
ac1211 wrote:call me old fashioned but to me a church is not a place where children should be raped by priests.
Call me old fashioned but to me a church is a sacred place where people can go to seek comfort and refuge from lifes troubles whether they believe in god or not,however i can understand exactly where the church is coming from on this and i think the decision not to allow yoga classes to take place there is the right one.
It is a church after all and to me it wouldn't seem right as yoga uses meditation as well as exercises and where it may not be a religion it is still in a different mindset to the christian belief and lets face it that's why they were built in the first place for people to come together and worship.
i personally would be against everyday keep fit classes taking place in a church because it starts to undermine its importance.and by the way i have not been to church since i was a kid so im not coming from a religious standpoint.
When you've mastered basic logic, and correcting faulty reasoning, let us know. Start with finding out what the association fallacy is.
MGRA
says...
10:42pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Turtlebay
says...
10:48pm Wed 26 Sep 12
No one is trying to force the non believers to believe in God, therefore likewise the practitioners of non Christian worship should find alternative premises to practice theit beliefs.
MGRA
says...
11:10pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Turtlebay wrote:you are a moron who can not read. Read the article again and then comment, this time without invented garbage. Pilates takes "spirituality" as much as western contemporary yoga, you are as ignorant and the bigot priest.....
The facts are, this woman booked a room for use with the Pilates course only. After booking the room it came out that she was going to be using it for other things including teaching spiritual yoga which goes against the teaching of Christianity.
No one is trying to force the non believers to believe in God, therefore likewise the practitioners of non Christian worship should find alternative premises to practice theit beliefs.
Stephen J
says...
11:24pm Wed 26 Sep 12
Turtlebay wrote:What "beliefs"? Yoga as practised in this context is not dependant upon nor promotes any beliefs at all. Yoga is no more Hindu than a roast Sunday dinner is Christian. Where do you get this "non-Christian worship" stuff from?
The facts are, this woman booked a room for use with the Pilates course only. After booking the room it came out that she was going to be using it for other things including teaching spiritual yoga which goes against the teaching of Christianity.
No one is trying to force the non believers to believe in God, therefore likewise the practitioners of non Christian worship should find alternative premises to practice theit beliefs.
kingnotail
says...
11:31pm Wed 26 Sep 12
mack chinnon
says...
12:02am Thu 27 Sep 12
MGRA
says...
12:10am Thu 27 Sep 12
kingnotail wrote:ah , but that is a "weakness" to be hidden and "hushed" up.... does Yoga now seem irrelevant ? Yes it does and well done Echo for allowing us to point out this disgusting hypocracy. Hide paedophilia, but jump up and down and "ban" Yoga !?!?! Way to go Catholicism..... WHY on earth are the pews empty ?? any ideas ??
The catholic church, where homosexuality is one of the worst sins possible. Unless of course you are molesting young boys..
TheJoiners
says...
12:36am Thu 27 Sep 12
Despise EVERYTHING the catholic church stands for, vile and corrupt at every turn.
Georgem
says...
8:10am Thu 27 Sep 12
MGRA wrote:Lol
you don't get it. I did not "once" read a story about child abuse... I have read "over 50 accounts" of child abuse. the catholic church has abused 1000s of children. they are "accounts", not "stories", Your denial of the reality is a perfect illustration of why the hundreds of catholic perverts have been hidden by the church for so long.... you think they are "stories",, which is frankly disgusting
Georgem
says...
8:10am Thu 27 Sep 12
MGRA wrote:What an angry little boy you are.
Turtlebay wrote:you are a moron who can not read. Read the article again and then comment, this time without invented garbage. Pilates takes "spirituality" as much as western contemporary yoga, you are as ignorant and the bigot priest.....
The facts are, this woman booked a room for use with the Pilates course only. After booking the room it came out that she was going to be using it for other things including teaching spiritual yoga which goes against the teaching of Christianity.
No one is trying to force the non believers to believe in God, therefore likewise the practitioners of non Christian worship should find alternative premises to practice theit beliefs.
MGRA
says...
9:05am Thu 27 Sep 12
Georgem wrote:hilarious isn't it..... glad you find it so funny.... you probably have a hundred and one excuses for the 100s of paedophile catholic priests and no doubt can think of many reasons why their countless victims were "to blame".... keep going you are the perfect advert for why people should avoid the catholic church and its sins. Ah but for you and the rest of the brainwashed sheep, those were just "stories"....
MGRA wrote:Lol
you don't get it. I did not "once" read a story about child abuse... I have read "over 50 accounts" of child abuse. the catholic church has abused 1000s of children. they are "accounts", not "stories", Your denial of the reality is a perfect illustration of why the hundreds of catholic perverts have been hidden by the church for so long.... you think they are "stories",, which is frankly disgusting
Stillness
says...
9:23am Thu 27 Sep 12
MGRA wrote:Is MGRA a new type of super bug that effects brain tissue? The church is an organization, it is neither good nor bad, it does not have sins. It has members that have committed sins. You should be careful how many people you are painting with that big broad brush of yours.
Georgem wrote:hilarious isn't it..... glad you find it so funny.... you probably have a hundred and one excuses for the 100s of paedophile catholic priests and no doubt can think of many reasons why their countless victims were "to blame".... keep going you are the perfect advert for why people should avoid the catholic church and its sins. Ah but for you and the rest of the brainwashed sheep, those were just "stories"....
MGRA wrote:Lol
you don't get it. I did not "once" read a story about child abuse... I have read "over 50 accounts" of child abuse. the catholic church has abused 1000s of children. they are "accounts", not "stories", Your denial of the reality is a perfect illustration of why the hundreds of catholic perverts have been hidden by the church for so long.... you think they are "stories",, which is frankly disgusting
Your outburst at Georgem shows that you have missed the point. Ironic that the original meaning of sin was "to miss the mark".
Georgem
says...
9:35am Thu 27 Sep 12
MGRA wrote:Even funnier! Keep up the good work. It's been a long time since I had my very own jester.
Georgem wrote:hilarious isn't it..... glad you find it so funny.... you probably have a hundred and one excuses for the 100s of paedophile catholic priests and no doubt can think of many reasons why their countless victims were "to blame".... keep going you are the perfect advert for why people should avoid the catholic church and its sins. Ah but for you and the rest of the brainwashed sheep, those were just "stories"....
MGRA wrote:Lol
you don't get it. I did not "once" read a story about child abuse... I have read "over 50 accounts" of child abuse. the catholic church has abused 1000s of children. they are "accounts", not "stories", Your denial of the reality is a perfect illustration of why the hundreds of catholic perverts have been hidden by the church for so long.... you think they are "stories",, which is frankly disgusting
Georgem
says...
9:37am Thu 27 Sep 12
Stillness wrote:Well put.
MGRA wrote:Is MGRA a new type of super bug that effects brain tissue? The church is an organization, it is neither good nor bad, it does not have sins. It has members that have committed sins. You should be careful how many people you are painting with that big broad brush of yours.
Georgem wrote:hilarious isn't it..... glad you find it so funny.... you probably have a hundred and one excuses for the 100s of paedophile catholic priests and no doubt can think of many reasons why their countless victims were "to blame".... keep going you are the perfect advert for why people should avoid the catholic church and its sins. Ah but for you and the rest of the brainwashed sheep, those were just "stories"....
MGRA wrote:Lol
you don't get it. I did not "once" read a story about child abuse... I have read "over 50 accounts" of child abuse. the catholic church has abused 1000s of children. they are "accounts", not "stories", Your denial of the reality is a perfect illustration of why the hundreds of catholic perverts have been hidden by the church for so long.... you think they are "stories",, which is frankly disgusting
Your outburst at Georgem shows that you have missed the point. Ironic that the original meaning of sin was "to miss the mark".
Goldenwight
says...
9:45am Thu 27 Sep 12
eurogordi wrote:You have personal concerns about those churches which allow practises which started in other religions.
I fully support the decision taken by this priest and have personal concerns about those churches that do allow practices which started in other religions.
None of us are perfect, whatever religion, meditation or relaxation we choose to follow, but the fundamentals of yoga do conflict with the teachings of Christianity.
Well done, Father Chandler, and I very much hope and pray that other Christian leaders and churches will follow your example.
As another contributor has already written "It's about time that Christians were allowed to have a voice again!! Good on them for standing up for what the Bible teaches!"
Incidentally, if this story was about a mosque refusing a church choir to to hire a room for rehearsals,, I am sure that no one would be criticising the decision of Islamic leaders for upholding their belief structure!
You must have serious problems with Christianity, then, rooted as it is in Judaeism. Not to mention the pagan spiritual elements which were later incorporated in Northern Europe.
Or would this be a case of being selective in your interpretation of the Word of God. Much as the
Spanish Inquisition and the Ku Klux Klan were rather picky about how THEY interpreted it. But that is OK, because they were Christians after all.
badengk1
says...
10:09am Thu 27 Sep 12
Georgem
says...
10:13am Thu 27 Sep 12
badengk1 wrote:Huh? People generally stop going to church because they stop being religious. If someone still believes in these silly superstitions, but decides not to go to church because of trivial matters like this, they're fools.
Its in their church hall. Its not going to impose on any religious goings on within the church its self. What happens when come theif comes along and nicks the lead off the building, maybe the money recieved for the hire of the hall can go towards the up keep of the church. No wonder I know no one appart from a few of my nans friends who attend church if they are so short sighted and fickle like that. makes me want to go to church even less now.
MGRA
says...
10:52am Thu 27 Sep 12
Georgem wrote:yes how foolish to see bigotry as reason to steer clear of the Catholic church.... so apart from trivial matters like that, I assume you mean matters like millions of deaths from aids directly attributed to the policies of the Catholic church when you talk about non-trivial matters !? or is that another "story". Its funny how fools find it so easy to spot fools.
badengk1 wrote:Huh? People generally stop going to church because they stop being religious. If someone still believes in these silly superstitions, but decides not to go to church because of trivial matters like this, they're fools.
Its in their church hall. Its not going to impose on any religious goings on within the church its self. What happens when come theif comes along and nicks the lead off the building, maybe the money recieved for the hire of the hall can go towards the up keep of the church. No wonder I know no one appart from a few of my nans friends who attend church if they are so short sighted and fickle like that. makes me want to go to church even less now.
freefinker
says...
10:55am Thu 27 Sep 12
You really do need to take his advise.
rich the stitch
says...
11:03am Thu 27 Sep 12
freefinker wrote:Funny how he's gone quiet.
.. southy, I do hope you return to this story and read Paramjit at 5:56pm Wed 26 Sep 12, above. You really do need to take his advise.
I also like the fact he posted a link on here, but I'm sure he's told us all countless times that any link that anyone else puts on here is wrong or been hacked. Interesting how the hackers from all over the world have nothing better to do than change facts/ figures just to make Southy look foolish.
Georgem
says...
11:04am Thu 27 Sep 12
MGRA wrote:Blah blah blah blah. Good to see you've declared war on straw. Keep up the good work.
Georgem wrote:yes how foolish to see bigotry as reason to steer clear of the Catholic church.... so apart from trivial matters like that, I assume you mean matters like millions of deaths from aids directly attributed to the policies of the Catholic church when you talk about non-trivial matters !? or is that another "story". Its funny how fools find it so easy to spot fools.
badengk1 wrote:Huh? People generally stop going to church because they stop being religious. If someone still believes in these silly superstitions, but decides not to go to church because of trivial matters like this, they're fools.
Its in their church hall. Its not going to impose on any religious goings on within the church its self. What happens when come theif comes along and nicks the lead off the building, maybe the money recieved for the hire of the hall can go towards the up keep of the church. No wonder I know no one appart from a few of my nans friends who attend church if they are so short sighted and fickle like that. makes me want to go to church even less now.
Georgem
says...
11:07am Thu 27 Sep 12
rich the stitch wrote:The really amusing part is, the link he's posted quite clearly proves him to be wrong on that matter.
freefinker wrote:Funny how he's gone quiet.
.. southy, I do hope you return to this story and read Paramjit at 5:56pm Wed 26 Sep 12, above. You really do need to take his advise.
I also like the fact he posted a link on here, but I'm sure he's told us all countless times that any link that anyone else puts on here is wrong or been hacked. Interesting how the hackers from all over the world have nothing better to do than change facts/ figures just to make Southy look foolish.
MGRA
says...
11:14am Thu 27 Sep 12
What an idiot. Thats not how it works in the real world... No doubt sheople like GeorgeM with his hear no, see no , speak no outlook will lap up every detail of why simple courtesy went out of the window.
cliffwalker
says...
11:14am Thu 27 Sep 12
Chas O'Bursledon wrote:It seems to me that in the terms of your owncontribution you condemn yourself.
Another stupid example of how hate and bigotry never solved a problem. I am proud of my atheism. My moral compass does not allow me to hate or condemn a person I do not know for their beliefs. I do not judge them unless they impose or try to impose their belief system on me. Yoga does no harm. It is not a religion or a martial art. I do not condemn Catholicism but a very stupid man who is coincidentally a priest. I would worry about the example he is setting his congregation.
MGRA
says...
11:17am Thu 27 Sep 12
Georgem wrote:baaa baaaaaaaaaaaaaaa baaaa
MGRA wrote:Blah blah blah blah. Good to see you've declared war on straw. Keep up the good work.
Georgem wrote:yes how foolish to see bigotry as reason to steer clear of the Catholic church.... so apart from trivial matters like that, I assume you mean matters like millions of deaths from aids directly attributed to the policies of the Catholic church when you talk about non-trivial matters !? or is that another "story". Its funny how fools find it so easy to spot fools.
badengk1 wrote:Huh? People generally stop going to church because they stop being religious. If someone still believes in these silly superstitions, but decides not to go to church because of trivial matters like this, they're fools.
Its in their church hall. Its not going to impose on any religious goings on within the church its self. What happens when come theif comes along and nicks the lead off the building, maybe the money recieved for the hire of the hall can go towards the up keep of the church. No wonder I know no one appart from a few of my nans friends who attend church if they are so short sighted and fickle like that. makes me want to go to church even less now.
Georgem
says...
11:18am Thu 27 Sep 12
MGRA wrote:What "hear no, see no, speak no" outlook would that be, then? I've made no reference to any of that whatsoever. You're filling in the gaps in your own lack of reading comprehension. Carry on, though, it's quite amusing.
I heard yesterday the fitness instructor recieved no detailed explanation when they cancelled her booking. Then incredibly on the radio the "father" said he was suprised that she went to the media rather than contact him to ask why it was cancelled.
What an idiot. Thats not how it works in the real world... No doubt sheople like GeorgeM with his hear no, see no , speak no outlook will lap up every detail of why simple courtesy went out of the window.
Georgem
says...
11:19am Thu 27 Sep 12
MGRA wrote:You automatically lose 1000 internet points by using the term "sheople". Only complete tits use that these days.
Georgem wrote:baaa baaaaaaaaaaaaaaa baaaa
MGRA wrote:Blah blah blah blah. Good to see you've declared war on straw. Keep up the good work.
Georgem wrote:yes how foolish to see bigotry as reason to steer clear of the Catholic church.... so apart from trivial matters like that, I assume you mean matters like millions of deaths from aids directly attributed to the policies of the Catholic church when you talk about non-trivial matters !? or is that another "story". Its funny how fools find it so easy to spot fools.
badengk1 wrote:Huh? People generally stop going to church because they stop being religious. If someone still believes in these silly superstitions, but decides not to go to church because of trivial matters like this, they're fools.
Its in their church hall. Its not going to impose on any religious goings on within the church its self. What happens when come theif comes along and nicks the lead off the building, maybe the money recieved for the hire of the hall can go towards the up keep of the church. No wonder I know no one appart from a few of my nans friends who attend church if they are so short sighted and fickle like that. makes me want to go to church even less now.
MGRA
says...
11:46am Thu 27 Sep 12
Georgem wrote:does not sound very christian of you George,,, using a misogynist term like that ! shame on you, one for the confessional box perheps... Anyway its easy to tie up supposed "christian" catholics in a knot with the question they can never answer without making themselves look stupid and contradicting their so called religion.... "is it ok to say 'Jesus' ! after you sneeze".... ?
MGRA wrote:You automatically lose 1000 internet points by using the term "sheople". Only complete tits use that these days.
Georgem wrote:baaa baaaaaaaaaaaaaaa baaaa
MGRA wrote:Blah blah blah blah. Good to see you've declared war on straw. Keep up the good work.
Georgem wrote:yes how foolish to see bigotry as reason to steer clear of the Catholic church.... so apart from trivial matters like that, I assume you mean matters like millions of deaths from aids directly attributed to the policies of the Catholic church when you talk about non-trivial matters !? or is that another "story". Its funny how fools find it so easy to spot fools.
badengk1 wrote:Huh? People generally stop going to church because they stop being religious. If someone still believes in these silly superstitions, but decides not to go to church because of trivial matters like this, they're fools.
Its in their church hall. Its not going to impose on any religious goings on within the church its self. What happens when come theif comes along and nicks the lead off the building, maybe the money recieved for the hire of the hall can go towards the up keep of the church. No wonder I know no one appart from a few of my nans friends who attend church if they are so short sighted and fickle like that. makes me want to go to church even less now.
Georgem
says...
11:49am Thu 27 Sep 12
MGRA wrote:I'm not a Christian, so it's ok.
Georgem wrote:does not sound very christian of you George,,, using a misogynist term like that ! shame on you, one for the confessional box perheps... Anyway its easy to tie up supposed "christian" catholics in a knot with the question they can never answer without making themselves look stupid and contradicting their so called religion.... "is it ok to say 'Jesus' ! after you sneeze".... ?
MGRA wrote:You automatically lose 1000 internet points by using the term "sheople". Only complete tits use that these days.
Georgem wrote:baaa baaaaaaaaaaaaaaa baaaa
MGRA wrote:Blah blah blah blah. Good to see you've declared war on straw. Keep up the good work.
Georgem wrote:yes how foolish to see bigotry as reason to steer clear of the Catholic church.... so apart from trivial matters like that, I assume you mean matters like millions of deaths from aids directly attributed to the policies of the Catholic church when you talk about non-trivial matters !? or is that another "story". Its funny how fools find it so easy to spot fools.
badengk1 wrote:Huh? People generally stop going to church because they stop being religious. If someone still believes in these silly superstitions, but decides not to go to church because of trivial matters like this, they're fools.
Its in their church hall. Its not going to impose on any religious goings on within the church its self. What happens when come theif comes along and nicks the lead off the building, maybe the money recieved for the hire of the hall can go towards the up keep of the church. No wonder I know no one appart from a few of my nans friends who attend church if they are so short sighted and fickle like that. makes me want to go to church even less now.
Stillness
says...
11:59am Thu 27 Sep 12
MGRA wrote:Is there anything you don't rant about?
I heard yesterday the fitness instructor recieved no detailed explanation when they cancelled her booking. Then incredibly on the radio the "father" said he was suprised that she went to the media rather than contact him to ask why it was cancelled.
What an idiot. Thats not how it works in the real world... No doubt sheople like GeorgeM with his hear no, see no , speak no outlook will lap up every detail of why simple courtesy went out of the window.
For God's sake calm down man, think of your blood pressure. (Not the Catholic God's sake obviously).
MGRA
says...
12:01pm Thu 27 Sep 12
Stillness wrote:I am as calm as a cucumber. Rants are in Caps....
MGRA wrote:Is there anything you don't rant about?
I heard yesterday the fitness instructor recieved no detailed explanation when they cancelled her booking. Then incredibly on the radio the "father" said he was suprised that she went to the media rather than contact him to ask why it was cancelled.
What an idiot. Thats not how it works in the real world... No doubt sheople like GeorgeM with his hear no, see no , speak no outlook will lap up every detail of why simple courtesy went out of the window.
For God's sake calm down man, think of your blood pressure. (Not the Catholic God's sake obviously).
MGRA
says...
12:02pm Thu 27 Sep 12
Georgem wrote:stop spoiling the fun, pretend you are and answer the ****ing question !! ;-)
MGRA wrote:I'm not a Christian, so it's ok.
Georgem wrote:does not sound very christian of you George,,, using a misogynist term like that ! shame on you, one for the confessional box perheps... Anyway its easy to tie up supposed "christian" catholics in a knot with the question they can never answer without making themselves look stupid and contradicting their so called religion.... "is it ok to say 'Jesus' ! after you sneeze".... ?
MGRA wrote:You automatically lose 1000 internet points by using the term "sheople". Only complete tits use that these days.
Georgem wrote:baaa baaaaaaaaaaaaaaa baaaa
MGRA wrote:Blah blah blah blah. Good to see you've declared war on straw. Keep up the good work.
Georgem wrote:yes how foolish to see bigotry as reason to steer clear of the Catholic church.... so apart from trivial matters like that, I assume you mean matters like millions of deaths from aids directly attributed to the policies of the Catholic church when you talk about non-trivial matters !? or is that another "story". Its funny how fools find it so easy to spot fools.
badengk1 wrote:Huh? People generally stop going to church because they stop being religious. If someone still believes in these silly superstitions, but decides not to go to church because of trivial matters like this, they're fools.
Its in their church hall. Its not going to impose on any religious goings on within the church its self. What happens when come theif comes along and nicks the lead off the building, maybe the money recieved for the hire of the hall can go towards the up keep of the church. No wonder I know no one appart from a few of my nans friends who attend church if they are so short sighted and fickle like that. makes me want to go to church even less now.
Georgem
says...
12:10pm Thu 27 Sep 12
MGRA wrote:Oh, ok.
Georgem wrote:stop spoiling the fun, pretend you are and answer the ****ing question !! ;-)
MGRA wrote:I'm not a Christian, so it's ok.
Georgem wrote:does not sound very christian of you George,,, using a misogynist term like that ! shame on you, one for the confessional box perheps... Anyway its easy to tie up supposed "christian" catholics in a knot with the question they can never answer without making themselves look stupid and contradicting their so called religion.... "is it ok to say 'Jesus' ! after you sneeze".... ?
MGRA wrote:You automatically lose 1000 internet points by using the term "sheople". Only complete tits use that these days.
Georgem wrote:baaa baaaaaaaaaaaaaaa baaaa
MGRA wrote:Blah blah blah blah. Good to see you've declared war on straw. Keep up the good work.
Georgem wrote:yes how foolish to see bigotry as reason to steer clear of the Catholic church.... so apart from trivial matters like that, I assume you mean matters like millions of deaths from aids directly attributed to the policies of the Catholic church when you talk about non-trivial matters !? or is that another "story". Its funny how fools find it so easy to spot fools.
badengk1 wrote:Huh? People generally stop going to church because they stop being religious. If someone still believes in these silly superstitions, but decides not to go to church because of trivial matters like this, they're fools.
Its in their church hall. Its not going to impose on any religious goings on within the church its self. What happens when come theif comes along and nicks the lead off the building, maybe the money recieved for the hire of the hall can go towards the up keep of the church. No wonder I know no one appart from a few of my nans friends who attend church if they are so short sighted and fickle like that. makes me want to go to church even less now.
Sneezing is Gods way of dispelling concentrated Satan out of your body. It's perfectly ok to utter the name of Our Lord after this happens.
Stillness
says...
12:23pm Thu 27 Sep 12
MGRA wrote:I thought the saying was "as cool as a cucumber" but I've just been out to the polytunnel and have seen that you are right as all my cucumbers are very calm.
Stillness wrote:I am as calm as a cucumber. Rants are in Caps....
MGRA wrote:Is there anything you don't rant about?
I heard yesterday the fitness instructor recieved no detailed explanation when they cancelled her booking. Then incredibly on the radio the "father" said he was suprised that she went to the media rather than contact him to ask why it was cancelled.
What an idiot. Thats not how it works in the real world... No doubt sheople like GeorgeM with his hear no, see no , speak no outlook will lap up every detail of why simple courtesy went out of the window.
For God's sake calm down man, think of your blood pressure. (Not the Catholic God's sake obviously).
freefinker
says...
12:36pm Thu 27 Sep 12
Georgem wrote:.. well obviously.
rich the stitch wrote:The really amusing part is, the link he's posted quite clearly proves him to be wrong on that matter.
freefinker wrote:Funny how he's gone quiet.
.. southy, I do hope you return to this story and read Paramjit at 5:56pm Wed 26 Sep 12, above. You really do need to take his advise.
I also like the fact he posted a link on here, but I'm sure he's told us all countless times that any link that anyone else puts on here is wrong or been hacked. Interesting how the hackers from all over the world have nothing better to do than change facts/ figures just to make Southy look foolish.
Evil hackers altered it immediately after he posted the link.
MGRA
says...
12:37pm Thu 27 Sep 12
Stillness wrote:isn't it "as cool as a duck pond then" !?
MGRA wrote:I thought the saying was "as cool as a cucumber" but I've just been out to the polytunnel and have seen that you are right as all my cucumbers are very calm.
Stillness wrote:I am as calm as a cucumber. Rants are in Caps....
MGRA wrote:Is there anything you don't rant about?
I heard yesterday the fitness instructor recieved no detailed explanation when they cancelled her booking. Then incredibly on the radio the "father" said he was suprised that she went to the media rather than contact him to ask why it was cancelled.
What an idiot. Thats not how it works in the real world... No doubt sheople like GeorgeM with his hear no, see no , speak no outlook will lap up every detail of why simple courtesy went out of the window.
For God's sake calm down man, think of your blood pressure. (Not the Catholic God's sake obviously).
Taskforce 141
says...
1:14pm Thu 27 Sep 12
eurogordi
says...
1:27pm Thu 27 Sep 12
Goldenwight wrote:I do not deny that the early western church adopted practices from other cultures, but in all cases these were Christianised and the changes that were made did not conflict with Biblical teachings.
eurogordi wrote: I fully support the decision taken by this priest and have personal concerns about those churches that do allow practices which started in other religions. None of us are perfect, whatever religion, meditation or relaxation we choose to follow, but the fundamentals of yoga do conflict with the teachings of Christianity. Well done, Father Chandler, and I very much hope and pray that other Christian leaders and churches will follow your example. As another contributor has already written "It's about time that Christians were allowed to have a voice again!! Good on them for standing up for what the Bible teaches!" Incidentally, if this story was about a mosque refusing a church choir to to hire a room for rehearsals,, I am sure that no one would be criticising the decision of Islamic leaders for upholding their belief structure!You have personal concerns about those churches which allow practises which started in other religions. You must have serious problems with Christianity, then, rooted as it is in Judaeism. Not to mention the pagan spiritual elements which were later incorporated in Northern Europe. Or would this be a case of being selective in your interpretation of the Word of God. Much as the Spanish Inquisition and the Ku Klux Klan were rather picky about how THEY interpreted it. But that is OK, because they were Christians after all.
As far as Judaism being the foundation of Christianity, I totally agree with this but would add that Christianity COMPLETES Judaism, so again there is no conflict in my personal opinion.
Perhaps I should also add that I am writing this as someone who comes from a Judaeo-Christian; ie. I am a Christian by choice by Jewish by heritage.
Stillness
says...
1:30pm Thu 27 Sep 12
MGRA wrote:Anyone know where my nearest duck pond is?
Stillness wrote:isn't it "as cool as a duck pond then" !?
MGRA wrote:I thought the saying was "as cool as a cucumber" but I've just been out to the polytunnel and have seen that you are right as all my cucumbers are very calm.
Stillness wrote:I am as calm as a cucumber. Rants are in Caps....
MGRA wrote:Is there anything you don't rant about?
I heard yesterday the fitness instructor recieved no detailed explanation when they cancelled her booking. Then incredibly on the radio the "father" said he was suprised that she went to the media rather than contact him to ask why it was cancelled.
What an idiot. Thats not how it works in the real world... No doubt sheople like GeorgeM with his hear no, see no , speak no outlook will lap up every detail of why simple courtesy went out of the window.
For God's sake calm down man, think of your blood pressure. (Not the Catholic God's sake obviously).
Shoong
says...
1:33pm Thu 27 Sep 12
Taskforce 141 wrote:Simple as that then ;-)
God isnt real - deal with it people!
Stillness
says...
1:39pm Thu 27 Sep 12
In all seriousness Father Ted has over reacted to a harmless activity taking place within a collection of bricks that he thinks are somehow magical. It's not his fault, he didn't ask to be the way he is............Blame the parents! That's what I say ;-)
Echo Awards
says...
1:55pm Thu 27 Sep 12
Taskforce 141 wrote:Congratulations, Taskforce 141, you have won this weeks coveted 'Least Relevant Comment' award.
God isnt real - deal with it people!
Inform Al
says...
2:13pm Thu 27 Sep 12
Stillness wrote:Did I just detect a political sheep like bleat in this theological debate?
Why not lets just agree that any organization is bound to have it's share of self opinionated jobs worth's with an over inflated view of their own importance. You only have to look at the local socialist party for proof. If you don't believe me just ask southy.
In all seriousness Father Ted has over reacted to a harmless activity taking place within a collection of bricks that he thinks are somehow magical. It's not his fault, he didn't ask to be the way he is............Blame the parents! That's what I say ;-)
Stillness
says...
2:19pm Thu 27 Sep 12
Inform Al wrote:"Political sheep"? Ahhhhh, you have mistaken pew for ewe. Simple mistake.
Stillness wrote:Did I just detect a political sheep like bleat in this theological debate?
Why not lets just agree that any organization is bound to have it's share of self opinionated jobs worth's with an over inflated view of their own importance. You only have to look at the local socialist party for proof. If you don't believe me just ask southy.
In all seriousness Father Ted has over reacted to a harmless activity taking place within a collection of bricks that he thinks are somehow magical. It's not his fault, he didn't ask to be the way he is............Blame the parents! That's what I say ;-)
Tina Wilder
says...
2:30pm Thu 27 Sep 12
Stillness
says...
3:34pm Thu 27 Sep 12
Tina Wilder wrote:Thank God for that.
I used to do Yoga before I became a Christian and can assert due to my own experience that took me deep into the Chinese philosophy and oriental religions, that Yoga and Christianity have nothing in common.
Matt Probert
says...
7:14pm Thu 27 Sep 12
menotyou
says...
7:17pm Thu 27 Sep 12
Stillness
says...
7:28pm Thu 27 Sep 12
menotyou wrote:Oh sh1t, that should put the cat amongst the pigeons. I was about to stop following this story but on second thoughts I think I'll hang around for a bit.
this particular priest is a bigoted idiot who has forced many of his congregation to other churches and is very unwelcoming of new people in his church, shame really prehaps he should become a jehovahs witness - i beleive they are the ones who are in a cult?
Anyone fancy having a dig at Buddha whilst the story is still running?
MGRA
says...
8:04pm Thu 27 Sep 12
eurogordi wrote:then you will know that Constantine effectively "assembled" the new testament to appease the cults-of-the-day.... Christianity was "invented" by compilation. The new testament was compiled to effectively stop a war and Constantine was the first "christian" ruler of Rome for convenience...
Goldenwight wrote:I do not deny that the early western church adopted practices from other cultures, but in all cases these were Christianised and the changes that were made did not conflict with Biblical teachings.
eurogordi wrote: I fully support the decision taken by this priest and have personal concerns about those churches that do allow practices which started in other religions. None of us are perfect, whatever religion, meditation or relaxation we choose to follow, but the fundamentals of yoga do conflict with the teachings of Christianity. Well done, Father Chandler, and I very much hope and pray that other Christian leaders and churches will follow your example. As another contributor has already written "It's about time that Christians were allowed to have a voice again!! Good on them for standing up for what the Bible teaches!" Incidentally, if this story was about a mosque refusing a church choir to to hire a room for rehearsals,, I am sure that no one would be criticising the decision of Islamic leaders for upholding their belief structure!You have personal concerns about those churches which allow practises which started in other religions. You must have serious problems with Christianity, then, rooted as it is in Judaeism. Not to mention the pagan spiritual elements which were later incorporated in Northern Europe. Or would this be a case of being selective in your interpretation of the Word of God. Much as the Spanish Inquisition and the Ku Klux Klan were rather picky about how THEY interpreted it. But that is OK, because they were Christians after all.
As far as Judaism being the foundation of Christianity, I totally agree with this but would add that Christianity COMPLETES Judaism, so again there is no conflict in my personal opinion.
Perhaps I should also add that I am writing this as someone who comes from a Judaeo-Christian; ie. I am a Christian by choice by Jewish by heritage.
chavfreezone
says...
8:01am Fri 28 Sep 12
Home Rule for England
says...
9:20am Fri 28 Sep 12
Chas O'Bursledon wrote:Your opening sentence is a bit OTT isn't it? How does banning yoga from a church equate to 'hate and bigotry'?
Another stupid example of how hate and bigotry never solved a problem. I am proud of my atheism. My moral compass does not allow me to hate or condemn a person I do not know for their beliefs. I do not judge them unless they impose or try to impose their belief system on me. Yoga does no harm. It is not a religion or a martial art. I do not condemn Catholicism but a very stupid man who is coincidentally a priest. I would worry about the example he is setting his congregation.
ianexams
says...
11:10am Fri 28 Sep 12
miltonarcher
says...
11:27am Fri 28 Sep 12
wilson castaway wrote:DRINK!..............
Ahh go on, go on go on go on go on go on go on.........
GIRLS!..............
FECK!
miltonarcher
says...
11:29am Fri 28 Sep 12
miltonarcher
says...
11:32am Fri 28 Sep 12
thedavie
says...
5:04pm Fri 28 Sep 12
I wonder if St Edmund's Church decision makers have read Deepak Chopra or Catholic Thomas Merton
Also my Father in law was Hindu but it did not stop him letting Christians use his own house for their Sunday services
Both Catholic and Anglican made use of his offer
War is caused by greed and a lack of respect for our fellow man
dango says...
9:47am Wed 26 Sep 12