- Mobile site
- E-Newsletters
-
- News feed
- Find us on Twitter
@dailyecho
Daily Echo on Twitter
@the_saints
Saints News on Twitter
SceneSouth
Leisure news on Twitter
- Find us on Facebook
Facebook
Daily Echo on Facebook
Woman jailed for killing mum-in-law with rolling pin (From Daily Echo)
When news happens, text SDE and your photos or videos to 80360. Or contact us by email and phone.
Rajvinder Kaur jailed for killing mother-in-law with rolling pin in Southampton home
11:56am Thursday 19th July 2012 in Southampton
A Hampshire mum wept as she was told she would serve at least 11 years in jail for battering her mother in law to death.
Rajvinder Kaur used a wooden rolling pin to rain at least 20 blows to the head of 56-year-old Baljit Buttar before leaving her in blood-soaked bathroom.
At Winchester Crown Court Judge Mr Justice Burnett jailed Kaur for life to serve a minimum of 11 years behind bars.
He described the murder as “frenzied” after she “exploded with rage” because she was being nagged on the morning of February 25 2011.
Sentencing Kaur, 37, her told her that one of the key aggravating features of her case was making her nine-year-old son open the bathroom door to find her grandmother naked, dead and lying in a pool of blood in a bid to fix herself an alibi.
He went on to describe how Kaur then willingly let her husband Iqbal Singh become a suspect for the killing of his mum as he w3as held and quizzed by police.
You lost your temper and completely lost your self control
Mr Justice Burnett
Two friends , who had gone to the flat in Broadlands Road, Swaythling, to help following news of Mrs Buttar's death were also arrested and interviews suspicion of murder.
Mr Justice Burnett said Kaur had peddled lies through 14 police interviews and had gone on to change her story and admit the killing through provocation forcing a retrial.
He described how the consequences were “tragic in so many ways for so many people.”
And he added: “The precise circumstances of what occurred are known only to you. You lost your temper and completely lost your self control. The attack which followed was a frenzied one with perhaps 20 blows to her head and elsewhere on her body.
“You did nothing to help her, your actions afterwards were cruel and calculated.”
Kaur admitted manslaughter, but was yesterday found guilty of murder.
Comments(22)
waltons11
says...
12:47pm Thu 19 Jul 12
Georgem
says...
1:29pm Thu 19 Jul 12
Shoong
says...
2:16pm Thu 19 Jul 12
Taskforce 141 wrote:It's important to remind ourselves that capital punishment was abolished here because the last man sent to the gallows was proven to be innocent afterwards.
Hang her and be done with it and save the tax payers money for her accommodation for the next 11 years (of which she will probably serve 5-6!)
mansak_hunt
says...
3:29pm Thu 19 Jul 12
Shoong wrote:Peter Allen and Gwynne Evans were the last men hanged in the UK but they confessed to the crime and have never been proven innocent?
Taskforce 141 wrote:It's important to remind ourselves that capital punishment was abolished here because the last man sent to the gallows was proven to be innocent afterwards.
Hang her and be done with it and save the tax payers money for her accommodation for the next 11 years (of which she will probably serve 5-6!)
Please explain.
Frank28
says...
4:06pm Thu 19 Jul 12
Georgem
says...
4:14pm Thu 19 Jul 12
Frank28 wrote:Where does it say she was an illegal immigrant?
How can they call her a Southampton woman - when she's an illegal immigrant?
Shoong
says...
4:19pm Thu 19 Jul 12
mansak_hunt wrote:I do beg your pardon, you're right.
Shoong wrote:Peter Allen and Gwynne Evans were the last men hanged in the UK but they confessed to the crime and have never been proven innocent?
Taskforce 141 wrote:It's important to remind ourselves that capital punishment was abolished here because the last man sent to the gallows was proven to be innocent afterwards.
Hang her and be done with it and save the tax payers money for her accommodation for the next 11 years (of which she will probably serve 5-6!)
Please explain.
Still, for me personally, as soon as you send an innocent man to his death, it invalidates the whole thing.
mansak_hunt
says...
4:41pm Thu 19 Jul 12
Shoong wrote:Yes I agree a death sentence can never be justified, even though it may seem appealing.
mansak_hunt wrote:I do beg your pardon, you're right.
Shoong wrote:Peter Allen and Gwynne Evans were the last men hanged in the UK but they confessed to the crime and have never been proven innocent?
Taskforce 141 wrote:It's important to remind ourselves that capital punishment was abolished here because the last man sent to the gallows was proven to be innocent afterwards.
Hang her and be done with it and save the tax payers money for her accommodation for the next 11 years (of which she will probably serve 5-6!)
Please explain.
Still, for me personally, as soon as you send an innocent man to his death, it invalidates the whole thing.
State sanctioned executions would not be a step in the right direction, IMO.
pod
says...
5:21pm Thu 19 Jul 12
hythe knights wrote:In yesterdays Echo it stated that she was here illegally having overstayed her visa.
Georgem wrote:A dog born in a stable is not a horse
Frank28 wrote:Where does it say she was an illegal immigrant?
How can they call her a Southampton woman - when she's an illegal immigrant?
opera phantom
says...
5:49pm Thu 19 Jul 12
Shoong wrote:Sorry,bullet in the head. job done.
Taskforce 141 wrote:It's important to remind ourselves that capital punishment was abolished here because the last man sent to the gallows was proven to be innocent afterwards.
Hang her and be done with it and save the tax payers money for her accommodation for the next 11 years (of which she will probably serve 5-6!)
yellowcard
says...
11:11pm Thu 19 Jul 12
Georgem
says...
11:58am Fri 20 Jul 12
hythe knights wrote:But why ILLEGAL, specifically?
Georgem wrote:A dog born in a stable is not a horse
Frank28 wrote:Where does it say she was an illegal immigrant?
How can they call her a Southampton woman - when she's an illegal immigrant?
Georgem
says...
11:59am Fri 20 Jul 12
opera phantom wrote:Oh yes! I forgot about guilt-detecting bullets!
Shoong wrote:Sorry,bullet in the head. job done.
Taskforce 141 wrote:It's important to remind ourselves that capital punishment was abolished here because the last man sent to the gallows was proven to be innocent afterwards.
Hang her and be done with it and save the tax payers money for her accommodation for the next 11 years (of which she will probably serve 5-6!)
opera phantom
says...
12:04pm Fri 20 Jul 12
Georgem wrote:Not bothered. Like many am sick of the violent crime in this country.
opera phantom wrote:Oh yes! I forgot about guilt-detecting bullets!
Shoong wrote:Sorry,bullet in the head. job done.
Taskforce 141 wrote:It's important to remind ourselves that capital punishment was abolished here because the last man sent to the gallows was proven to be innocent afterwards.
Hang her and be done with it and save the tax payers money for her accommodation for the next 11 years (of which she will probably serve 5-6!)
If you don't want the death penalty, then lock them away for life.
Georgem
says...
1:40pm Fri 20 Jul 12
opera phantom wrote:"Not bothered".
Georgem wrote:Not bothered. Like many am sick of the violent crime in this country.
opera phantom wrote:Oh yes! I forgot about guilt-detecting bullets!
Shoong wrote:Sorry,bullet in the head. job done.
Taskforce 141 wrote:It's important to remind ourselves that capital punishment was abolished here because the last man sent to the gallows was proven to be innocent afterwards.
Hang her and be done with it and save the tax payers money for her accommodation for the next 11 years (of which she will probably serve 5-6!)
If you don't want the death penalty, then lock them away for life.
And we wonder why crime is out of control.
opera phantom
says...
3:50pm Fri 20 Jul 12
Bring it back, but if that is not acceptable then keep them in prison until they die. There are evil people out there who are beyond redemption. You will never do any thing with them. The woolly liberal brigade have had their way for too long and you will not hear a better example than that when Paddy Ashdown when he said that he was uneasy about Bin Laden being shot on sight. There are too many people who have been murdered, raped because evil scum have been let out of prison
Georgem
says...
4:05pm Fri 20 Jul 12
opera phantom wrote:Wait, what? You're comfortable with the USA simply sending troops to another country to assassinate someone, on the pretext that he MAY have committed a terrorist act against them? You don't think it's at all worrying that a foreign government can simply decide that someone should no longer be alive, and have impunity to assassinate them? You think it's "woolly liberal" to express concern that a superpower has appointed itself World Police, and nobody else has a say?
No. What I am saying regarding being not bothered is. I am not bothered what the anti death penalty brigade say.
Bring it back, but if that is not acceptable then keep them in prison until they die. There are evil people out there who are beyond redemption. You will never do any thing with them. The woolly liberal brigade have had their way for too long and you will not hear a better example than that when Paddy Ashdown when he said that he was uneasy about Bin Laden being shot on sight. There are too many people who have been murdered, raped because evil scum have been let out of prison
opera phantom
says...
4:58pm Fri 20 Jul 12
I assume that by your logic we should not have attempted to assassinate
Hitler in WW11.
Bin Laden MAY have been guilty of terrorist offences?
I feel that we can only agree to disagree.
Georgem
says...
5:32pm Fri 20 Jul 12
opera phantom wrote:What's Hitler got to do with it?
This gets more and more interesting.
I assume that by your logic we should not have attempted to assassinate
Hitler in WW11.
Bin Laden MAY have been guilty of terrorist offences?
I feel that we can only agree to disagree.
As for bin Laden, well, the USA invaded countries on the strength that they were harbouring 'the man behind 9/11', and they spent a decade chasing 'the man behind 9/11' before finally killing him. So he must have been behind the attacks, right?
http://www.informati
onclearinghouse.info
/article13664.htm
Hmmm.
Believe what you like. I can't stop you. But be aware that there's more to the news than what you see on News at 10.
Georgem
says...
5:35pm Fri 20 Jul 12
On June 5, 2006, the Muckraker Report contacted the FBI Headquarters to learn why Bin Laden’s Most Wanted poster did not indicate that Usama was also wanted in connection with 9/11. The Muckraker Report spoke with Rex Tomb, Chief of Investigative Publicity for the FBI. When asked why there is no mention of 9/11 on Bin Laden’s Most Wanted web page, Tomb said, “The reason why 9/11 is not mentioned on Usama Bin Laden’s Most Wanted page is because the FBI has no hard evidence connecting Bin Laden to 9/11."
But I guess you know better than the FBI.
opera phantom
says...
8:17pm Fri 20 Jul 12
9/11?
But I am glad that the evil man is dead.
Taskforce 141 says...
12:31pm Thu 19 Jul 12