Send us your pictures and video by text, email or by uploading. Click here to find out how. »
10:27am Thursday 5th June 2008
The Daily Echo can today reveal the areas inside and outside Southampton that would receive mass-medicated water if city health chiefs get their way. (See today's Daily Echo to see the areas affected).
About two-thirds of people within the city boundaries are set to be given topped-up levels of fluoride in a bid to improve chronic dental health in deprived areas.
But, as the map opposite shows, as well as the 160,000 Southampton residents affected, more than 36,000 people living outside of the city will also get increased fluoride, even though there are no major concerns about dental problems there.
Residents in parts of Eastleigh, Boyatt Wood, Totton, Rushington, Netley and Butlocks Heath would all be affected.
Those residents, and many living within Southampton, do not suffer worrying levels of dental health problems, but they would be given extra doses of fluoride anyway.
Meanwhile, large areas within the city that do have major problems would continue to receive non-fluoridated water.
Townhill Park, Harefield, Thornhill and the Flowers Estate in Bassett have all been identified as target neighbourhoods, where there are high levels of tooth decay in children.
However, they are not included in the scheme because their tap water comes from other distribution centres to those authorities say are best to use for fluoridation - at Otterbourne and Rownhams.
Click here for the complete archive of articles and reports into both sides of the fluoride debate
South Central Strategic Health Authority is running the three-month public consultation due to start in August, at the request of Southampton City Primary Care Trust.
The SHA insists all residents affected by the proposals will be given the chance to have their say on the scheme, regardless of whether they are city or county residents.
Hampshire PCT, which covers the areas outside Southampton that would be included, says it is supporting the project.
Jean Bradlow, Hampshire PCT's director of public health said some of those places beyond the city boundaries to be fluoridated could benefit from the scheme.
"Hampshire PCT recognises that child dental health is poor in Southampton and that water fluoridation is a safe and effective means of reducing dental decay," she said.
"This proposal will effect some residents in parts of Eastleigh, Totton and Netley where we have pockets of poor dental health which would benefit from fluoridation.
"We urge residents of these areas to share their views during the consultation."

WHO GETS THE FLUORIDE?
The map above shows the zone that would be covered by the fluoridation scheme if it gets the go-ahead. The zone includes areas outside the city boundary that would receive fluoride in the water like Eastleigh, Totton and Netley while some Southampton communities including parts of Sholing, Bitterne and Townhill Park would not.
Gozza, Worried says...
11:11am Thu 5 Jun 08
But, as the map opposite showsWhat map?
Colgate Warrior, says...
11:15am Thu 5 Jun 08
Ciaran, says...
12:02pm Thu 5 Jun 08
Gozza wrote:Erm, the big one.
But, as the map opposite showsWhat map?
Joanna, Woolston says...
12:28pm Thu 5 Jun 08
Mr Sarcy-Barstard, says...
12:37pm Thu 5 Jun 08
Joanna wrote:Gosh Joanna, I have looked at the studies and had made my own mind up. But now you have made this earth-shattering in depth scientific finding, I say put the poison in the water and take away everyone's choice.
I grew up in an area with fluoridation. My husband didn't. We're of the same class and dental habits. I have never had a cavity - he's had 10. This shows the benefit it provides. Anyone else have a real story instead of one they read in a study?
Barry, Sholing says...
12:41pm Thu 5 Jun 08
Joanna wrote:My son loves carrots and has had lots of dental problems throughout his life. My daughter hates carrots with a vengance but has perfect teeth.
I grew up in an area with fluoridation. My husband didn't. We're of the same class and dental habits. I have never had a cavity - he's had 10. This shows the benefit it provides. Anyone else have a real story instead of one they read in a study?
Ok Then, says...
12:45pm Thu 5 Jun 08
Colgate Warrior wrote:Old fashioned.
I buy toothpaste, call me old fashioned.
Christoff, says...
1:00pm Thu 5 Jun 08
Mr Sarcy-Barstard wrote:lol....Joanna clearly has the scientific breakthrough that settles the debate.
Joanna wrote: I grew up in an area with fluoridation. My husband didn't. We're of the same class and dental habits. I have never had a cavity - he's had 10. This shows the benefit it provides. Anyone else have a real story instead of one they read in a study?Gosh Joanna, I have looked at the studies and had made my own mind up. But now you have made this earth-shattering in depth scientific finding, I say put the poison in the water and take away everyone's choice.
Sue, Highfield says...
1:01pm Thu 5 Jun 08
bill, soton says...
2:29pm Thu 5 Jun 08
Joanna wrote:I met a pro-fluoride person yesterday who wants fluoride for everybody as her children were brought up in an area with fluoride and have perfect teeth. I asked where did they live at that time and she said London. London has never been fluoridated but she will not take my word for it so I've sent her the map of the fluoride levels in England. I bet she still won't accept it as none of us like to admit we may be wrong.
I grew up in an area with fluoridation. My husband didn\'t. We\'re of the same class and dental habits. I have never had a cavity - he\'s had 10. This shows the benefit it provides. Anyone else have a real story instead of one they read in a study?
Gin Lady, Soton says...
2:57pm Thu 5 Jun 08
Jim Schultz, Ormond Beach Fl USA says...
3:15pm Thu 5 Jun 08
Isabelle, Soton says...
6:18pm Thu 5 Jun 08
Tony, Beautiful Sholing says...
12:20am Fri 6 Jun 08
Jim Schultz, Ormond Beach Fl USA says...
1:13am Fri 6 Jun 08
Jim Schultz, Ormond Beach Fl USA says...
1:22am Fri 6 Jun 08
Sarah Peckham, Southampton says...
2:32pm Fri 6 Jun 08
Carly, Hampshire says...
10:27pm Sat 7 Jun 08
Disgusted, Southampton says...
10:20pm Tue 10 Jun 08
P Griffiths, Andover says...
7:29pm Tue 17 Jun 08
Jennifer, Hampshire says...
5:40pm Mon 7 Jul 08
mel morris, middlands says...
3:26pm Mon 28 Jul 08
mel morris, middlands says...
3:32pm Mon 28 Jul 08
Duh, Southampton says...
11:01am Thu 5 Jun 08
These are all the lower class areas. Surely free toothbrushes would be a cheaper option? AND holding the parents accountable for neglecting there offspring.
I'm glad i'm not in one of those areas!