Health and council bosses accused over hospital

BED CLOSURES: At Woodhaven Hospital BED CLOSURES: At Woodhaven Hospital

AN MP has launched a furious attack on health and council bosses over the closure of mental health beds in Hampshire.

Julian Lewis used a parliamentary debate to accuse the health trust of using “misleading” data to justify closing beds at Woodhaven Hospital, in Calmore.

The Conservative New Forest East MP also slammed fellow Tories on Hampshire County Council, claiming he had been “deceived” and not given the chance to make his case to a committee.

But his plea for a minister to intervene was rejected.

Simon Burns, the Health Minister, said it would be “totally inappropriate” for the Government to wade into the debate, insisting it was a matter for local decision-makers.

The Southern Health Foundation Trust wants to close 58 beds, including the 24 at Woodhaven.

Speaking in Westminster Hall, Dr Lewis, who was supported by Winchester MP Steve Brine and Romsey and Southampton North MP Caroline Nokes, criticised the consultation into the changes, which he said were based on flawed statistics.

He had hoped to appear at a meeting of the county council’s Health Scrutiny Committee to argue that the closures should be referred to the Government.

He said the committee chairman, Councillor Pat West, had told him there was no need for him to attend a meeting in January.

But he subsequently discovered that the bed closure plan had been “fully endorsed” at the meeting.

Quoting from a letter he wrote to councillors, he said: “In almost 15 years as a Hampshire MP, I have never received treatment like this from an elected colleague in my own party, and am deeply shocked by it.”

Closing his speech, he said: “It would be easy to summarise this story as that of a trust which could not be trusted with its own statistics and a committee chairman who deceived an MP about a vital meeting.”

But it was really about carers, nurses and service-users, he said.

Mr Burns outlined the trust’s reasons for its decision, which would allow for more investment in alternative facilities and provide better support for people living outside hospital.

Other health trusts were doing similar things in different parts of the country, he said.

Cllr West was last night unavailable for comment.

Comments(22)

Linesman says...
3:13pm Mon 14 May 12

Well done Julian Lewis. As the Tory election campaign promised that the NHS was safe in their hands, it is nice to see that some of their MPs are attempting to make them keep that promise.

Over the Edge says...
3:46pm Mon 14 May 12

Linesman wrote:
Well done Julian Lewis. As the Tory election campaign promised that the NHS was safe in their hands, it is nice to see that some of their MPs are attempting to make them keep that promise.
Spot on Linesman, the coalition are full of empty promises.

No doubt their supporters will on here in a minute to slaughter us both.

Simon Burns, the Health Minister, said it would be “totally inappropriate” for the Government to wade into the debate, insisting it was a matter for local decision-makers.

Those local decisions are made because of central Government policies, decisions also funding, if you makes cuts to a local NHS foundations funding they will make cuts to local services.

Shoong says...
3:53pm Mon 14 May 12

Over the Edge wrote:
Linesman wrote:
Well done Julian Lewis. As the Tory election campaign promised that the NHS was safe in their hands, it is nice to see that some of their MPs are attempting to make them keep that promise.
Spot on Linesman, the coalition are full of empty promises.

No doubt their supporters will on here in a minute to slaughter us both.

Simon Burns, the Health Minister, said it would be “totally inappropriate” for the Government to wade into the debate, insisting it was a matter for local decision-makers.

Those local decisions are made because of central Government policies, decisions also funding, if you makes cuts to a local NHS foundations funding they will make cuts to local services.
Perhaps they will contribute more than just copy & pasting from the article.

Well done, hero.

Over the Edge says...
3:55pm Mon 14 May 12

Shoong wrote:
Over the Edge wrote:
Linesman wrote:
Well done Julian Lewis. As the Tory election campaign promised that the NHS was safe in their hands, it is nice to see that some of their MPs are attempting to make them keep that promise.
Spot on Linesman, the coalition are full of empty promises.

No doubt their supporters will on here in a minute to slaughter us both.

Simon Burns, the Health Minister, said it would be “totally inappropriate” for the Government to wade into the debate, insisting it was a matter for local decision-makers.

Those local decisions are made because of central Government policies, decisions also funding, if you makes cuts to a local NHS foundations funding they will make cuts to local services.
Perhaps they will contribute more than just copy & pasting from the article.

Well done, hero.
Thanks Shoong, no need for the hero bit though.

Your contribution was amazing by the way,,,,what was it?

sarfhamton says...
5:05pm Mon 14 May 12

what he failed to mention is that the plan is to re-open Woodhaven with 20 beds for other patients. Typical Tory lies.

Shoong says...
5:18pm Mon 14 May 12

Over the Edge wrote:
Shoong wrote:
Over the Edge wrote:
Linesman wrote:
Well done Julian Lewis. As the Tory election campaign promised that the NHS was safe in their hands, it is nice to see that some of their MPs are attempting to make them keep that promise.
Spot on Linesman, the coalition are full of empty promises.

No doubt their supporters will on here in a minute to slaughter us both.

Simon Burns, the Health Minister, said it would be “totally inappropriate” for the Government to wade into the debate, insisting it was a matter for local decision-makers.

Those local decisions are made because of central Government policies, decisions also funding, if you makes cuts to a local NHS foundations funding they will make cuts to local services.
Perhaps they will contribute more than just copy & pasting from the article.

Well done, hero.
Thanks Shoong, no need for the hero bit though.

Your contribution was amazing by the way,,,,what was it?
My point really is, what are you going to do to help then? Start a petition? Start a fund raising & awareness campaign? Get your cheque book out?

Or do FA apart from a political swipe while pretending to take the moral high ground?

Thought so.

Linesman says...
7:24pm Mon 14 May 12

Shoong wrote:
Over the Edge wrote:
Shoong wrote:
Over the Edge wrote:
Linesman wrote:
Well done Julian Lewis. As the Tory election campaign promised that the NHS was safe in their hands, it is nice to see that some of their MPs are attempting to make them keep that promise.
Spot on Linesman, the coalition are full of empty promises.

No doubt their supporters will on here in a minute to slaughter us both.

Simon Burns, the Health Minister, said it would be “totally inappropriate” for the Government to wade into the debate, insisting it was a matter for local decision-makers.

Those local decisions are made because of central Government policies, decisions also funding, if you makes cuts to a local NHS foundations funding they will make cuts to local services.
Perhaps they will contribute more than just copy & pasting from the article.

Well done, hero.
Thanks Shoong, no need for the hero bit though.

Your contribution was amazing by the way,,,,what was it?
My point really is, what are you going to do to help then? Start a petition? Start a fund raising & awareness campaign? Get your cheque book out?

Or do FA apart from a political swipe while pretending to take the moral high ground?

Thought so.
For a start, it was not Me that made the promise that the NHS would be safe in My hands.

If I were to make a promise, that is the central theme of my electioneering, even though the state of the economy is known during that pre-election period, then I would consider it to be of paramount importance if I came to power on the strength of that promise.

Of course, if I were a devious bar steward, and found that I was in power, thanks to another party deciding that a taste of power was worth ditching their principles, I could always blame them for me not being able to keep my promise.

It must be a common site to see the tail wagging the dog, so why shouldn't the Clegg tail wag the Cameron dog?

Fatty x Ford Worker says...
7:24pm Mon 14 May 12

Percy me Parrot going nuts where can I take him and my self now on the railways,Choo Chooh.

Linesman says...
7:26pm Mon 14 May 12

Fatty x Ford Worker wrote:
Percy me Parrot going nuts where can I take him and my self now on the railways,Choo Chooh.
With such an intelligent post, I suggest that the parrot takes you out as it would probably be considered to be the 'Responsible Adult.'

Fatty x Ford Worker says...
7:29pm Mon 14 May 12

ME LIKE YOU CUCKOO GO AND JUMP OFF A!

Over the Edge says...
7:33pm Mon 14 May 12

Shoong wrote:
Over the Edge wrote:
Shoong wrote:
Over the Edge wrote:
Linesman wrote:
Well done Julian Lewis. As the Tory election campaign promised that the NHS was safe in their hands, it is nice to see that some of their MPs are attempting to make them keep that promise.
Spot on Linesman, the coalition are full of empty promises.

No doubt their supporters will on here in a minute to slaughter us both.

Simon Burns, the Health Minister, said it would be “totally inappropriate” for the Government to wade into the debate, insisting it was a matter for local decision-makers.

Those local decisions are made because of central Government policies, decisions also funding, if you makes cuts to a local NHS foundations funding they will make cuts to local services.
Perhaps they will contribute more than just copy & pasting from the article.

Well done, hero.
Thanks Shoong, no need for the hero bit though.

Your contribution was amazing by the way,,,,what was it?
My point really is, what are you going to do to help then? Start a petition? Start a fund raising & awareness campaign? Get your cheque book out?

Or do FA apart from a political swipe while pretending to take the moral high ground?

Thought so.
Moral high ground, I think not, there is no high ground to be had.

If you want a political swipe, try this for size, 61,000 frontline nursing staff losing their job (Royal College of Nursing figures) because of the coalition Government.

Oh by the way, what job do I do? you have no clue as to my employment therefore you cannot say that I will do FA.

For your information, I work daily with people who have suffered from mental illness and who are trying to re-build their lives, I support them from the state benefit system back to employment, however if the people I work with didn't have the opportunity in the past to be in-patients some of them wouldn't be here today and seeking to re-build their lives.

Fatty x Ford Worker says...
7:35pm Mon 14 May 12

EMMERDALE AND CORRYS ON TONIGHT YOU TOSSERS!

Fatty x Ford Worker says...
7:38pm Mon 14 May 12

Over the Edge wrote:
Shoong wrote:
Over the Edge wrote:
Shoong wrote:
Over the Edge wrote:
Linesman wrote:
Well done Julian Lewis. As the Tory election campaign promised that the NHS was safe in their hands, it is nice to see that some of their MPs are attempting to make them keep that promise.
Spot on Linesman, the coalition are full of empty promises.

No doubt their supporters will on here in a minute to slaughter us both.

Simon Burns, the Health Minister, said it would be “totally inappropriate” for the Government to wade into the debate, insisting it was a matter for local decision-makers.

Those local decisions are made because of central Government policies, decisions also funding, if you makes cuts to a local NHS foundations funding they will make cuts to local services.
Perhaps they will contribute more than just copy & pasting from the article.

Well done, hero.
Thanks Shoong, no need for the hero bit though.

Your contribution was amazing by the way,,,,what was it?
My point really is, what are you going to do to help then? Start a petition? Start a fund raising & awareness campaign? Get your cheque book out?

Or do FA apart from a political swipe while pretending to take the moral high ground?

Thought so.
Moral high ground, I think not, there is no high ground to be had.

If you want a political swipe, try this for size, 61,000 frontline nursing staff losing their job (Royal College of Nursing figures) because of the coalition Government.

Oh by the way, what job do I do? you have no clue as to my employment therefore you cannot say that I will do FA.

For your information, I work daily with people who have suffered from mental illness and who are trying to re-build their lives, I support them from the state benefit system back to employment, however if the people I work with didn't have the opportunity in the past to be in-patients some of them wouldn't be here today and seeking to re-build their lives.
Corrys more interesting!

LadyNetley says...
7:40pm Mon 14 May 12

The closure of Woodhaven will resukt in more suicides or murders. There are people walking the streets who are clearly a danger to others or a danger to themselves.

IronLady2010 says...
7:57pm Mon 14 May 12

Fatty x Ford Worker wrote:
ME LIKE YOU CUCKOO GO AND JUMP OFF A!
Can you not find a job? Or at least stay off the alcohol?

Huffter says...
8:01pm Mon 14 May 12

They should just get rid of the beds which are being closed and put some more in their place.

Fatty x Ford Worker says...
8:06pm Mon 14 May 12

IronLady2010 wrote:
Fatty x Ford Worker wrote:
ME LIKE YOU CUCKOO GO AND JUMP OFF A!
Can you not find a job? Or at least stay off the alcohol?
Yes you are right but what else can I do!

Over the Edge says...
8:37pm Mon 14 May 12

Fatty x Ford Worker wrote:
Over the Edge wrote:
Shoong wrote:
Over the Edge wrote:
Shoong wrote:
Over the Edge wrote:
Linesman wrote:
Well done Julian Lewis. As the Tory election campaign promised that the NHS was safe in their hands, it is nice to see that some of their MPs are attempting to make them keep that promise.
Spot on Linesman, the coalition are full of empty promises.

No doubt their supporters will on here in a minute to slaughter us both.

Simon Burns, the Health Minister, said it would be “totally inappropriate” for the Government to wade into the debate, insisting it was a matter for local decision-makers.

Those local decisions are made because of central Government policies, decisions also funding, if you makes cuts to a local NHS foundations funding they will make cuts to local services.
Perhaps they will contribute more than just copy & pasting from the article.

Well done, hero.
Thanks Shoong, no need for the hero bit though.

Your contribution was amazing by the way,,,,what was it?
My point really is, what are you going to do to help then? Start a petition? Start a fund raising & awareness campaign? Get your cheque book out?

Or do FA apart from a political swipe while pretending to take the moral high ground?

Thought so.
Moral high ground, I think not, there is no high ground to be had.

If you want a political swipe, try this for size, 61,000 frontline nursing staff losing their job (Royal College of Nursing figures) because of the coalition Government.

Oh by the way, what job do I do? you have no clue as to my employment therefore you cannot say that I will do FA.

For your information, I work daily with people who have suffered from mental illness and who are trying to re-build their lives, I support them from the state benefit system back to employment, however if the people I work with didn't have the opportunity in the past to be in-patients some of them wouldn't be here today and seeking to re-build their lives.
Corrys more interesting!
A boring life you must lead.

Dr Martin says...
10:20pm Mon 14 May 12

LadyNetley wrote:
The closure of Woodhaven will resukt in more suicides or murders. There are people walking the streets who are clearly a danger to others or a danger to themselves.
Not necessarily so, in theory those who are at most risk to themselves if they need to be hospitalised in another unit, there are other mental hospitals other than Woodhaven.
I am afraid keeping Woodhaven will do little to the murder rate, it isn’t a prison or a forensic unit, and finally we can’t keep every risky person locked up in hospital or prison and closing Woodhaven wont change that much

Linesman says...
10:48pm Mon 14 May 12

Fatty x Ford Worker wrote:
Over the Edge wrote:
Shoong wrote:
Over the Edge wrote:
Shoong wrote:
Over the Edge wrote:
Linesman wrote:
Well done Julian Lewis. As the Tory election campaign promised that the NHS was safe in their hands, it is nice to see that some of their MPs are attempting to make them keep that promise.
Spot on Linesman, the coalition are full of empty promises.

No doubt their supporters will on here in a minute to slaughter us both.

Simon Burns, the Health Minister, said it would be “totally inappropriate” for the Government to wade into the debate, insisting it was a matter for local decision-makers.

Those local decisions are made because of central Government policies, decisions also funding, if you makes cuts to a local NHS foundations funding they will make cuts to local services.
Perhaps they will contribute more than just copy & pasting from the article.

Well done, hero.
Thanks Shoong, no need for the hero bit though.

Your contribution was amazing by the way,,,,what was it?
My point really is, what are you going to do to help then? Start a petition? Start a fund raising & awareness campaign? Get your cheque book out?

Or do FA apart from a political swipe while pretending to take the moral high ground?

Thought so.
Moral high ground, I think not, there is no high ground to be had.

If you want a political swipe, try this for size, 61,000 frontline nursing staff losing their job (Royal College of Nursing figures) because of the coalition Government.

Oh by the way, what job do I do? you have no clue as to my employment therefore you cannot say that I will do FA.

For your information, I work daily with people who have suffered from mental illness and who are trying to re-build their lives, I support them from the state benefit system back to employment, however if the people I work with didn't have the opportunity in the past to be in-patients some of them wouldn't be here today and seeking to re-build their lives.
Corrys more interesting!
Each to their own level of intelligence, and you have indicated yours.

southy says...
12:29pm Tue 15 May 12

Dr Martin wrote:
LadyNetley wrote:
The closure of Woodhaven will resukt in more suicides or murders. There are people walking the streets who are clearly a danger to others or a danger to themselves.
Not necessarily so, in theory those who are at most risk to themselves if they need to be hospitalised in another unit, there are other mental hospitals other than Woodhaven.
I am afraid keeping Woodhaven will do little to the murder rate, it isn’t a prison or a forensic unit, and finally we can’t keep every risky person locked up in hospital or prison and closing Woodhaven wont change that much
The Socialist Party was on this case a year ahead of Dr Lewis who got involved when it started to get close to election time.
The Socialist Party manage to keep Crowling House open and stop it from being closed by the Trust board, (The Trust board wages for this section is now over £1 million a year all for working 1 or 2 days per mth). Crowling House is now being run down Staff there have been made redundant, they could not close it down out right because they knows that the Socialist Party will be on there case, so they are trying to close it down though the back door, by running the place down and then turn round saying it do not work and use that as an excuse to close it.
The idea behind all of this is to Privatise the NHS, bit by bit.
This Tory Lib/Dem government is to going to cut 61,000 front line nursing staff, The Labour party will cut 58,000 front line nursing staff, if I am right in hearing whats been said in Brighton the Greens intend to cut around the same number as Labour, we know that UKIP and BNP will do the same as the Torys its in there manifest that they will make cuts.

southy says...
12:31pm Tue 15 May 12

If any one wants to fight the cut backs and closing down parts of the NHS, the NHS as a AGM in Sept at the Nova.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree