Report this comment
  • "Almost all of that which ‘solomum’ has written I would agree with, especially as it applies to young people. The discipline of being in the right place at the right time and the social contact through work can be valuable experience.
    I am a volunteer with a well known advice service and see as clients a wide spectrum of benefit claimants. It is not, I believe, appropriate, when someone who has been made redundant after having worked for 35 years, never claimed benefits in their lives before and indeed doesn’t know how to, to ‘force’ them into unpaid ‘work experience’.
    I am uneasy about highly profitable supermarkets having free labour provided by my taxes. It is also potentially a distortion of the labour market. From April 1st many will lose Working Tax Credit because they are working less than 24 rather than 16 hours per week. Already we are seeing those affected, they are desperate for extra hours which are not available to them. Taken by the ‘free’ labour?
    Let the work experience be in the voluntary sector or properly paid at the national minimum wage. The proceeds should not go to Tesco’s shareholders."
  • This field is mandatory
  • This field is mandatory
  • Please note we will not accept reports with HTML tags or URLs in them.

  • Enter the above word in the box below

There's nothing wrong with un-paid work placements

The newsroom at the Southern Daily Echo offices in Southampton.

The newsroom at the Southern Daily Echo offices in Southampton.

First published in Editor Ian Murray's Blog Daily Echo: Photograph of the Author by , Editor-in-chief

The newsroom at the Daily Echo provides work experience for many people throughout the year.

Most of them are young, looking for their first step on the career ladder, but some are older, looking for a career change.

The placements are usually for a week, sometimes two, are unpaid and are provided to help give experience to the youngsters. Little, if anything they create is used in the paper. That is not the purpose of their time with us.

Do I feel we are exploiting these people? Far from it.

Why then do we do it?

In part to seek talent – a few of those we have met along the way have returned to us years later as trainee journalists. In part to help local schools and colleges meet work placement criteria. But mostly because we all know we were once young and looking for that first taste of the working world to give us valuable, recognisable experience.

The furore over the government’s scheme to house tens of thousands of unemployed youngsters with companies while continuing to pay their benefits bewilders me.

True, the companies involved do not have to pay any salaries to their ‘interns.’ Equally true a lot of the work experience they offer is mundane and can be boring. But then again the real life work they are sampling can be just the same.

But why the government has found itself under attack for forging a mass work placement scheme with a number of large employers I can only put down to politics.

I have more sympathy with existing employees at those firms taking part who complain their overtime has been cut thanks to ‘cheap’ labour being on hand. Perhaps the answer would be for those gaining experience to stack shelves one day and then take the goods back down again the next, leaving, what I shall call, active work to those on the books.

I do recognise the type of young persons who have been paraded before the cameras on the BBC and Channel 4 to berate the scheme as demeaning. Of the hundreds of youngsters we have seen on work placements a few, a very few, have complained the newsroom was not exciting enough, the tasks they were sometimes asked to do dull and repetitive. A very few of the very few have walked out without having the courtesy of explaining why they wished to leave. But there will always be some who think they are too good for the rest of us.

We are not part of the government’s official scheme. We will continue to offer work placements to enthusiastic applicants. No doubt a few will not find us to their liking. But then again, that’s what the real world is all about.

Comments (14)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree