'I HAVE an inch of optimism remaining.'
Those are the words of a Romsey town councillor after Test Valley Borough Council conceded an appeal over a major scheme for retirement flats at the gateway to the town.
A public inquiry was recently held into Churchill Retirement Living's scheme for 47 flats at the former Edwina Mountbatten House care home.
It was held after Test Valley Borough Council's southern area planning committee refused the scheme earlier this year, despite planning officers recommending approval.
However, on Tuesday, August 20, Test Valley Borough Council withdrew its opposition to the appeal.
READ MORE: Shock as council withdraws opposition to appeal for retirement flat plans
Romsey Town Council's planning committee discussed the case at its meeting on Thursday, August 22. Cllr John Parker spoke at the inquiry on behalf of the town council, which opposed the scheme.
He said: “What led to the decision was a carefully orchestrated piece of work by Churchill's KC who had worked along the lines that there were substantial benefits to building the home and used that as an argument to say that it overcame each individual impact on the heritage properties in the conservation area.
“He took a massive view of the benefits and played it against each individual harm. That led to a situation where the planning consultant had to agree that the substantial benefits outweighed the less than substantial harm in each case. She then had to concede that the decision of the southern area planning committee was irrational."
SEE ALSO: Edwina Mountbatten House: Appeal starts for controversial plans
Cllr Mark Cooper, who chairs Test Valley Borough Council's southern area planning committee, said: “I have an inch of optimism remaining that the inspector, not withstanding Test Valley's capitulation, dismiss the appeal. The impact on the entrance of the town will be absolutely massive.”
The planning inspector's decision is expected to be published by mid-October.
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules hereLast Updated:
Report this comment Cancel