Giving something away should be one of the easier financial concepts.
It was yours; you give it to someone else, and now it is theirs.
Inheritance tax has a rule regarding that. It was created on July 25, 1986, for gifts made on or after that date.
It's called a "gift with reservation of benefit". The principle underneath it is simple: you cannot genuinely give something away for inheritance tax purposes while still keeping the use or benefit of it yourself.
On my first course in 1988, they used the example of a man giving away a painting to his son, but he kept it in his house, thereby seeing it each day and retaining that benefit.
An obvious example we see is your home.
Imagine you give your house to your child. The paperwork is completed and her name is on the title. You then carry on living there, rent free, exactly as before.
You may feel you have given the house away. The tax man looks at that differently, sadly. Your daughter owns it, but you are still enjoying it. That can make it a gift with reservation, meaning the house can still be treated as part of your estate for inheritance tax when you die.
If you gave the house away 15 years ago but have lived in it rent free ever since, the reservation has continued. Fifteen years does not make the problem disappear. Time is not the cure if you have never really stopped benefiting from the gift.
The position can change if you genuinely give up that benefit. With a house, that might mean moving out. Alternatively, occupation can in some circumstances continue if you pay full commercial consideration – ie a proper market rent.
And "proper" matters.
This is not the moment for a family arrangement involving £100 a month, Sunday lunch, buying some of the groceries and a promise to cut the hedge. Mr Tax Man looks at whether the arrangement is genuinely commercial. If market rent is being relied upon, it needs to be supportable and kept under review. In other words, it must be exactly like a proper commercial arrangement.
If the reservation ends later, ie when you rectify the incorrect process, the tax clock does not pretend it ended on the original gift date. You are treated as making a potentially exempt transfer when the reservation ceases, so the seven-year rule period becomes relevant from that point onward.
I'll explain.
You gift the house at 65 and stay there rent free. At 75 you move out completely. It is the change at 75 that matters for ending the reservation, not the piece of paper signed 10 years earlier.
There is another question: "What if I only give away half the house?"
Again, follow what happens in real life.
If you give half to your son but he lives elsewhere while you occupy the whole house without paying him, you have a problem. If he genuinely occupies the property with you, the rules can work differently, provided the conditions are met and you are not receiving an additional benefit connected with the gift.
So don't begin with percentages. Begin with occupation and benefit ie what's really happening here. Who lives there? Who enjoys it? Who pays what? What have you really surrendered?
The same thinking stretches beyond houses. Take a holiday cottage gifted away but still regularly used by the donor. There can be a nasty double edge: the original gift may already have created a Capital Gains Tax consequence, yet the property can still be brought back into the donor's estate for inheritance tax because the benefit was retained.
That is an expensive way of discovering that legal ownership and inheritance tax treatment are not the same thing.
An occasional social visit to a house you have genuinely given away can be very different from continuing to treat it as your own second home. But these cases turn on facts, and enthusiastic DIY tax planning can become rather less enthusiastic.
Before giving away an asset, slow the whole thing down.
What exactly are you giving away? What benefit will you keep? Could you need the asset later? Will there be Capital Gains Tax now? If you are retaining occupation, what payment is required? And are you genuinely prepared to lose control?
Inheritance tax planning should not leave you poorer, insecure or dependent simply to save tax.
A gift works best when it really is a gift. If you need to keep something back, establish exactly what that means before you hand anything over.
I am writing a guide to inheritance tax. If you would like a complimentary copy, please email info@wwfp.net and one will be sent to you when it is ready. Peter McGahan is the Chief Executive Officer of Independent Financial Adviser Worldwide Financial Planning. Worldwide Financial Planning is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.
Share