Turbine developer expecting opposition from Ministry of Defence to Bullington wind farm

Turbine developer expecting opposition from Ministry of Defence to Bullington wind farm

Turbine developer expecting opposition from Ministry of Defence to Bullington wind farm

First published in News Daily Echo: Photograph of the Author by

DEFENCE chiefs could object to a major wind farm in the Hampshire countryside over fears of radar interference.

EDF Energy Renewables plans to build 14 126-metre masts on farmland at Bullington Cross, north of Winchester.

But wind turbines, whose spinning blades are about the same size as a passenger jet wing, disrupt radar systems.

Radar operators find it hard to distinguish between low-flying aircraft and wind turbines, causing confusion for civil and military air traffic controllers.

Bullington Cross is “an extremely busy aviation site with a high density of both military and civil aviation activity,” according to an impact statement submitted as part of the planning application to Winchester City Council.

The proposed wind farm will interfere with air traffic control systems at Middle Wallop - home to the Army Air Corps - and Boscombe Down, an aircraft testing site.

All 14 turbines will be visible on radar screens at the two bases and the Ministry of Defence may object, says the report.

Bullington Cross is also close to the approach and holding area for aircraft on runway 20 at Southampton International Airport.

Some of the turbines may be visible to radar at the regional airport and all will be in the line of sight of radar at Lasham, home of the UK’s largest gliding centre and a company that services airliners.

Bullington Cross is also within a MoD low flying area for battlefield helicopters and 4km from Popham Airfield used by civilian light aircraft.

A report by EDF said it expected the MoD to object to the plans, as it has done elsewhere.

Defence chiefs are likely to ask for the turbines to be lit, probably with flashing infra-red lights, says the energy giant.

The MoD has fought plans for wind farms in other areas because they interfere with radar at defence bases.

But French-owned EDF said the impact on aviation and radiation can be “negligible” once measures are taken to overcome concerns, such as new radar systems that can distinguish between aircraft and turbines.

Douglas Paterson, of Keep Hampshire Green, a campaign set up to fight the wind farm, questioned who would pay for the new equipment.

“It is normal for the developer to cover the costs but that will bump up household electricity bills further and is only necessary to build the wind farm. This is on top of the £3m a year the wind farm will harvest in subsidies - £75m over its 25-year lifespan – which will add to our electricity bills and there are other hidden costs.”

The wind farm proposals has provoked opposition from locals who say the giant turbines – taller than Battersea Power station chimneys– will destroy previously unspoilt countryside.

However EDF argues the wind farm will generate enough energy to power eight per cent of domestic electricity needs of Winchester, Test Valley and Basingstoke and Deane district council areas combined while cutting 26,000 tonnes of carbon emissions per year.

Seven of the turbines are in Winchester district, two in Test Valley and four in Basingstoke council areas. Planning applications have been submitted to all three councils.

The public consultation ends on May 24 with a decision expected by October 30.

Comments (3)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

7:25am Wed 15 May 13

KarenSTEMM says...

Here's wishing the Keep Hampshire Green group the very best of luck in fighting this horrendous scheme. We need to face up to it - wind turbines don't deliver the goods. They're unreliable, inefficient, and costly, not only in terms of adding to soaring energy bills, but also environmentally. So-called 'community benefit' is a legalised bribe which allows the largely foreign owned energy companies to do a Lady Bountiful and offer us SOME of our money back that has been stolen from us in subsidies, and rising bills. It will never repay us for the devastation of the countryside by towering turbines, more pylons, miles of access roads, concrete filled pits for bases, sub stations etc; the drop in value or unsaleability of homes blighted by wind factories; impact on the tourism industry which is vital to many rural economies; noise pollution; shadow flicker......If they're so fantastic, why the need to pour billions of ££££s down the drain in subsidies, and trying to bribe communities into accepting them?
Here's wishing the Keep Hampshire Green group the very best of luck in fighting this horrendous scheme. We need to face up to it - wind turbines don't deliver the goods. They're unreliable, inefficient, and costly, not only in terms of adding to soaring energy bills, but also environmentally. So-called 'community benefit' is a legalised bribe which allows the largely foreign owned energy companies to do a Lady Bountiful and offer us SOME of our money back that has been stolen from us in subsidies, and rising bills. It will never repay us for the devastation of the countryside by towering turbines, more pylons, miles of access roads, concrete filled pits for bases, sub stations etc; the drop in value or unsaleability of homes blighted by wind factories; impact on the tourism industry which is vital to many rural economies; noise pollution; shadow flicker......If they're so fantastic, why the need to pour billions of ££££s down the drain in subsidies, and trying to bribe communities into accepting them? KarenSTEMM
  • Score: 0

9:18am Wed 15 May 13

Yves1977 says...

I like them - very soothing and calming to look at!
I like them - very soothing and calming to look at! Yves1977
  • Score: 0

8:51am Mon 20 May 13

Matthew Buck says...

A modest proposal - http://tinyurl.com/C
hronicleCartoonMoDWi
ndFarm
A modest proposal - http://tinyurl.com/C hronicleCartoonMoDWi ndFarm Matthew Buck
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree