When news happens, text SDE and your photos or videos to 80360. Or contact us by email and phone.
4:30pm Tuesday 22nd December 2009 in
IT’S the controversial county council headquarters built with £40m of taxpayers’ money.
But when the Daily Echo tried to cover the official opening to show readers what they got for their money, we were banned.
The glitzy launch was aimed at showing how the dilapidated 1960s office block had been transformed into a sleek, modern, sustainable building, which has already won awards for its green credentials.
However, as council leaders were hailing Elizabeth II Court’s revamp, the Daily Echo photographer was being turned away from the event.
This is despite hundreds of dignitaries being allowed in, among them Cabinet members, county councillors and mayors from across Hampshire. They sipped punch and ate canapes as county council leader Ken Thornber lavished praise on the plush new HQ, formerly known as Ashburton Court.
To add insult to injury, the county spent more of taxpayers’ money producing a glossy souvenir brochure, which it handed out to those who attended.
The council’s actions have prompted a barrage of criticism.
Martin Tod, prospective Liberal Democrat parliamentary candidate for Winchester, said: “I'm really shocked. This is a publicly-owned building, they are public officials.
They've just spent over £40m of public money, the public has a right to know.
“Democracy only works if the press can freely report on what politicians get up to. It’s extremely worrying that anyone in public life should think it was acceptable to throw the press out in this way.
“After all, they’re a county council, not MI5. What have they got to hide?”
Christine Melsom, chairman of tax campaign group Isitfair?, added: “It seems to me there’s something Ken Thornber was not wanting us to see.
“The building is public and they should be able to see what’s going on – it’s a huge amount of money being spent there.”
The county council’s stylish new surroundings have already been slammed for being too extravagant.
Around £1.25m has been spent on furniture alone while the children’s department has multi-coloured designer sofas. The new-look offices boast the best in office chairs and streamlined desks and cabinets.
Cllr Thornber confirmed that press and media organisations from across Hampshire had not been invited.
He added: “This is not a public building in that, apart from the reception and meeting areas, all offices are secure and access can only be through authorised pass.
This is in accordance with good security and safety arrangements.”
Comments(27)
StEmmosfire
says...
12:49pm Tue 22 Dec 09
goard
says...
1:01pm Tue 22 Dec 09
ChrisEastleigh
says...
1:09pm Tue 22 Dec 09
Stephen J
says...
1:17pm Tue 22 Dec 09
Stephen J
says...
1:30pm Tue 22 Dec 09
Hampshire County Council
says...
1:45pm Tue 22 Dec 09
Michael S
says...
2:42pm Tue 22 Dec 09
Michael S
says...
2:46pm Tue 22 Dec 09
southy
says...
2:52pm Tue 22 Dec 09
Hampshire County Council wrote:Is it true, That our Southampton Councilor, The one that use to stand out side Colleges, And hand out National Front campaign leaflets, Was ask to attend.
The new Elizabeth 11 Court building, or parts of it, have been open for more than a year. The public, staff, users and partners have made extensive use of the building since its staged opening. The media, including representatives of the Daily Echo, have attended meetings in the building. The Editor of the local newspaper, The Hampshire Chronicle, was invited to attend the official formal opening by the Lord Lieutenant on behalf of the Queen, as were regional broadcast media so it is not true to suggest that the media were not invited. The doors to the building, including secure office areas not usually open to the public, were thrown open in September, like many of our other buildings, for the national Heritage Open Days event and a Daily Echo/Hampshire Chronicle reporter was also given an private tour of the building, unlimited photographic opportunities and interviews when the first phase was completed. We are extremely proud of what has been achieved and we have been delighted to have had the opportunity to showcase these acheivements to a wide audience, including a number of journalists from national publications, as well as the hundreds of external visitors who come through the Elizabeth 11 Court doors every day.
AdrianSmith
says...
3:03pm Tue 22 Dec 09
retiredoldgit
says...
3:05pm Tue 22 Dec 09
freemantlegirl2
says...
3:45pm Tue 22 Dec 09
Hampshire County Council wrote:See the Spin Doctors are out in force today!! make an official comment, leave column comments to us tax payers!
The new Elizabeth 11 Court building, or parts of it, have been open for more than a year. The public, staff, users and partners have made extensive use of the building since its staged opening. The media, including representatives of the Daily Echo, have attended meetings in the building. The Editor of the local newspaper, The Hampshire Chronicle, was invited to attend the official formal opening by the Lord Lieutenant on behalf of the Queen, as were regional broadcast media so it is not true to suggest that the media were not invited. The doors to the building, including secure office areas not usually open to the public, were thrown open in September, like many of our other buildings, for the national Heritage Open Days event and a Daily Echo/Hampshire Chronicle reporter was also given an private tour of the building, unlimited photographic opportunities and interviews when the first phase was completed. We are extremely proud of what has been achieved and we have been delighted to have had the opportunity to showcase these acheivements to a wide audience, including a number of journalists from national publications, as well as the hundreds of external visitors who come through the Elizabeth 11 Court doors every day.
Daily Echo
says...
3:51pm Tue 22 Dec 09
ChrisEastleigh wrote:As quoted in the story, the leader of the council, Ken Thornber, confirmed that no media organisation from Hampshire was invited to the opening.
So, were all journalists turned away, or just your photographer? What about the BBC, ITN, local radio or journos from other newspapers in Hampshire? Could it have been that your bloke didn't get his credentials sorted out beforehand and when he rocked up at the do with no invite, a press card and an "I've a right to be here" attitude, the security told him to sling his hook?
Ciaran
says...
4:00pm Tue 22 Dec 09
Major Sir Jerry Pending
says...
4:00pm Tue 22 Dec 09
freemantlegirl2
says...
5:18pm Tue 22 Dec 09
Ciaran wrote:LOL! guilty conscience obviously and confirmed by the Echo comment that they photographer was refused admission. Smacks of something to hide.!
I do hope the staff from HCC posting on this article are on holiday and not wasting tax payers' cash by posting while at work!!
southy
says...
6:18pm Tue 22 Dec 09
freemantlegirl2 wrote:note freemantle he or she will not get back on the question of that nf tory councilor was he invited or not. i have heard he was
Ciaran wrote:LOL! guilty conscience obviously and confirmed by the Echo comment that they photographer was refused admission. Smacks of something to hide.!
I do hope the staff from HCC posting on this article are on holiday and not wasting tax payers' cash by posting while at work!!
whelk
says...
6:31pm Tue 22 Dec 09
now in the north
says...
7:49pm Tue 22 Dec 09
whelk wrote:For your information, it most certainly is not a waste of time story.
haha so as usual muppets get up in arms over a pathetic non-story. Are the Echo so hard up that they have given up reporting actual newsworthy articles? For this to be the main headline shows why no-one buys such a poor excuse for a newspaper anymore.
Where will you all go when they go to the wall? too much to hope you may get jobs as you'd miss Jezza Kyle.
This reeks of the same crap when Saints banned them. Echo the innocent party as always to nasty saints, nasty council blah blah when just a cheap rag that has a lousy journalistic code who wheel out right-wing rent-a-quote at every opportunity as if that is some sort of benchmark of public opinion. Who is Christine Melsom some unemployed layabout who hates paying tax? And probably the editors spinster sister!
Hope Saints keep the ban up
Michael S
says...
8:21pm Tue 22 Dec 09
Militant Ford Worker
says...
9:09pm Tue 22 Dec 09
southy wrote:Who is that then I wonder?
Hampshire County Council wrote:Is it true, That our Southampton Councilor, The one that use to stand out side Colleges, And hand out National Front campaign leaflets, Was ask to attend.
The new Elizabeth 11 Court building, or parts of it, have been open for more than a year. The public, staff, users and partners have made extensive use of the building since its staged opening. The media, including representatives of the Daily Echo, have attended meetings in the building. The Editor of the local newspaper, The Hampshire Chronicle, was invited to attend the official formal opening by the Lord Lieutenant on behalf of the Queen, as were regional broadcast media so it is not true to suggest that the media were not invited. The doors to the building, including secure office areas not usually open to the public, were thrown open in September, like many of our other buildings, for the national Heritage Open Days event and a Daily Echo/Hampshire Chronicle reporter was also given an private tour of the building, unlimited photographic opportunities and interviews when the first phase was completed. We are extremely proud of what has been achieved and we have been delighted to have had the opportunity to showcase these acheivements to a wide audience, including a number of journalists from national publications, as well as the hundreds of external visitors who come through the Elizabeth 11 Court doors every day.
southy
says...
9:48pm Tue 22 Dec 09
Militant Ford Worker wrote:yes the little chappie
southy wrote:Who is that then I wonder?
Hampshire County Council wrote:Is it true, That our Southampton Councilor, The one that use to stand out side Colleges, And hand out National Front campaign leaflets, Was ask to attend.
The new Elizabeth 11 Court building, or parts of it, have been open for more than a year. The public, staff, users and partners have made extensive use of the building since its staged opening. The media, including representatives of the Daily Echo, have attended meetings in the building. The Editor of the local newspaper, The Hampshire Chronicle, was invited to attend the official formal opening by the Lord Lieutenant on behalf of the Queen, as were regional broadcast media so it is not true to suggest that the media were not invited. The doors to the building, including secure office areas not usually open to the public, were thrown open in September, like many of our other buildings, for the national Heritage Open Days event and a Daily Echo/Hampshire Chronicle reporter was also given an private tour of the building, unlimited photographic opportunities and interviews when the first phase was completed. We are extremely proud of what has been achieved and we have been delighted to have had the opportunity to showcase these acheivements to a wide audience, including a number of journalists from national publications, as well as the hundreds of external visitors who come through the Elizabeth 11 Court doors every day.
To whom are you alluding to Southy?
Surely not the little chappie?
Surely not!!
I can't believe it!
I do hope there is no truth to this.
Youthful indiscretions can sometimes come back to haunt one.
Baron76
says...
9:57am Wed 23 Dec 09
sotonwinch09
says...
11:57am Wed 23 Dec 09
ChrisEastleigh
says...
12:31pm Wed 23 Dec 09
Daily Echo wrote:Fair enough, I missed the line "Cllr Thornber confirmed that press and media organisations from across Hampshire had not been invited.", but their response and yours confirmed that the Hampshire Chronicle editor had been invited. So it wouldn't be true to say that no press had been invited, because the editor was. You've confirmed that the photographer didn't have an invite, only the editor. So he could have taken a camera in?
ChrisEastleigh wrote:As quoted in the story, the leader of the council, Ken Thornber, confirmed that no media organisation from Hampshire was invited to the opening.
So, were all journalists turned away, or just your photographer? What about the BBC, ITN, local radio or journos from other newspapers in Hampshire? Could it have been that your bloke didn't get his credentials sorted out beforehand and when he rocked up at the do with no invite, a press card and an "I've a right to be here" attitude, the security told him to sling his hook?
However, our photographer turned up on behalf of the editor of the Hampshire Chronicle, who had received an invite.
He acted in a professional and courteous manner, without having dealt with security - a press officer from Hampshire County Council refused him admission.
goard
says...
12:33pm Wed 23 Dec 09
Enter your postcode, town or place name
Search for jobs with the Daily Echo
Search Now »
Find the right person for you with the Daily Echo
Search Now »
Search for homes with the Daily Echo
Search Now »
Search for cars with the Daily Echo
Search Now »
Lone Ranger says...
12:33pm Tue 22 Dec 09
.
They are spending/wasting public money on the "add-on's", souvenir brochure's and lavish refereshments and all out of the public purse.
The sooner that this "leader" Thornber realises his place ( a public servant) the better. He is nothing more than a small person trying to wear big shoes