News RSS Feed Send your news, pictures & videos


Don’t carve up constituency


ISLE of Wight MP Andrew Turner is launching a campaign to stop the Government slicing his constituency in two and giving half to another MP.

The Conservative MP, pictured, said he would “vigorously oppose” any attempt to carve up the constituency after Prime Minister David Cameron told the Commons it was “not fair” that Mr Turner had to look after 110,000 constituents when the average constituency contained about 76,000 voters.

The Isle of Wight is currently the largest constituency in the UK, in population terms, and if boundaries were redrawn so that each MP represented the same number of people then the Island could end up being split into two, or parts of the Island joined politically with different parts of the mainland.

Mr Turner, who is leading a Westminster Hall debate on the matter today, said: “The Isle of Wight has a unique identity and needs special consideration. I will vigorously oppose any proposals to merge part of the Island with a mainland constituency.”

Mr Cameron, speaking during Prime Minister's Questions, said: “It is important that we have reform so that we have equal-sized constituencies across our country.”

Comments(9)

Redfield says...
9:09am Tue 15 Jun 10

Compared to the size of other constituencies IOW is tiddley and it is hard to fathom why they are even contemplating carving it up - especially when the gov are talking of reducing the number of MP's. I thought we'd got rid of the senseless logic of gov with the last lot but it seems there is still some leftovers!

southy says...
10:20am Tue 15 Jun 10

Redfield wrote:
Compared to the size of other constituencies IOW is tiddley and it is hard to fathom why they are even contemplating carving it up - especially when the gov are talking of reducing the number of MP's. I thought we'd got rid of the senseless logic of gov with the last lot but it seems there is still some leftovers!
its larger than southampton and yet we have 2 and 1/3 constituency, maybe it be good idea to take say 30 to 40,000 voters and add them to the new forest.

Adrian Smith says...
11:27am Tue 15 Jun 10

Redfield wrote:
Compared to the size of other constituencies IOW is tiddley and it is hard to fathom why they are even contemplating carving it up - especially when the gov are talking of reducing the number of MP's. I thought we'd got rid of the senseless logic of gov with the last lot but it seems there is still some leftovers!
Yes, they should be looking to grow the userbase to 100,000+ per constituency - and cutting the relevant number of MPs.
.
Does Turner manage those 110,000 well? I don't know but if he does then other MPs must be made to operate as efficiently as him.

JaneNB says...
11:30am Tue 15 Jun 10

Mr Turner should have encouraged a split in the IOW into 2 seats before the last election.

It would have addessed the overall iniquity.

Instead he acts like Canute, trying to order back the waves of equal representation. Past his sell by date?

Condor Man says...
1:08pm Tue 15 Jun 10

We don't need 650 MP's, it would be sensible for Southampton to have only 1 MP as opposed to 3. Given the time it takes Alan Whitehead to respond I'd give him the chop first.

SotonChris says...
1:20pm Tue 15 Jun 10

Redfield, the IoW costituency is the largest in the UK (103,000 voters) and it has 24,000 people more than the second largest (79,000)! Admittedly in terms of physical size it isn't huge, but if we worked off that principle then we'd have lots of seats in the highlands with only a couple of voters in each!

southy says...
2:22pm Tue 15 Jun 10

Adrian Smith wrote:
Redfield wrote:
Compared to the size of other constituencies IOW is tiddley and it is hard to fathom why they are even contemplating carving it up - especially when the gov are talking of reducing the number of MP's. I thought we'd got rid of the senseless logic of gov with the last lot but it seems there is still some leftovers!
Yes, they should be looking to grow the userbase to 100,000+ per constituency - and cutting the relevant number of MPs.
.
Does Turner manage those 110,000 well? I don't know but if he does then other MPs must be made to operate as efficiently as him.
i would agree with you on the equal amount off voters in each constituencys like the new forest only needs one mp. a lot off tory seats have less voters in there constituency and are rural.

Maine Lobster says...
4:33pm Tue 15 Jun 10

I expect the Government wants to create the opportunity for more Tory MP's. Now we have this unholy alliance of Cameron's cronies & Clegg's desperados, this is nothing more than a cynical move to try and strengthen their position in the house of commons.

I doubt you will see any constituency carve ups in Labour heartlands!

MapsMan says...
6:32pm Wed 16 Jun 10

Well, given that the IoW is used in the media as comparisons for land size / population, well here's a great opportunity to take that one step further: make each constituency the size as the IoW. That would probably mean about 50% fewer MPs nationally, if not more as - if I'm not wrong - Scottish constituencies have fewer electors.


Isle of Wight MP, Andrew Turner Don’t carve up constituency

Most popular






Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »

Local Businesses