Twyford Down campaigners warn of new road building 'menace' (From Daily Echo)
When news happens, text SDE and your photos or videos to 80360. Or contact us by email and phone.
Campaigners mark 20th anniversary of protest to stop re-routing of M3 motorway near Winchester
5:04pm Saturday 29th September 2012 in News By Echo Reporter
A protester is removed at Twyford Down during the campaign to stop the re-routing of the M3 in 1992
CAMPAIGNERS from around the country have joined a rally to mark the 20th anniversary of a Hampshire protest which changed the landscape of Government road-building policy for a generation.
The fight to save Twyford Down, near Winchester , from the diggers in the 1990s was a watershed moment for campaigners battling against road expansion by the then Conservative administration.
Today protesters warned that the country faces a major new programme of nationwide road-building.
About 100 people took part in the reunion where a 98ft banner was unfurled on top of the down which read: “Twenty years since Twyford Down. Don't go backwards, no new roads.”
Dr Chris Gillam, who returned to the site where he protested 20 years ago, said of the proposals for new roads: “Plans for these roads have already been fought and defeated.
“But, like zombies, they keep coming back. Their impacts haven't changed and local opposition will be just as strong.
“This weekend's event at Twyford Down will let people know what's coming.
“It will embolden and connect those who do not wish to see local environments destroyed and their towns and cities made even more car-dependent.
“And it will remind people that collectively taking action can change things.”
The Campaign for Better Transport has identified 70 projects across the country and expects hundreds more to emerge from local authority and Local Enterprise Partnership plans.
Chief executive Stephen Joseph said: “Government has forgotten the lessons they were taught at places like Twyford Down.
“Major road-building is slow, expensive and disastrous for the environment .
“By allowing a programme of road-building by stealth to develop, the Government is setting itself up for long and vociferous fights up and down the country.
“We need to deal with the real transport problems being faced by local communities.
“This means fixing potholes in existing roads, investing in decent public transport services and getting freight off road and on to rail.”
The Twyford Down campaign by grassroots environmentalists like the Dongas Tribe, Road Alert and Earth First, and aided by organisations like Greenpeace and Friends of the Earth, was joined by local people who wanted to keep the ancient down and it went nationwide.
Work to cut a 40ft wide and 100ft deep, two-mile cutting through the chalk face of the down for the M3 extension started in 1992 and led to bitter fights, with several protesters eventually being jailed.
Campaigners occupied the site in tunnels and chained themselves to diggers in an attempt to stop the extension after years of legal challenges to the work failed.
It was the UK's first road protest camp but soon it was a tactic familiar across the country in the years to come in places like Newbury in Berkshire.
The extension was completed in 1994, but at a high cost, and the countrywide opposition forced the Government to rethink.
It initially cut an ugly white chalk scar into the landscape around Winchester but, in later years, it has grown over and become less of an eyesore.
The Government pressed ahead with Twyford Down because it had instigated an ambitious expansion of roads in the UK after a controversial White Paper in 1989 called Roads To Prosperity signalled a multibillion-pound spend on 500 road-building schemes.
But by 1994, research found more roads led only to more cars and alternative ideas to limit car use started to be considered, with the Labour government then scrapping the expansion.
Twyford Down caused such emotion because it had been designated a Site of Special Scientific Interest, was recognised as a gathering place for ancient tribes and was criss-crossed by “Dongas” - a network of ancient pathways.
But the existing road network around Winchester had also become a bottleneck, with major roads like the A34, A31 and A33 meeting in the city.
A bypass, built in the 1930s, helped but, by the 1990s, that represented the missing link in the M3 from London to Southampton with traffic queuing for miles at the infamous Hockley traffic lights just outside the city.
Comments(19)
MGRA
says...
5:52pm Sat 29 Sep 12
Fatty x Ford Worker
says...
5:55pm Sat 29 Sep 12
dango
says...
6:25pm Sat 29 Sep 12
MGRA wrote:beat me to it! They bought Fiat vans, seriously?
what is shocking is that the police actually had vans made by that company !!
8089
says...
6:38pm Sat 29 Sep 12
MGRA
says...
6:46pm Sat 29 Sep 12
dango wrote:incredible..... Fred Flintstone mobiles would have been a better option ,,, surely !
MGRA wrote:beat me to it! They bought Fiat vans, seriously?
what is shocking is that the police actually had vans made by that company !!
huckit P
says...
6:56pm Sat 29 Sep 12
espanuel
says...
6:57pm Sat 29 Sep 12
Tottonion
says...
7:23pm Sat 29 Sep 12
So what changed at Twyford Down???
downfader
says...
7:30pm Sat 29 Sep 12
huckit P wrote:You bet..? How about going to find out how many have been in work since or during?
Yes, the protests certainly changed things - like the final bill which had to be paid by the average taxpayer (and I bet there weren't many of those in the protesters camp!).
There are better ways of dealing with traffic than building too many roads. In the last DFT traffic report it was established that for the 2011 period that 66% of all journeys were for less than 5 miles. In the 2010 report the average trip distance was figured out to be 6 miles.
On that basis there is no need for more road infrastructure - just some pragmatism on how we use them
100%HANTSBOY
says...
7:40pm Sat 29 Sep 12
downfader wrote:Yes totally agree,time to increase bus routes and reduce bus fares,and train fares.
huckit P wrote:You bet..? How about going to find out how many have been in work since or during?
Yes, the protests certainly changed things - like the final bill which had to be paid by the average taxpayer (and I bet there weren't many of those in the protesters camp!).
There are better ways of dealing with traffic than building too many roads. In the last DFT traffic report it was established that for the 2011 period that 66% of all journeys were for less than 5 miles. In the 2010 report the average trip distance was figured out to be 6 miles.
On that basis there is no need for more road infrastructure - just some pragmatism on how we use them
Obviously there is no incentive (green or financial) for the Govts. of the time to force people out of their cars and onto public transport.
Car sharing should be pushed more
Coach travel and new coach stations and out of town park and ride is the way forward.
downfader
says...
7:56pm Sat 29 Sep 12
100%HANTSBOY wrote:Agree. Car-pooling is very beneficial, cheap. Bus/train firms have to think more about their customers than their shareholders too, suspect thats a major factor in high fares.
downfader wrote:Yes totally agree,time to increase bus routes and reduce bus fares,and train fares.
huckit P wrote:You bet..? How about going to find out how many have been in work since or during?
Yes, the protests certainly changed things - like the final bill which had to be paid by the average taxpayer (and I bet there weren't many of those in the protesters camp!).
There are better ways of dealing with traffic than building too many roads. In the last DFT traffic report it was established that for the 2011 period that 66% of all journeys were for less than 5 miles. In the 2010 report the average trip distance was figured out to be 6 miles.
On that basis there is no need for more road infrastructure - just some pragmatism on how we use them
Obviously there is no incentive (green or financial) for the Govts. of the time to force people out of their cars and onto public transport.
Car sharing should be pushed more
Coach travel and new coach stations and out of town park and ride is the way forward.
One other way of reducing traffic - buy food shopping online. One lorry can deliver to many, many homes.
Maine Lobster
says...
9:11am Sun 30 Sep 12
Tottonion wrote:People taking collective action cand change things. eg the anti Poll Tax movement which included a cross section of the community uniting against an unjust tax.
And it will remind people that collectively taking action can change things.”
So what changed at Twyford Down???
The Twyford Down protesters were a few genuine environmentalists supported by the usual bunch of serial yobbos up for a ruck with the Police.
the majority of society wanted the cutting done, thank heavens!
If the cause is right, the people will come!
downfader
says...
9:19am Sun 30 Sep 12
You have to admit - isnt it a bit rich to throw money at this when there are roads in such disrepair... where councils and the highways agency both end up saying "we cant budget for fixing the problem."
This government should throw the money at repairing what we currently have instead
Torchie1
says...
10:03am Sun 30 Sep 12
downfader wrote:If you drive sensibly and watch the road ahead for obvious hazards, the modern suspension and tyres can cope with a less than perfect surface.
Part of the issue for me is how we're supposed to be going through austerity, and this Government have committed more money to road building than the last. They've been throwing lots of money at quangos and contractors to investigate potential routes, look at rerouting homes, business and farming.
You have to admit - isnt it a bit rich to throw money at this when there are roads in such disrepair... where councils and the highways agency both end up saying "we cant budget for fixing the problem."
This government should throw the money at repairing what we currently have instead
forest hump
says...
10:07am Sun 30 Sep 12
bogart259
says...
11:25am Sun 30 Sep 12
Maine Lobster wrote:The majority of the people never wanted the cutting - most people in Winchester wanted the tunnel. That is why the Tories lost the seat in Winchester after the motorway was completed.
Tottonion wrote:People taking collective action cand change things. eg the anti Poll Tax movement which included a cross section of the community uniting against an unjust tax.
And it will remind people that collectively taking action can change things.”
So what changed at Twyford Down???
The Twyford Down protesters were a few genuine environmentalists supported by the usual bunch of serial yobbos up for a ruck with the Police.
the majority of society wanted the cutting done, thank heavens!
If the cause is right, the people will come!
Torchie1
says...
2:11pm Sun 30 Sep 12
bogart259 wrote:I hope it's not an exaggerated figure but I would suggest that the millions of people who have now used this sensible addition to the network don't care whether they went through or under the hill that was there before.
Maine Lobster wrote:The majority of the people never wanted the cutting - most people in Winchester wanted the tunnel. That is why the Tories lost the seat in Winchester after the motorway was completed.
Tottonion wrote:People taking collective action cand change things. eg the anti Poll Tax movement which included a cross section of the community uniting against an unjust tax.
And it will remind people that collectively taking action can change things.”
So what changed at Twyford Down???
The Twyford Down protesters were a few genuine environmentalists supported by the usual bunch of serial yobbos up for a ruck with the Police.
the majority of society wanted the cutting done, thank heavens!
If the cause is right, the people will come!
Urbane Forager
says...
9:24am Mon 1 Oct 12
CHARLIE TAYLOR wrote:Sadly, Swampie died recently...
whatever happened to Swampie?
He suffered a nasty heart attack and was taken to hospital...
The doctors offered him a by-pass but he refused on enviromental and ethical grounds...
(ho ho ho) ;-)
We did a lovely walk round Twyford Down recently; it does have a golf course on top of it, which spoils the view somewhat.
We were looking for walnuts, we found more than 20 trees but could always hear the seething motorway traffic in the background, roaring through the M3 cut.
http://theurbanefora
ger.blogspot.co.uk/2
012/09/walnuts-water
-walk.html
CHARLIE TAYLOR says...
5:36pm Sat 29 Sep 12