Campaign to save Southampton's cardiac unit reaches Downing Street

Daily Echo reporter Melanie Adams (far right)and campaigners take the Have A Heart petition to Downing Street Daily Echo reporter Melanie Adams (far right)and campaigners take the Have A Heart petition to Downing Street

ARMED with 232,733 signatures, the Daily Echo and an army of campaigners have taken the fight to save children’s heart surgery at Southampton to the doorstep of Number 10.

Take Part in the Consultation
Click here to help save the heart unit.
The consultation is what the government will use to evaluate which units it will keep. It is imperative that as many people as possible use this opportunity to say they want 'Option B' which will save Southampton's children's cardiac unit.

At 1pm we knocked on the famous door and delivered ten boxes packed with Have a Heart petitions, with the hope of driving home the message to the Prime Minister and his government that the future of Southampton General Hospital’s specialist unit must be saved.

But this does not mean that the fight is over.

There are still nine days to go before the end of the consultation and our MPs have vowed to keep fighting in the corridors of power to ensure the right decision is made at the end of this year.

Just 24 hours after we drop off the petitions to David Cameron, the MP for Winchester and Chandlers Ford, Steve Brine, has secured a three-hour debate in the House of Commons, into the review.

Mr Brine said: “MPs across the House are worried about this process and it is excellent that the issues will be debated in full on the floor of the House of Commons itself.

“I hope the review team will listen very carefully to the arguments put forward and act appropriately to ensure public confidence is not further eroded.”

Also at Downing Street was Caroline Nokes, MP for Romsey and Southampton North, who believes it is imperative that she and her colleagues ensure that government are aware of the campaign.

She said: “A total of 232,000 signatures is a phenomenal number but it is not just about the support, it is also about the individual stories and how strongly parents and former patients feel about this unit.

“It is imperative that we as MPs today, Thursday and in the final few days of the consultation process, convey the message that if surgery at Southampton is stopped it would be a ludicrous conclusion of a review that is supposed to be about safety.

“Every time we see the Prime Minister and the Health Minister we are all pushing this message.”

Despite being ranked the second best in the country our paediatric heart unit is under threat as health chiefs look to cut the UK's 11 centres down to six or seven.

Southampton was featured in just one of four options which will be put out for public consultation, before the Joint Committee of Primary Care Trusts (JCPCT) makes its final decision.

If Southampton closed, families would be forced to get life-saving treatment in London or Bristol, at units which experts say fell below the “exemplary”

standards that the city boasts.

John Denham, MP for Southampton Itchen, added: “The petition is hugely important but I am going to continue to bombard ministers with different aspects of the case, telling them why so many people are unhappy about the way the consultation has been conducted, to ensure all factors have been properly taken into account.

“This is not a selfish attitude.

We are not just fighting this because it happens to be in Southampton, this about making sure that children right across the country have got the chance to be treated at one of the best hospital units in the country.”

• Since this story was first printed, more signatures have been received by the Daily Echo, taking the final total to over 250,000.

Comments(11)

BMWDellboy says...
12:22pm Wed 22 Jun 11

With only nine days to go we need to keep the pressure on to retain this highly rated specialist unit.

southy says...
1:37pm Wed 22 Jun 11

The Government going to do what it wants to do, and that is the break up the NHS a bit more to get ready to be sold off.

But all the same good luck people lets hope the right thing is done, for the benefit of ordinary people.

StEmmosfire says...
2:47pm Wed 22 Jun 11

A battle worth fighting for. This is far more important to protest about than the binmens measley 2% cuts on their already over inflated wages and overtime scam.

SpittingMoreFire says...
3:25pm Wed 22 Jun 11

AAll wrote:
Just one question: have the people using Oxford been asked about travelling to Southampton?

Read the following.......

Excellent heart care on our doorstep
Press Release 1312
20 April 2011

Excellent heart care on our doorstep

The family of toddler Tayla Smith are urging Northamptonshire people to support the specialist children's heart care services at Glenfield Hospital 'on their doorstep'.

Born in November 2009 with two holes in her heart, Tayla, from Kettering, was due to go to John Radcliffe Hospital in Oxford early in 2010, but they suspended surgery amid concerns over safety.

Instead she and her family faced a three-hour journey to have treatment, when Tayla was offered alternative surgery in Southampton, but mum Tracey was determined she would go to Glenfield Hospital's East Midlands Congenital Heart Centre (EMCHC).

"When your child is seriously ill, you will travel to the ends of the earth to get the best care," says her mum Tracey who searched the internet and found that one of the best centres was just half an hour away.

"Because it is such a massive operation, you are on the internet and always looking into it and there was Glenfield Until then I didn't know it was a children's heart hospital. We looked at the surgeons, and their success rates, and that's how I knew about Glenfield."

Specialists at Glenfield saw Tayla and made a decision to delay surgery to allow Tayla's body to naturally mend the smaller of the two holes, she underwent successful surgery in September 2010. By this time the smaller hole had closed.

Before her surgery, Tayla was admitted to her local hospital with a chest infection. When it progressed to pneumonia she was transferred to the Leicester Royal Infirmary. "When she nearly died, they were on our doorstep. The consultant came over from Glenfield and saw her - we wouldn't get that if she had gone to Southampton."

Tayla spent six days in Glenfield Hospital, during which time, her mum, Tracey, dad, Steve and 12-year-old brother, Owen, stayed with her.

"It did make a difference, because my husband would have been with me anyway but for my son, he could go home if it was too much for him - it's only half an hour away. If we had been in Southampton, he would have had to have stayed at home and they woud have been extra stress, trying to find someone who could look after him. And being so local, my family could come every day."

Now 16 months old, Tayla, from Kettering, is doing well.

Mr Atillio Lotto, consultant paediatric surgeon at the East Midlands Congenital Heart Centre at Glenfield Hospital, said: "As Tayla's family lives in Kettering I was not surprised to know that after she was referred for her surgery to Southampton General Hospital, which is more than two and half hours journey from Kettering, Tayla’s mum and dad asked to be referred to Glenfield Hospital in Leicester.

"Patients should be made aware that they have a choice over where they want to receive treatment."

The future of Glenfield's children's surgical centre is uncertain after a national NHS review recommended reducing the number of surgical centres. This review, called safe and sustainable, has come up with four options for the future. Each option is a set of surgical centres. The East Midlands Congenital Heart Centre at Glenfield is only in one option - option A.

A public consultation is now asking for your views on these options. Mr Lotto, added: "We need you, our patients and our public, to have your say during this consultation and support 'option A' to help us to hold on to our hearts and keep children's heart surgery at Glenfield Hospital.”
I can't bear cut 'n' paste journalism.
.
But you do put forward the case that if Southampton 'wins' its fight, it will inevitably be at cost to another children's cardiac unit elsewhere and the local community it serves. Perhaps we all should have come together and forced the Government to think again.
.
May I take this opportunity to sincerely thank the Echo's Ms Adams for all her hard work and those readers who have shared their stories with us. It has been humbling. I hope your efforts will not be in vain.
.
SAVE OUR CHILDREN'S CARDIAC UNIT!
.

ydkjs2 says...
4:49pm Wed 22 Jun 11

I no longer live in England but I have read with interest the fight to keep this facility open. I just don't understand the decision to close a 'life saving' unit. Surely it is more vital to keep it open and continue to save children. Why is this happening?

Condor Man says...
4:49pm Wed 22 Jun 11

I see the brazen denham gets in on the photo opportunity.

Lone Ranger. says...
8:59pm Wed 22 Jun 11

Thank God Cllr Smith didnt get too involved after his massive mistake addressing the letter to Andrew Lansley, "SHADOW" UK Secretary of State for Health.
.
Still another what do you expect. After all its boys doing an mans job.
.
Thank goodness he was never good enough to be an MP

Shoong says...
11:59am Thu 23 Jun 11

southy wrote:
The Government going to do what it wants to do, and that is the break up the NHS a bit more to get ready to be sold off.

But all the same good luck people lets hope the right thing is done, for the benefit of ordinary people.
Class card again.

Ragdolly says...
12:28pm Thu 23 Jun 11

I think it's really important for us to emphasize that throughout our "Save Our Heart Unit" campaign we have NOT and will NOT be detrimental to other units unlike others who insist on posting on here! We are fighting to ensure that our children get the best QUALITY of care and Southampton's Children's Cardiac Unit is ranked 2nd in the whole country so there is no question that we have a unit that is already achieving very successful surgical outcomes and in the same review our centre was noted for it's exemplary PICU and for Innovation and Research, our team in Southampton are and have been for decades undertaking the most complex surgical procedures with the best results in the country.
Our "fight" to retain our surgical centre is justified because this review is about achieving a Quality, Safe & Sustainable service for our children now and in the furture and we have been acknowledged in Sir Ian Kennedy's review last summer to be at the top of the game for delivering all this and more because we are ranked 2nd!!!

suidafrica says...
11:37pm Thu 23 Jun 11

Just an observation on the 'spiting more fire' article above.
This article seems to imply that had the child in question gone to Southampton she would have received an inferior service particularly when she became very unwell with pneumonia. The Southampton team have an excellent mobile intensive care service which transports children who need intensive care from their local hospitals back to Southampton. The Southampton consultants often travel as part of this team to local hospitals to stabilise sick children. And as the PICU and the children's cardiac services are in the same hospital, the consultants don't need to travel between hospitals to review cardiac patients who are admitted to PICU - they are availble on site to see the children whenever and as often as it is needed even if the child's heart problem is not the main reason they are in hospital.

It's wonderful if children can have complex medical close to their homes but it's wrong to imply that had this child been cared for in Southampton, she would have received less attention from the consultants or inferior care.

SpittingMoreFire says...
3:54am Fri 24 Jun 11

suidafrica wrote:
Just an observation on the 'spiting more fire' article above.
This article seems to imply that had the child in question gone to Southampton she would have received an inferior service particularly when she became very unwell with pneumonia. The Southampton team have an excellent mobile intensive care service which transports children who need intensive care from their local hospitals back to Southampton. The Southampton consultants often travel as part of this team to local hospitals to stabilise sick children. And as the PICU and the children's cardiac services are in the same hospital, the consultants don't need to travel between hospitals to review cardiac patients who are admitted to PICU - they are availble on site to see the children whenever and as often as it is needed even if the child's heart problem is not the main reason they are in hospital.

It's wonderful if children can have complex medical close to their homes but it's wrong to imply that had this child been cared for in Southampton, she would have received less attention from the consultants or inferior care.
Firstly, I did not cut 'n' paste that article above.
.
It is a press release from somewhere else for their save their cardiac unit campaign. Someone has chosen to post here and I made a response to it.
.
That article talks about the possibility of closure of the Oxford unit, where the community there will have to travel miles to get to another unit. Just the same as if Southampton's unit is closed. We are talking about the possibility of up to five unit closures nationwide after all.
.
If you are unhappy with the content of that article implying that Southampton would give inferior care, take it up with whoever wrote the press release.
.
I can't bear cut 'n' paste journalism, and I did not dump it here.
.
FYI: I am of the opinion that none of these centres should be closed, plus Southampton should never have been considered for closure in the first place.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree