Premier League chairmen split over cost controls

Daily Echo: Saints chairman Nicola Cortese Saints chairman Nicola Cortese

Barclays Premier League chairmen are split over how to introduce cost controls to England's top flight despite broad support for some measures.

Although a majority of the 20 clubs who attended a shareholders' meeting today are supportive of bringing in financial controls, major differences of opinion remain over what form these should take.

The meeting at the Premier League's headquarters ended with no decision taken, and the league's executives will now try to draw up some detailed proposals on a range of options ahead of a meeting in February.

Any decision is likely to come into force from the start of next season.

Some clubs such as Arsenal and Manchester United want clubs to be obliged to break even every year, while it is understood others argued at today's meeting that owners should be allowed to put in their own money to subsidise spending. There was also disagreement over the level of owner investment that should be permitted.

Other clubs, including Fulham, believe there should be no restrictions at all while yet another group including Sunderland want the controls to only be short-term restrictions on player wage increases.

There have now been five meetings of top-flight chairmen where cost controls have been discussed without any concrete decisions being made.

West Ham co-owner David Gold told Press Association Sport: ''There have been no decisions made. The debate carries on. I am hoping that we can come to some conclusions for the best interest of the football clubs and the league as whole, hopefully before the start of next season.''

Swansea chairman Huw Jenkins said he was hopeful an agreement could be reached.

He said: ''I think we will get a consensus on this. Over the next few months we should get something in place, most likely before the start of next season.

''The main issue is that in the present economic climate, we as a league, portray the right image and make sure that everyone involved in football is looking after the supporters and making sure everything is kept under control and is run in the right manner.''

Jenkins added: ''We are looking at the financial fair play rules and introducing that throughout the Premier League for the good of everyone in the Premier League and for the good of the game.

''I see it generally as a good discussion about making sure the Premier League retains its position as the number one league in the world and that we keep portraying the right image.

''It's great that we have got everyone on board all fighting for the same cause. It should work well for everyone connected in football.''

Comments (7)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

6:20pm Thu 15 Nov 12

TEBOURBA says...

What did our illustrious Chairman say, or wouldn't he talk to anyone and no one to him??
What did our illustrious Chairman say, or wouldn't he talk to anyone and no one to him?? TEBOURBA

6:59pm Thu 15 Nov 12

OSPREYSAINT says...

TEBOURBA wrote:
What did our illustrious Chairman say, or wouldn't he talk to anyone and no one to him??
Wouldn't you like to know, but of course you never will.
[quote][p][bold]TEBOURBA[/bold] wrote: What did our illustrious Chairman say, or wouldn't he talk to anyone and no one to him??[/p][/quote]Wouldn't you like to know, but of course you never will. OSPREYSAINT

7:05pm Thu 15 Nov 12

slugger says...

TEBOURBA wrote:
What did our illustrious Chairman say, or wouldn't he talk to anyone and no one to him??
he said he had no choice but to sack you alan .
[quote][p][bold]TEBOURBA[/bold] wrote: What did our illustrious Chairman say, or wouldn't he talk to anyone and no one to him??[/p][/quote]he said he had no choice but to sack you alan . slugger

7:10pm Thu 15 Nov 12

angus mc coatup says...

TEBOURBA wrote:
What did our illustrious Chairman say, or wouldn't he talk to anyone and no one to him??
what he did say was.
"that tebourba must be the biggest tw@t ever, and knows far kall "

ryrihf !!!!!!!!
[quote][p][bold]TEBOURBA[/bold] wrote: What did our illustrious Chairman say, or wouldn't he talk to anyone and no one to him??[/p][/quote]what he did say was. "that tebourba must be the biggest tw@t ever, and knows far kall " ryrihf !!!!!!!! angus mc coatup

12:06am Fri 16 Nov 12

randre says...

TEBOURBA wrote:
What did our illustrious Chairman say, or wouldn't he talk to anyone and no one to him??
I don't know, I wasn't there.
[quote][p][bold]TEBOURBA[/bold] wrote: What did our illustrious Chairman say, or wouldn't he talk to anyone and no one to him??[/p][/quote]I don't know, I wasn't there. randre

2:30am Fri 16 Nov 12

thehoggsback says...

TEBOURBA wrote:
What did our illustrious Chairman say, or wouldn't he talk to anyone and no one to him??
he said he could smell you. FOADP
[quote][p][bold]TEBOURBA[/bold] wrote: What did our illustrious Chairman say, or wouldn't he talk to anyone and no one to him??[/p][/quote]he said he could smell you. FOADP thehoggsback

10:07am Fri 16 Nov 12

Jesus_02 says...

My Opinion is that whatever is introduced should allow for unlimited investment but also ensure sustainability.

If a chairman wants to employ Messi over 3 years and give him a 100m one off payment and only pay him 20k a week then that’s fine by me as long as the clubs income covers the 20k a week. It the chairman’s prerogative and it’s his money to waste.

Basically running cost should not be allowed to income.

One off Investments and Income from player trading should never be allowed to offset a clubs wage burden. This would leave player purchases to be offset by player sales or investment.

Otherwise you end up with a system where by you need to spend money that you have made by the end of the financial year or lose it in the calculation of “Income”
My Opinion is that whatever is introduced should allow for unlimited investment but also ensure sustainability. If a chairman wants to employ Messi over 3 years and give him a 100m one off payment and only pay him 20k a week then that’s fine by me as long as the clubs income covers the 20k a week. It the chairman’s prerogative and it’s his money to waste. Basically running cost should not be allowed to income. One off Investments and Income from player trading should never be allowed to offset a clubs wage burden. This would leave player purchases to be offset by player sales or investment. Otherwise you end up with a system where by you need to spend money that you have made by the end of the financial year or lose it in the calculation of “Income” Jesus_02

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

Get Adobe Flash player
About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree