- Mobile site
- E-Newsletters
-
- News feed
- Find us on Twitter
@dailyecho
Daily Echo on Twitter
@the_saints
Saints News on Twitter
SceneSouth
Leisure news on Twitter
- Find us on Facebook
Facebook
Daily Echo on Facebook
Players heading for St Mary's exit (From Daily Echo)
When news happens, text SDE and your photos or videos to 80360. Or contact us by email and phone.
Players heading for St Mary's exit
10:50am Thursday 3rd January 2013 in Sport
By Simon Carter, Sports Editor
LEE BARNARD
THERE are several obvious candidates for the exit door if Saints are aiming to trim their squad during the current transfer window.
While most of the talk revolves around which players the club could sign, this month is also a chance to either sell or loan out those who are currently out of favour at St Mary’s.
As revealed in the Daily Echo last month, several players are out of contract in the summer.
Jason Puncheon, now free to talk to foreign clubs if any were interested, is the only one currently in the first team picture who is seeking a new deal.
Others include Danny Butterfield, Frazer Richardson, Richard Chaplow, Ryan Dickson, Danny Seaborne and Tommy Forecast.
In addition, strikers Lee Barnard and Jonathan Forte are well down the pecking order.
Full backs Butterfield and Dickson have yet to appear in the Premier League this season, so appear well out of the frame.
Dickson, who didn’t make a single league appearance last season either for Saints, wasn’t even included in the Capital One Cup tie at Leeds when Nigel Adkins made 11 changes.
There seems little point keeping Dickson at the club when he is capable of doing a good job in the lower divisions.
The same applies to Butterfield, who is mainly a right back but who has seen the likes of centre half Maya Yoshida and even midfielder Jack Cork played in that position ahead of him this season.
Richardson is in the same position as Butterfield, but at least he has played in the league this season.
The last of his four appearances came at Stoke recently, showing Adkins at least still has the former Leeds and Charlton man in his immediate plans.
Steve De Ridder is in a similar position.
The Belgian winger hadn’t appeared in the Premier League all season prior to a sub outing against Sunderland just before Christmas, and he made another late cameo appearance against Arsenal on New Year’s Day.
Does that signal a change of heart from the manager that De Ridder still has a major role to play at the club?
Barnard has just returned to St Mary’s after spending the first half of 2012/13 on loan at Bournemouth.
Though initially a regular starter, Barnard hasn’t even been on the bench for Cherries lately as Eddie Howe has partnered Lewis Grabban and Brett Pitman, with the likes of Matt Tubbs on the bench.
Forte has also been loaned out this season, to another League 1 promotion hopeful, Crawley Town.
Adkins is expected to be looking to loan out the two strikers again, even though Saints will soon be a striker down when Emmanuel Mayuka links up with Zambia for their forthcoming African Cup of Nations tournament.
There appears no point keeping players at the club if they are nowhere near the first team squad.
There isn’t even a reserve league anymore to keep the fringe players match fit.
Another man who could benefit from a move away from St Mary’s is Chaplow.
A top performer during Saints’ 2010/11 League 1 promotion winning side, the midfielder has only made two sub appearances in the top flight this term.
Out of contract in the summer, it is currently hard to see him being handed a new deal.
The same goes for Seaborne, who has been on loan at Championship club Charlton since November.
Though Adkins is hardly spoilt for choice when it comes to central defenders, the former Exeter City captain has not played in the Premier League.
Instead, Saints are expected to either look abroad or closer to home for the new blood that is needed to shore up what is still one of the leakiest defences in the top flight.
Comments(45)
allsaintsnocurves
says...
11:27am Thu 3 Jan 13
Cork showed he is a better right back than Butterfield and Richardson for me. I'd also have Reeves in at left back ahead of Dickson or Fox.
De Ridder hasn't made much of an impact since joining the club...he may have had the odd chance but I'd expect him to be sold.
SO50 Saint
says...
11:32am Thu 3 Jan 13
sarfhamton
says...
11:36am Thu 3 Jan 13
billythesaint
says...
11:36am Thu 3 Jan 13
NC Fan4Life
says...
11:52am Thu 3 Jan 13
However the most important thing is to bring in 3 or 4 new signings who are BETTER than what we have got.
1. A Goalkeeper (Butland or better)
2. A Centerback (Dawson / Astori quality)
3. An influencial Midfielder (Lampard quality)
4. A quick winger who can cross well
5. Possible fullback as cover.
6. And what about Henry on loan ? He and Lampard would give confidence.
NA & NC need to get these asap before the Aston Villa game which is a vital six pointer as we will only have 16 games after that to get more than a point a game which includes against all the top six teams.
Come on NC/NA don't leave it too late, others are already making signings, together we can do it.
Come on you red & white pin stripes !!
Saints n Winners
says...
12:16pm Thu 3 Jan 13
Confucious
says...
12:30pm Thu 3 Jan 13
Admittedly these people helped get us where we are, but we can't afford to be sentimental. They should now go to Bournemouth where they will be more useful.
We should at least offload all those who boo our own players or boo when the half or full time whistle goes when we are trailing or have lost.
Come on Nicola - get moving and sort 'em out.
El Santo
says...
12:57pm Thu 3 Jan 13
SO50 Saint wrote:I feel really sorry for them. They have helped us to get here. I am particularly fond of Chaplow, who I thought (obviously in disagreement with NA, which disqualifies my thoughts) would make a great addition to our team since he is so good as a holding midfielder. I still think he is PL quality, given the chance of playing 2-3 games in a row. He could be the man we need to strengthen our relatively weak defense.
With these players all you can do is thank them for their efforts and allow them to move on if possible. The likes of Barney, Chappers, Butterfield all did fantastic jobs in the lower leagues andf hopefully they will all be able to find new teams with similar ambitions to themselves. Suprised no mid table sides in the championship have looked at Chaplow
damoose
says...
1:00pm Thu 3 Jan 13
RedArmy1
says...
1:02pm Thu 3 Jan 13
Looking forward to VILLA AWAY.
Now Saints have established themselves in the premiership the games are very competitive.
WIGAN AWAY will also be another Target games for Maximum Points.
Regarding the CUP and Chelsea.
Give Artur Borac game time. Do not put Kelvin back in goal.
Put out a Strong Team - (not like Leeds) and Give our Team the opportunity to play against the European Champions - not as a warm up game - but gain valuable experience.
We have to play them in the League. Let Nigel and the Team make a name for themselves.
WE CAN WIN AGAINST ANYONE AT HOME.
LET'S CONTINUE THE MOMENTUM.
NIGEL DO NOT - JUST PUT OUT A WEAKENED SIDE.
WE ARE SOUTHAMPTON. COYR.
NikkkoNik
says...
1:02pm Thu 3 Jan 13
RedArmy1
says...
1:05pm Thu 3 Jan 13
The only time I can foresee any Trouble with Supporters this Season at St Mary's may be when we play Chelsea.
They are not called Chelskum for nothing with their blue travelling fans.
NO-ONE DICTATES TERMS AT ST MARY'S.
We have seen off leeds millwall etc ..
WE ARE SOUTHAMPTON. COYR.
SaintJD
says...
1:10pm Thu 3 Jan 13
St Retford
says...
1:25pm Thu 3 Jan 13
They could probably just about buy Luke Shaw for that, so it's a bit of a worry.
SaintJD
says...
1:32pm Thu 3 Jan 13
NikkkoNik wrote:Saying Nigel put in Boruc because he knew we'd be beaten is nonsense surely and, from what I heard of the QPR game they showed absolutely no desire to win the game, but happened to sneak a lucky win (deserved though on their effort and commitment) with a rare attack.
I would like to see two new players, Goalkeeper, proven PL experience, Jack is too young and similar to Gazza, so not likely to do anything this season. I think a strong holding midfielder like a Veria type. Cork and Spider have being OK, but they get bullied with stronger teams and if one was injured we would be stuffed. If we then had money to burn a new winger/striker with pace and ability and perhaps another defender. I still believe we are throwing away too many points regularly; goalkeeping is still a big concern. We should have played Borac earlier and decided if he was good enough, we wasted our time playing Kelvin again; he had already failed on many occasions at this level. If I was the manager asking for money for another goalkeeper, the board might say, you have not played the last one you got. I partially believe Nigel expected to get beat by Arsenal and Borac would have proven he is not capable at this level, instead, he may just need more games and he will get better. Secondly Nigel will have to raise his game in the second half; QPR raised the bar last night and instead of holding on for a draw with Arsenal, Nigel will have to go for the win. We will need an additional 7 wins to stay up. All the teams around us will strengthen and I know it sounds obvious, once January ends it will be too late.
If anything, the QPR result is proof that there are other ways of winning than going gung-ho - you can hold out for a draw, hang on in there and sneak a result on the break.
Obviously agree we need to strengthen and shore up the defence though - without silly individual mistakes from players who aren't up to it we would have got far more points on the board in the early part of the season, and against Stoke, when we brought one or two of them back in. Clearly need cover all across the back.
legod7
says...
1:54pm Thu 3 Jan 13
El Santo
says...
2:05pm Thu 3 Jan 13
legod7 wrote:Yes... and no. The 5 bookings are written off as of 31st of December. So he doesn't miss the game.
Off subject. Is Schneiderlan now on 5 bookings for the season ? If so he will miss the Chelsea game
SO50 Saint
says...
2:24pm Thu 3 Jan 13
saintlysoul
says...
2:25pm Thu 3 Jan 13
SO50 Saint
says...
2:26pm Thu 3 Jan 13
CB FRY LIVES
says...
2:59pm Thu 3 Jan 13
Saints n Winners wrote:Looks as if JOE COLE is going back to West Ham.oNE WEST HAM PLAYER WHO WOULD DO OK for SAINTS is VAZ TE.
I agree on Dawson at Spurs. Forget Lampard, he is still on the England scene and will set his sights a bit higher than us. I do think that Joe Cole is a possibility though. We need to be ruthless with our goalies though; Shelve Kelv and get Friedel in, then we will have 2 higher level experienced guys battling it for the shirt with a youngster learning off of them.
hedge end bob
says...
3:29pm Thu 3 Jan 13
saintlysoul wrote:Like te idea playing J W P , but whatwouldyou do with Clyne??. He has worked well with Puncheon so far and can defend.
I thought Jack Cork did well at right back against Arsenal. What trying this. Leave him at right back then play JWP as a holding / creative midfielder in front of the defence and Spider Ramirez and Davis in the middle. I thought jwpblooked lively when he came on against Arsenal he is composed and a good distributor of the ball moreover he's not frightened to get stuck in! Just a thought!!!
Crispinmumbles
says...
3:35pm Thu 3 Jan 13
CB FRY LIVES wrote:Yeh, Vaz Te misses even more spectacularly than Do Prado. Dawson would be a good shout if he weren't so injury prone. We need to out the likes of Barnard, Butterfield, Seabourne and De Ridder, Fox, Boruc and Do Prado who aren't good enough. I feel sorry for Chappers, deserves more of a go but experienced English speaking premiership players are a must (less time required to settle). Paul Robinson and Joelyn Lescott fit the bill and Wayne Bridge is on loan at Brighton so we could wangle a deal for him as City might recall to sell. Players with something left in the tank who know the score and would add quality and experience if the wages can be done sensibly. Also how about Landovan Donavan who
Saints n Winners wrote:Looks as if JOE COLE is going back to West Ham.oNE WEST HAM PLAYER WHO WOULD DO OK for SAINTS is VAZ TE.
I agree on Dawson at Spurs. Forget Lampard, he is still on the England scene and will set his sights a bit higher than us. I do think that Joe Cole is a possibility though. We need to be ruthless with our goalies though; Shelve Kelv and get Friedel in, then we will have 2 higher level experienced guys battling it for the shirt with a youngster learning off of them.
I believe is out of contract . Cole wouldn't have helped, too injury prone and inconsistent these days and look at how Everton use loans in January, lessons to be learnt.
sk8srsinking
says...
3:52pm Thu 3 Jan 13
hedge end bob
says...
4:02pm Thu 3 Jan 13
hedge end bob
says...
4:04pm Thu 3 Jan 13
NikkkoNik
says...
4:17pm Thu 3 Jan 13
SaintJD wrote:QPR have allot to do, but this win may give them hope, secondly Harry can go to the chairman and ask for a few more players, had they lost that game it might have been throwing more money and hope something sticks. They may start to build momentum. Perhaps they believe the 5 or 6 teams above them are vulnerable. Over Christmas Reading made 4 points, we mustard 3 good results and 1 poor one and came away with 3 dropping 12. This division is brutal and if we are in with a chance we have to go for it. Taking off Rameries was a poor decision, he had not played the game before at Stoke and who cares about the Chelsea game? You could argue the more games Chelsea play in the FA Cup, League cup and Europa league the better for us as they may put in weaker teams at the end of the season once they have secured a top four position. We have to get tougher and will need to find these 7 wins.
NikkkoNik wrote:Saying Nigel put in Boruc because he knew we'd be beaten is nonsense surely and, from what I heard of the QPR game they showed absolutely no desire to win the game, but happened to sneak a lucky win (deserved though on their effort and commitment) with a rare attack.
I would like to see two new players, Goalkeeper, proven PL experience, Jack is too young and similar to Gazza, so not likely to do anything this season. I think a strong holding midfielder like a Veria type. Cork and Spider have being OK, but they get bullied with stronger teams and if one was injured we would be stuffed. If we then had money to burn a new winger/striker with pace and ability and perhaps another defender. I still believe we are throwing away too many points regularly; goalkeeping is still a big concern. We should have played Borac earlier and decided if he was good enough, we wasted our time playing Kelvin again; he had already failed on many occasions at this level. If I was the manager asking for money for another goalkeeper, the board might say, you have not played the last one you got. I partially believe Nigel expected to get beat by Arsenal and Borac would have proven he is not capable at this level, instead, he may just need more games and he will get better. Secondly Nigel will have to raise his game in the second half; QPR raised the bar last night and instead of holding on for a draw with Arsenal, Nigel will have to go for the win. We will need an additional 7 wins to stay up. All the teams around us will strengthen and I know it sounds obvious, once January ends it will be too late.
If anything, the QPR result is proof that there are other ways of winning than going gung-ho - you can hold out for a draw, hang on in there and sneak a result on the break.
Obviously agree we need to strengthen and shore up the defence though - without silly individual mistakes from players who aren't up to it we would have got far more points on the board in the early part of the season, and against Stoke, when we brought one or two of them back in. Clearly need cover all across the back.
sotonman2012
says...
4:35pm Thu 3 Jan 13
ly we can add more depth & quality another striker is key capable of scoring 10+ goals a season we can't keep relying on Lambert.COYR
RedArmy1
says...
4:39pm Thu 3 Jan 13
This is not a rant - but I hope Nigel does not let down the fans and City of Southampton by fielding a weak side.
He has much to gain by challenging his players to WIN this tie and then go on to beat VILLA AWAY.
RED ARMY 2013. WE RULE THE SOUTH. COYR.
saintlysoul
says...
4:52pm Thu 3 Jan 13
hedge end bob wrote:Good point. Does anyone know what's wrong with Clyne or when he's due back?
saintlysoul wrote:Like te idea playing J W P , but whatwouldyou do with Clyne??. He has worked well with Puncheon so far and can defend.
I thought Jack Cork did well at right back against Arsenal. What trying this. Leave him at right back then play JWP as a holding / creative midfielder in front of the defence and Spider Ramirez and Davis in the middle. I thought jwpblooked lively when he came on against Arsenal he is composed and a good distributor of the ball moreover he's not frightened to get stuck in! Just a thought!!!
Beer Monster
says...
4:55pm Thu 3 Jan 13
RedArmy1
says...
5:12pm Thu 3 Jan 13
Beer Monster wrote:Boruc needs game time - that is for sure (and the goal keeping coaches need to challenge him with greater intensity)
NA has ruled out bringing in a goalie - stick with Boruc for Villa?
NIGEL IS NOT ALWAYS RIGHT.
He insisted that he would continue to play the same way up to 10 games into the Season and it almost cost him his job.
Saints have become more Defensive and WE are all proud of the way they battled against Arsenal.
HE IS NOT RIGHT ABOUT THE GOAL KEEPING SITUATION.
Getting a Top Quality Keeper gets you one quarter of the total of points needed to remain in the Premiership.
BUY A TOP KEEPER - Move up the Premier League.
Kelvin and Gazza have given away 8 points.
WE SHOULD BE ABOVE WET SPAM.
Think again Nigel - 10 Million is money in the bank to get in a Top Quality Keeper. Some things you cannot cut back on. This is one of them.
BUY !!! NIGEL IN THE JANUARY WINDOW.
I was at FULHAM AWAY and you cannot outscore goalkeeping mistakes.
Nigel - do not allow stubbornness to put your job in jeopardy again !!!
WE ARE SOUTHAMPTON. COYR.
SaintJD
says...
5:15pm Thu 3 Jan 13
Southampton manager Nigel Adkins plans to bring in new faces this month but has ruled out signing another goalkeeper.
Kelvin Davis, Paulo Gazzaniga and Artur Boruc have all started this season, with all three guilty of notable errors. However, Adkins, himself a former goalkeeper, has vowed to stand by them, ending talk of a move for Birmingham's Jack Butland or Blackburn's Paul Robinson.
"They are the three goalkeepers we've got now and I do not anticipate another goalkeeper coming in during this window," said Adkins.
SaintJD
says...
5:18pm Thu 3 Jan 13
up saints
says...
5:23pm Thu 3 Jan 13
batesieboy
says...
5:35pm Thu 3 Jan 13
Confucious wrote:Don't forget the ones who leave ten minutes before the final whistle. Presumably so their Mummy doesn't tell them off for being late home.
Nicola needs to get the marketing team to get some fresh blood in the stands. There are two in the row in front of me who are always groaning and moaning - and likely at least 2000 all told who are falling short. Weak support if fine for Div 1, but not for the dogfight that is the Prem. We need to step up the quality and move on.
Admittedly these people helped get us where we are, but we can't afford to be sentimental. They should now go to Bournemouth where they will be more useful.
We should at least offload all those who boo our own players or boo when the half or full time whistle goes when we are trailing or have lost.
Come on Nicola - get moving and sort 'em out.
batesieboy
says...
5:42pm Thu 3 Jan 13
SO50 Saint wrote:You say that...quite rightly...BUT how many three pointers have we managed to turn into one?? The last THREE matches, for a start....Of course we are capable of beating them...what worries me is that we have "beaten" teams but have not collected all the points!!
I really don't think we need too much to be brought in in order to stay up this season. I think a GK and CB and maybe a pacey winger on loan would do it. I really do think as has been said above that the home draws have cost us this season. For me apart from 5/6 teams the rest of the leage is a much of a muchness with everyone quite capable of beating everyone else. We just need to ensure that when the vital games Villa and Wigan away we pick up the 3 points. I also think we are more than capable of beating the likes of West Ham, Stoke and West Brom at home along with a few other mid table teams who are still to visit
starlitdragstar
says...
5:45pm Thu 3 Jan 13
RedArmy1
says...
5:51pm Thu 3 Jan 13
starlitdragstar wrote:Brad Friedel if available would be an option.
Brad Friedel is the only keeper I would consider worth getting, even on loan until the end of the season. Why does Boruc always looks as if he's been on the Wacky Baccy? and why isn't Gazza even getting on the bench, or is he still injured?
The TOP SIDES in the top half of the Premiership have excellent Keepers.
WE DON'T.
Singing "There's only one Nigel Adkins" is good - but too early in the game distracts the players - the Manager and the concentration of the Keeper.
Playing Arsenal - as we we were singing that - they scored.
WHEN WE ARE WINNING 3-0 OR HAVE WON A FAMOUS AWAY VICTORY - (Like QPR) Fair enough !!
THE LEAGUE DOES NOT LIE and we should be higher than where we are.
WE ARE SOUTHAMPTON. COYR.
SO50 Saint
says...
5:58pm Thu 3 Jan 13
What amazed me the last 2 games was walking out gutted we only got a point knowing we deserved more. The Fulham game I didnt go too but on the tele it certainly looked like we were the far better side
Clever Dick
says...
6:00pm Thu 3 Jan 13
batesieboy wrote:And don't forget the Guly moaners. I've got a guy near me who would give him stick if he missed a chance for his double hat trick. At least the Gaston Ramirez moaners mite now shut up too after the Ars game. Obvious quality and always has been. That's why we paid 12M for him. SUPPORT the TEAM!!
Confucious wrote:Don't forget the ones who leave ten minutes before the final whistle. Presumably so their Mummy doesn't tell them off for being late home.
Nicola needs to get the marketing team to get some fresh blood in the stands. There are two in the row in front of me who are always groaning and moaning - and likely at least 2000 all told who are falling short. Weak support if fine for Div 1, but not for the dogfight that is the Prem. We need to step up the quality and move on.
Admittedly these people helped get us where we are, but we can't afford to be sentimental. They should now go to Bournemouth where they will be more useful.
We should at least offload all those who boo our own players or boo when the half or full time whistle goes when we are trailing or have lost.
Come on Nicola - get moving and sort 'em out.
bigfella777
says...
6:01pm Thu 3 Jan 13
As long as Adkins is in charge and Guly is fit to start, why is there anything to worry about??
warrens 76
says...
8:32pm Thu 3 Jan 13
bigfella777 wrote:Is that you kent141
Look, it doesnt really matter who's in the squad or on the pitch. It also doesnt matter about all the quality players we have signed who all disappear into room 101 at St Marys never to be seen again until Cortese says so.
As long as Adkins is in charge and Guly is fit to start, why is there anything to worry about??
Tirau Dan
says...
9:13pm Thu 3 Jan 13
A window cleaner you would be
If you can see what I can see
When I'm cleanin' windows
Where's the banjo...
Xmas is over and Santa has gone back to the North Pole - no need for greedy Santa lists to go to SMS.
Que Sera Sera - COYR

OSPREYSAINT says...
10:58am Thu 3 Jan 13